I have a Xmas present – a Marmot Zeus down jacket that is a great jacket but I have the opportunity to swap it for a Montbell Down inner. Is it a good idea? The Marmot is just too warm for my locale….Any thoughts?
Topic
Jacket choice
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
They are roughly the same cost, The Zues is too warm for you (so won't get that much use?), the Montbell would be an appropriate warmth and maybe 1/2 the weight. What's the hold up unless the gift giver would know of the switch and be offended. I would make the switch in a heartbeat. Years ago I basically did this, except in my case it was going from a Patagonia Puff to a Montbell Thermawrap.
–Mark
I own both a marmot zeus and a montbell down inner parka. The zeus is a bit warmer, more along the lines of a MB alpine light, and has a higher denier fabric with a slightly better hand. The montbell down inner is much lighter and sufficiently warm to be used without a shell down to maybe 40F while around camp. Only drawback in switching to the montbell if the zeus is too warm is that it compresses too much to make a decent pillow.
I have owned both. The Zeus large was 16oz (listed on REI's website as 12oz) so I returned it. I also thought it was warmer than needed for three-season backpacking in my region and didn't compress very well when stuffed into its own pocket (although it would have made a great pillow). I think the Zeus could be worn winter camping with appropriate layering. It has more fill than the UL Inner series or the WM Flash/Flight series. It is probably more comparable to the heavier MB Alpine line.
I now use the MontBell UL Inner Parka. It does not have as much loft as the Zeus, but has a hood that warms me up very quickly. If I get too cold, I get in the sleeping bag. It packs down smaller than a Nalgene bottle, but does not make a good pillow.
If I had to pick a jacket to wear around town, I would pick the Zeus. You can usually get a fantastic deal. For 3-season backpacking, the MB is a great choice.
>If I had to pick a jacket to wear around town, I would pick the Zeus. You can usually get a fantastic deal. For 3-season backpacking, the MB is a great choice.
I agree. I own the Zeus and absolutely love it for these Wisconsin winters. It just might be a little overkill for 3-season use, and as others have posted, the MB is probably the way to go.
I'm about to swaparoonie :) Montbell here we come…. thanks all…
Become a member to post in the forums.

