Topic

Golite 2010 site up now take a look

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 26 through 37 (of 37 total)
Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 10:55 am

It would really be great if we had standard terminology for what is lightweight. For example (for a 2-person tent), the term "light" might be "less than 2 pounds per person." The term "ultralight" might be "less than 1 pound per person." Then "super ultralight" might be "less than a half pound per person."

As it is, I have seen 2-person tents advertised as ultralight, and they went 5 pounds!

A note to web site managers for equipment companies: if you don't list the weight of the product on the web site, I won't buy it. In many cases, they specifically don't list the weight of the product because it is bad heavy. To many of us, that is poison.

–B.G.–

Ben Smith BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 10:56 am

Yeah, back when I was using the Odyssey, I started to consider carrying a total of 35-40 lbs "light". Now that I have a baseweight of around 10lbs in the winter, I consider myself UL…

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 11:29 am

Would there be much argument to the statement that BPL is the premier Lightweight and UL community/website/authority in the world?

If not, I wonder what would happen if the good Dr. J and staff simply dictated those guidelines? Or let the community vote on what they should be.

Like Bob said, an ultralight tent weights X or less per person. A lightweight tent weighs X or less per person.

Same for base weight. Same for every piece of gear (at least the popular categories of gear. I'm not sure we'd need to dictate what qualifies as an ultralight toenail clipper).

What if we just did draw the line?
SuperUltraLight *is* <5lbs
Ultralight *is* 5-12
Lightweight *is* 12-22
Traditional *is* 22-35
Heavy *is* 35+

Or whatever the numbers may be.

What are some of the problems that would arise from setting the standards?

Edit: I do realize that it would't be like REI, Backcountry, Moosejaw, GoLite, etc. would simply conform to any set terminology. But we'd know where everything stands!

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 11:37 am

"What are some of the problems that would arise from setting the standards?"

Unfortunately, there's no central hierarchy to set uniform standards — like with many other sports associations and authorities.

Just to be contrarian… I could "argue" for drawing the lines at 'round numbers' for better convenience, like this:

SUL 0-5lbs.
UL – 5-10lbs
Light – 10-30lbs
Traditional – 30-50lbs
Heavy – 50+ lbs

Personal views aside, what's considered 'traditional weight' bags and tents today were "pretty darn light" back a few decades ago — and hopefully, we will continue to see improvements. So should lines be redrawn periodically? Makes sense to me, except that will also open up another can of worms.

But to me, the golden rule is simply this: YMMV. And the weight I am most interested in is my own 'comfort weight' — that weight at which I can hike all day, every day, without really feeling anything onerous on my shoulders. And that would be around 25lbs for me. Cutting much below that IMO returns mostly psychic benefits, not physiological. But of course, I recognize that psychic benefits can be a lot of fun to some.

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 4:18 pm

Here is a quote from wikipedia…it does a nice job describing the commonly accepted standards.

Paraphrased:
Light Weight < 20 lbs
Ultra Light Weight <10 lbs
Super Ultra Light Weight <5 lbs

Quote:
"Although no technical standards exist, the terms light and ultralight commonly refer to base pack weights below 20 pounds (9.1 kg) and 10 pounds (4.5 kg) respectively. Traditional backpacking often results in base pack weights above 30 pounds (14 kg), and sometimes up to 60 pounds (27 kg) or more. Extreme enthusiasts of ultralight backpacking sometimes attempt super-ultralight backpacking in which the base pack weight is below 5 pounds (2.3 kg)."

Ryan does refer to the following limits in "Lightweight Backpacking and Camping"…LW=12-20, UL=5-12, and SUL <5lbs. So there is a minor difference.

There is some great guidance in BPL/RJ's book as well as Lightedn Up as to individual gear piece weights that support different categories.

For example "Lighten Up" suggests 3 lbs or less for each of the big three…or 9 lbs or less. For ultralight the book suggests 1-2 lbs for each…get the big three to < 6 lbs. In Chapter 15 (the God chapter) of LW BP & Camping RJ suggests a max of 2-3 lbs for the big 3 total..i.e. trying to get each one to <1 lb each. So if you believe this…

A big three item (shelter, pack, or sleeping gear) would look like this…

LW < 3 lbs
UL < 2 lbs
SUL < 1 lb

So one could say any pack, tent/person, or bag weighing under 3 lbs could be termed light weight. To be consider UL weight it would have to be under 2 lbs and under 1 lb for SUL.

Just tossing this out for consideration.

Jamie

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 4:33 pm

Jamie:

Yours and mine are pretty much the same, except for just the first line — "light weight". I peg that at <=30.

Now, reading your wiki quote above, they peg light at 20 and traditional at above 30. Well, what do they call weights between 20 and 30? IMHO, I agree with wiki that trad starts at 30. And thus, light would start logically at below 30 — not at below 20.

Anyway, just thinking out loud — not that it's anything critical…

Travis L BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 4:36 pm

>Well, what do they call weights between 20 and 30?

GoLite's Target Group!!!!

Sorry, couldn't help myself.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 4:39 pm

'GoLite's Target Group!!!!"

Ding ding ding… you got it! Which goes right back to my earlier post — get off GoLite's back for not targeting UL hikers. :) (in jest)

Jamie Shortt BPL Member
PostedFeb 3, 2010 at 4:52 pm

Ben, I agree with you that it looks like they are going after the "Lightweight" group or the traditional group that can be swayed to lightweight. There are a lot more of them than us. Does that mean there gear is weighing more…yeah it sure look like it. Does it still fit in the lightweight category? yes I'd say it does.

What we are loosing is some great gear that also supports the UL & SUL categories. So yes I hate loosing items like the Reed pants (5 oz), Virga Jacket (8 oz), Wisp windshirt (3 oz), Jam2 (20 oz), and Ultra 20 quilt (19 oz)… but they are a business and they have choices to make.

Jamie

Robert Cowman BPL Member
PostedFeb 4, 2010 at 1:02 am

When i came up with this i didn't want to bash any weights or fabrics or Eco methods all I was taking about was it seems like they are dabbling in many different products and lines and it doesn't seem like they are really in keeping with any of its customers in all ground.(Except travel anything works for that.) I remember the Trig, Hut and the Featherlite sleeping bag those were transitional pieces that anyone whether UL, Lite or heavy could appreciate in their packs. Yes there is always lighter, but I mean those old prices and the feeling of that gear was awesome. My first pieces were the paradigm jacket and the Daze. They made me not even buy the products in the store that I worked at. And I got up to 75% off.

Now they are making main stream products and that's not what they're about. Golite is the truly Transitional company that anyone from any crowd can appreciate. I just don't want to see them turn all mainstream and attempt to believe that every customer is in their demographic, or that they need to go after every customer demographic.

(you ULers know who you are that have a Wisp/Ether wind shirt)

PostedFeb 4, 2010 at 1:51 am

I've said it before, but the 2010 GoLite Poncho Tarp is alive and significantly lighter than ever. This is a great piece of gear for the UL/SUL hiker. It's sad to lose others (ie. Reed pant) but some do exist and the new 800 fp Roan jacket looks great.

PostedFeb 4, 2010 at 4:35 pm

@Ben and Co.:

I am judging GoLite not based on any standards per se, or against anyone else. I am judging GoLite by what it once was. Think Ion/Jam^2/Pinnacle, the non-existence of Jardine-like packs. The weight increases from the shelters is also a little ridiculous.

And I concede the Poncho-tarp improvement, but will wait for reviews. 15 denier > 70D (or whatever it was).

Finally, I reiterate my argument that GoLite is making a business decision in a capitalist society.

Viewing 12 posts - 26 through 37 (of 37 total)
Loading...