Never used the GG.. I went from an ID Silshelter and Golite Lair 1 with and without water resistant bivy, then bought off gear trade here an older model Tarptent Rainbow. At 6 foot tall, 190 pounds plenty of room for pack, and at times, with my 130-140 pound Great Dane( dog), " Boo Boo", I am very pleased with the Rainbow. As another poster said, you can shave a few ounces. I generally use no more than 4-5 stakes, with a rock, or three. All this is pretty subjective, if me find what you want to try on gear forum, lot of tarps, tarptents come up for sale pretty regular. Good luck.
Topic
GG The One – Photos?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Hi Nathan,
I am 6ft and use a neo air in the one, I have no troubles sitting up or touching the roof. having the high point in the middle works well for me. There is room by my waist for pack food etc. It is suprisingly roomy for it's weight.
Eric,
The Moment looks like a piece of great engineering. But for me a SpinnTwinn provides almost twice as much floor space as the Moment including its vestible. The SpinnTwinn is so palatial, that with proper pitching a bivy is not needed. Weight with a ground sheet is around 12 oz versus 28.5 for the Moment. Plus I am sure the SpinnTwinn is subject to a lot less condensation.
I don't need bug protection. But for 8 oz, I could get a MLD net tent and not need the ground sheet, bringing the total weight in around 18 oz. For another 1/2 oz one could also get the silnlyon door in the net tent for some extra rain protection. For me, I don't see anthing that would work better. In wind, proper pitching is necessary. Maybe in heavy snow the Moment would be better.
So for me, a tarp just works better. It is just an option.
Nick,
Your posts are always well-written and informative. This thread, plus your other post responding to my query inre the MLD Pro Poncho for winter camping have pretty much talked me into an ~8'x10' tarp as an ideal shelter for every season but winter(for which I have a Duomid)
Now I'm trying to decide which 8'x10' tarp? You mention the Spinntwin. That seems just about hands down the best option, but for what I've heard of the 'noisiness' of spinnaker fabric.
Silnylon is an option as well but adds a couple ounces, and also stretches.
MLD's cuben grace duo has the size of the Spinntwin, and subtracts the noisiness of spinnaker and the stretching of silnylon, but costs by far the most.
What is your, and anyone else's opinion on the noise spinnaker makes? Is it merely solved with a tight pitch. I'm the kind of person who, while not a light sleeper, when a noise gets into my head, I can't tune it out, so this is a concern for me.
Thanks.
I don't have any experience with shelters made from spinnaker material, but I do have a lot of experience with spinnakers on boats. The new fabric is "crunchy" however, it doesn't take that much time before the fabric becomes much softer and less noisy.
However, I would get some feedback with someone with the SpinTwin just to make sure.
I second the SpinnTwinn. I have a Refuge-X at a similar weight, but I prefer the SpinnTwinn for its huge size and lack of condensation. I've been in some pretty nasty rain/wind storms with no bivvy and kept dry.
The noise is said to lessen with time. Either that's happening with mine or I'm getting used to it. Really, I think the fabric is less noisy than it used to be…I tight pitch really helps.
One trick is to pitch with the poles at a slight outward angle. If it needs tightening up, you can simply reach out and pull the pole towards you. Works like a charm.
Happy Trails :~)>
> With 'The One' — brushing up against the ceiling will be part of your camping experience
Depends on the person. I will admit that first night I had this experience (mostly getting in and out of the one), but then I got used to the space and had no problems.
I am 5'10" and use a 2.5" pad.
> the droopiness of it all bothered me enough to sell mine
that's what got me. I believe this years design is better
One can certainly do a flat tarp and a net tent… but I have typically found the net tents didn't provide as much bug free space as I wanted.
–Mark
Fred-
What poles are you using there?
I converted the gram to ounces at a total of about 21oz, does that sound about right?
I use a Gossamer Gear SpinnShelter with an Alpinlite Bug Tent 1.25 and have been happy with it. It ends up around 22-23oz with stakes and stuffsacks. I actually used it in 45mph winds a couple of weeks ago in the Smokies.
Jim,
Thank you for the compliment!!
Yes the material is noisy. Just picking it up you hear it crackle. But pitch it tight. It has never woken me up. Keep in mind that the SpinnTwinn has a catenary cut to reduce the amount of material, so it really has fewer pitching options than a flat tarp. Even though it adds a little weight, the line tensioners included with it work well.
I considered the Grace Duo, but it is slightly smaller than the SpinnTwinn (about 8% less surface area) and weighs 1.3 oz less. I wanted as much surface area as possible, so I could get by without using a bivy. Plus I just know I would damage the cuben :)
Nick,
I'm sure your Spinn Twinn 8'X10" tarp works great. I had a urethane coated 8"X10" tarp for a few years before I could afford a tent. While I never got wet I did get spindrift snow inside during some of the winter storms of NW Pennsylvania.
Anyway. I've found single wall tents worth a bit of extra weight – and where I backpack there ARE bugs, especially creepy/crawly desert bugs and mountain no-seeums and mosquitos, some with West Nile virus.
I expect a lighter version of the TT Moment will come out someday with a new wonder fabric, and I'd probably "have" to get one. Until then I'll get by with the silnylon version.
Hi all, great thread, great information.
Nick- 21oz is right for 600g. The poles are Ferrino Tibetans, now dead and replaced with Pacepoles, which are amazing.
Jim- glad you had a 'Eureka' moment with the net combo. I thought about some exotic fabrics, but went with silnylon for durability and longetivity and cost- if you are worried about sagging, just pitch the poles at an angle and to tighten, just pull them vertical. YMMV.
I thought about the SpinnTwinn, but went with the traditional 8×10 for more variety of pitching options, and the ability to pitch sides right to the ground. I like to be able to sit up in my shelters. I've used the SMD net in my ShangriLa 3 too, but have ordered a lighter bivy for above tree line use as bugs aren't such a problem above 2000m, and a bivy extends the range of my sleep system.
I like BIG shelters- room to move, plenty of views. Seems a contradiction to be in the great outdoors, trapped in a claustrophobic tent, especially when it is raining.
cheers,
fred
Here’s the pictures
More on my album
http://www.flickr.com/photos/vinla/sets/72157622354811678/
I am 5’10 and use a neo air in the one.
I have enough room for my pack, food, everything.
Lau – that is exactly what I was looking for, thank you. It seems that the headroom is adequate for you. Out of curiosity is that the 08' or the 09' version?
Yes,
the headroom is enough for me, and this is the 09 version.
And actually, like Ben said, when i lying down my face is a little bit close to the tent, but it is OK for me.
Become a member to post in the forums.


