Topic

Top Apparel – Outside Buyers Guide Winter 2010 | Outside Online

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
PostedFeb 2, 2010 at 12:23 pm

Generally, I find Outside reviews to be little more than marketing blurbs. They also tend to be geared for skiing, so I have little use for them.
The reviews of the few items of interest to me (Nanno puff) tell me almost nothing. I'd at least like actual weights… and some real numbers (fill weight, MVTR).

Also, since when is a down jacket a "baselayer" (Nau Down Shirt)?

I value the reviews done by the staff here (and some members) because they attempt to make comparisons to similar products and so give the buyer an idea of relative utility. I understand this takes time and more than a few days of use, but really, why would I listen to a review that has not truly tested the product?
-rant over, sorry

PostedFeb 2, 2010 at 1:33 pm

During my semester at NOLS several years ago, one of my instructors showed me an article in Outside Magazine about one of the NOLS courses. Apparently the writer of the article took the Baja Sea-Kayaking course, which, in the words of my instructor, “is one of the cushiest courses we have.” The writer griped and complained about not being allowed to bring booze on the course, and not having real toilets and showers. I only read the introduction, but from what I heard, it was an entertaining/annoying read depending on how you approached it.

I’ve never read Outside because I just assumed it’s geared towards the people who, like the person who wrote that article, were more interested in a guided vacation. Granted, I only read the first couple paragraphs of the article and it was several years ago, so I can’t say I have a perfect memory of it.

Now. Back to the Buyer’s Guide… I get a kick out of a few of the pictures they have, like the OR Ethos and the Rab Microlight Alpine EVent. Looks like they just tossed the jackets on the floor and took a photo :)

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Loading...