Hi. I'm very late to this party, but having read everything I can about the Coleman Xtreme stoves I am faced with a dilemma. Should I buy a used Xtreme while I still can and a rebuild kit if I can find it or another stove to cannibalize for parts? Coleman's inventory of parts for the Xpedition, Xtreme, and Xpert are equally zilch. The Powermax canister situation is iffy at best, and the non Powermax cartridge adapter looks heavy . The Fyrestorm cartridge stand has a different hose derived from the Apex line. So if i want to live with obsolete equipment why not go way back to the Coleman Alpine Stove, the precursor to all of this. The fuel line looks heavy , but everything else looks good. Can it be used inverted? Reviews mention that it has a pressure compensating valve similar to the Japanese stove which ran afoul of Roger Caffin's tests for CO emissions so I'm wondering if it is potentially dangerous for tent cooking. Can anyone here please comment on these options. Here is a review of this stove
http://v-g.me.uk/GearTech/GearTech-Equipment-ColemanAlpineRV.htm
Topic
Coleman Post Xtreme strategies
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Hi John
First of all, I have to point out that Coleman are committed to keeping the Powermax canister on the market for the foreseeable future. Actually finding them near where you are is of course a different matter. USA should be fine, other countries … not so easy (contact local Coleman office).
The Coleman Alpine is very much an older generation. The pressure regulator on it was an interesting idea, but not all that useful in the field. So it died. I doubt it can be used with an inverted canister with that regulator though.
The point about the Xtreme is that it uses a liquid feed rather than a gas feed like the Alpine. This is what you need for winter. We treat it as the Gold Standard. Obsolete be damned! The Fyrestorm is a suitable replacement if you can't get the Powermax canisters near you. Both are very good stoves.
The Powermax adapter … sigh. Too heavy.
Should you buy an Xtreme and give it TLC? If you can get the Powermax canisters, I would say yes. I own two myself!
Cheers
Thanks for your comments Roger . I recently turned up 2 of the Coleman Alpines online , one of which is brand new so I thought it was worth asking . I will get an Xtreme and in the meantime plan on a Snowpeak Giga on the Bruton stand with your copper heat transfer set-up, using the Snowpeak on a canister for summer. Can you advise me on what spare parts I should seek out for both of these stoves to keep on hand , especially in the field? I've read your maintenance articles and all the CO articles as well , and I'm looking forward to the test results on pot diameter. Ironically , I can't yet find Powermax canisters in Portland OR despite a very good Coleman service center here at Ollie Damon. Snowpeak's plant is within short driving distance as well but it is still unclear if they deal repair parts out of it. I've been cooking on an Optimus 99 since the 70's.
Hi John
Well, we gave up on our Optimus 8R some (considerable!) time ago, but it worked well in those days… :-)
The Snowpeak Giga on a Brunton stove stand is actually quite a good combo. I like it.
Spare parts for this combo. Hum … well there is a BS011 O-ring making the crucial seal on each of the connections. I would carry a couple of those in a tiny ziplok. There is a smaller O-ring on each of the needle valves, but they are not really exposed. Not sure what size they are though – and they may be metric or imperial. Along with the O-rings I would certainly carry one of those tiny tubes of silicone grease which come with some stoves. I think they can be bought as well.
I would carry a small spanner to fit the jet so I could remove it for cleaning. How small is up to you! And I would find some very fine spring wire for cleaning the jet too. Do *NOT* try to use anything larger than the jet hole though!
We have an article on essential stove maintenance:
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/essential_stove_maintenance.html
I do recommend reading it.
Hassle Coleman as hard as is needed for the Powermax!
Cheers
Become a member to post in the forums.

