Just wondering how many out there still have them and use them! I'm in the market to buy a new filter and I really like the thought of no pumping!
Not alot of info on here, I see sawyer has a simlar model anybody use that?
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
Just wondering how many out there still have them and use them! I'm in the market to buy a new filter and I really like the thought of no pumping!
Not alot of info on here, I see sawyer has a simlar model anybody use that?
Dan,
Use the site's search or use google's site-specific search feature (advanced search features). You'll find LOTS of discussion on this site re: both gravity systems and sawyer filters.
yes not alot on the clean stream, And I find it information overload wit h the sawyer threads! couldn't find anything on the sawyer verison of the platypus…
I used a clean stream for the last couple of months on the pct after getting giardia for the second time. Yeah it takes me a while to learn my lessons.
It worked fine. I would back flush a little after each use and run some water with a little bleach through every couple of weeks, as it says in the instructions.
I did not use the whole system as a hate the big zip platypus sold with the system. I used normal platy bottles with the quick connect links sold separately. Just pop of the drink tube, attach the dirty bottle, wait 3-4 minutes while enjoying a snack and I was good to go. Definitely the system I will use going forward.
Dan,
I have been using the Sawyer Filter as a gravity filter using the Platypus 4 L Water tank and my 1.8 L Platypus Hoser hydration system at the clean water catch bag.
From what I can tell, the Clean stream and the Sawyer use the same hollow fiber technology.
From the little that I looked at the Clean stream is that the two water bags on it are kinda heavy….kinda heavy as a whole system.
For me, using the water tank and the hoser, they are things that I would bring with me anyway, no mater what method of water treatment I would be using, so my weight penalty for using a filter is the 2.5-3.0 oz for the sawyer filter and the attachment to connect it to the dirty water bag.
If you have been the User Review section of the forum, I have a very detailed review of what I am using with photographs to show what works for me.
That said, I have been using the Sawyer filter for about 3 years now without illness or failure.
I have backwashed the filter in the field too.
Anyway, hope that this helps.
Sorry that I don't have any direct experience with the Clean Stream….I kinda had to make one myself before they came out with the Clean Stream.
With a lifetime guarantee on the Sawyer filter, I doubt I will ever need anything else.
-Tony
Thanks guys using that I made up my mind! I went with the clean stream because the backflushing seemed really dummy proof and since i already was carrying the platy 4L water tank with my katadin I will still end up with a few less oz's.
again thanks for the replies
Hi Tony
Glad to hear you're still using your Sawyer.
This past summer I did a Colorado trip using the Sawyer filter and the dirty bag from the Platy Clean Stream system. It worked great, lighter and more convenient than any system I've used in the past. I don't have any pics at the moment to share, but basically you buy the replacement reservoir kit by Platy:
http://www.amazon.com/Platypus-Clean-Stream-Replacement-Reservoirs/dp/B001IV8I9U
REI used to sell it, not sure if they do now. You ditch the "clean" bag. Use your primary drinking system bag–mine is a Platy Hoser 3L bag.
You also need this:
http://www.amazon.com/Platypus-Clean-Stream-Replacement-Hose/dp/B001HAJ4DG
Now get a good length of tubing to hang down from the dirty bag and connect it to your Sawyer inline filter:
http://www.rei.com/product/778041
Now hang your dirty bag by the convenient handles on a tree. The beauty of this system is the quick disconnect on the dirty bag. You pop a button and the flow stops when you want to switch clean bags to refill. Also it's nice if you want to wash your hands or fill a pot. It's like having a faucet in camp.
Weight of my system is:
Platypus Clean Stream "dirty" bag w/ male barb = 3.03 oz
Dirty tubing + Sawyer filter + clean attachment (everything but dirty bladder)= 4.09 oz
Total weight = 7.12 oz
I challenge someone to find a better system (at least for hiking with a partner).
The dirty bag gives you 4L capability so you can ferret water from stream to camp. The handles are on the top where they should be so carrying the water is easy. The faucet is on the bottom where it should be. No more "jerry rigging."
Become a member to post in the forums.