What is the difference between the Microlite XP and the Gore Windstopper fabric on the Western Mountaineering bags? Is there a good reason one should not get the Gore Windstopper?
Topic
Differences in Western Mountaineering fabrics?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Mircolite is a high thread count polyester microfiber. Lighter weight than most other microfiber fabrics due to having smaller thread. It has a very high thread count (# threads per inch of fabric) and is tightly woven. The tight weave and hydrophobic yarn gives it its water resistance, and tight weave makes it wind resistant as well. Being non coated it is breathable.
The gore fabric is a lightweight nylon with a proprietary gore teflon like laminate. With the laminate the fabric itself is windproof and nearly waterproof, but as with all gore tex breathability suffers and condensation can build reducing loft. The fabric is also heavy as sleeping bag shell fabrics go. One supposed advantage, due to its water resistance it that you shouldn't need a bivy to protect from splashback if tarp camping in the rain, and are less susceptible to wetting from condensation in single walled tents.
All that said, I have a WM Apache with the gore fabric and would do the bag again but not the gore. For my use the extra weight and the internal condensation outweigh the other benefits. I was thinking advantage when tarp camping, but in the Sierra and in the southwest the number of nights where it rains are minimal so there really isn't a need for the gore tex. I fell for the marketing…but I won't again. Steve
If I may add to the OP's question… what about the extremelite fabric? I've been told it's actually Pertex Quantum, which on other bags is consisted the best fabric in the business with great lightweight DWR. However, there are so many reports that Extremelite's DWR is all but useless and it wets out instantly. What gives? I know WM calendars it first, perhaps this affects the DWR? If so, why are they calendaring both sides for down proofness when other manufacturer get by just fine without calendaring it?I really want a Versalite, but in real Quantum. Much rather one or two feathers get through than a bunch of condensed water vapour. It really looks like WM made a poor decision with this fabric.
WM has changed the Etremelite fabric a few times through the years. I have an Ultralite and a Summerlite that both use the "etremelite" fabric but obviously have different shells. They did use Pertex at one time, but have heard they recently switched to a different fabric for the extremelite series. I don't know if that is a good thing or a bad thing.
Like Bradford says, extremelite fabric has changed several times over the decades. I don't know what they are currently using, but it's not Quantum. I wouldn't worry about it though, as my Quantum covered WM bag has leaked more feathers than any of the other Extremelite fabrics they've used, and the Quantum is disappointingly lacking in the DWR department IMHO. Most likely has something to do with why they are no longer using it…?
Become a member to post in the forums.

