Topic

TT Moment vs. SMD Gatewood & Serentity combo

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Dennis Park BPL Member
PostedJan 31, 2010 at 9:07 am

Can you guys give pros/cons to help in my comparison between the TT Moment vs. SMD Gatewood Cape WITH Serenity net tent?

Thanks.

Follow up question: Any other tarp/inner net combos that I should consider?

PostedJan 31, 2010 at 10:43 am

On the face of it this is a REAL "apples and oranges" comparison. But here goes-

I had a TT Contrail, used it for 3 summers and liked it. When the Moment came out I sold the Contrail B/C I wanted a more wind-worthy tent.

The Moment is that and much more.

At a few oz. more than the Contrail you get:
1. a VERY taut canopy
2. more useable headroom
3. larger vestibule (for your pack AND cooking)
4. faster setup
5. lots of nice amenities and details

Just from photos I'd say the Gatewood cape is much smaller than the Moment (albeit lighter). But W/the added groundcloth, netting, etc. I'm thinking the weight advantage would go away and the set-up fuss factor would rise. That's something I don't want at the end of a long, hard day on the trail.

Eric

PostedJan 31, 2010 at 11:00 am

I'm in a similar situation for my Appalachian Trail thru-hike attempt starting in just under a month. I used a TT Contrail as my tent for the PCT and like it a lot, but had decided to go with a Gatewood Cape for the AT. Start with the GC and a light (not fully waterproof) bivy, switch that for the net tent when the weather warms up.

So in some experimentation in my back yard, I modified this plan; I'll still start with the Gatewood Cape and light bivy, but once it warms up I'll accept an 11 oz weight penalty to switch to the Contrail plus a separate poncho.

The deciding factor for me is how much, much more room and associated "spread out and relax" comfort I have in the Contrail. The Serenity net tent for the GC will work, but I have to lay still "just so" to ensure that no part of the bug netting is touching my body. I can sit up inside it (an important factor for me), but not in a way that ensures bugs couldn't bite through the netting when they're most voracious. One or two additional attachment points to pull the net tent out to the tent wall would certainly help there but … 600+ miles into the trip I'll certainly be strong enough to accept an 11 oz weight hit for a much more relaxed "in-tent" experience.

Note that how this trade-off works for you will depend on a lot of factors, like how tall you are, how bad you anticipate the bugs being on your hikes, how you prioritize weight carried vs. "space to spread out" in a bug-free zone, etc. I'm not saying the Gatewood Cape isn't a great piece of gear, it's just a matter of trading off when and where the right situations are for its use.

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedJan 31, 2010 at 11:21 am

I really like the tarp nettent combo. For me this is about flexibility. Most of my backpacking is in california where rain is often not much of a concern. The ability to use the net tent on its own for bug protection and beautiful night sky views is what sold me. I only need to setup the tarp if

I have the gatewood + serenity combo but have since switched to a cuben tarp plus MLD serenity nettent combo. This weighs in at 12 oz for both and is hard to beat. Alpinlite gear also has what looks like a very nice tarp and nettent combo.

I got a gatewood because I was worried about the lack of protection of a standard a-frame tarp. By using it I learned how little rain makes it through the gaps around a tarp and how the few drops that did get through got stopped by the netting. This made me realize that the extra coverage and weight of the gatewood was not really necessary for 3 season use.

Others to look at are the hexamid by Zpacks (http://www.zpacks.com/shelter/hexamid.shtml). I hear zpacks may be coming out with a separate net tent for the tarp only model which could be a very nice choice. That would be similar but lighter than the gatewood. On the other end of the space spectrum the six moon designs vamp and nettent looks very nice and will be available in march.

One note is that at 5'7" I find the gatewood too long and flappy to be useful as a poncho and carry separate rain gear when I use it.

PostedFeb 1, 2010 at 5:46 am

"I find the gatewood too long and flappy to be useful as a poncho and carry separate rain gear when I use it." I would agree with Nia and add that I found ponchos have no sleeves so when using poles the rain goes right down the arm and into clothes. One also has to remove tie-out lines or they dangle around when wearing the poncho. Adding a belt to a poncho alos helps control flapping. BTW The Golite poncho/tarp has snaps to shorten it when used as a poncho

Really liking the Gatewood as a shelter, however, I switched to the similar SMD Wild Oasis for bug protection. Somewhere there is a thread about a method of adding netting to a Gatewwod Cape.

Read the post above entitled "PCT Sleep System" Note the link to Alpinlitegear and the choice of net tents and poncho shelters.

Gatewood users should know about Grandma Gatewwod:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grandma_Gatewood

quote from the above site:
Gatewood hiked the Appalachian Trail in 1955 at the age of 67, wearing Keds sneakers and carrying an army blanket, a raincoat, and a plastic shower curtain which she carried in a homemade bag slung over one shoulder, thus making her a pioneer of Ultralight backpacking.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...