Topic

Would love to hear from Scarp1 users!

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
PostedJan 30, 2010 at 6:20 pm

I'm in need of a new tent which has some characteristics that my current tent doesn't have. I've been using a tarptent cloudburst since the spring of 2004, and I've loved many things about it, especially the space to weight ratio.

One thing it can not do though, is free-stand. There have been a few times when the ground is frozen or mostly rock, and it's been impossible to get the stakes in. Other times I've wanted to camp on a peak or a rock slab with no soil to hold stakes. Other times the space I have to set up is too small since the cloudburst's guy lines come out very far from the footprint of the tent itself.

Basically what I need is a lightweight tent that I can take to a mountain peak, or onto a glacier, or the beak of half dome, or anywhere else, and be able to set it up with no stakes (with weight inside to keep it from blowing away). Winds can be strong in these places, so something like the tarptent moment with the long pole probably would not be a robust enough freestanding design without being thoroughly staked also.

I am tempted to get a Black Diamond FirstLight because it has a small footprint and it's very much frestanding, and I could just put heavy things in the interior corners and have it work on a rock slab with no need for stakes. It's not water proof though! That's like the most basic requirement for a tent!

What I need to know is if the scarp1 is a reliable freestanding tent with the cross-poles. I saw the picture on henry's site of it being held in the air, so I know it holds its shape, but since the floor is a separate piece from the outer corners where the poles connect, putting heavy things on the inside corners wouldn't help hold the thing down in high winds when it's not staked. In most cases I could tie the exterior corners to rocks to hold it down, but it can't be guaranteed that there would be anything to tie the corners to in some places I have in mind. Its footprint is a bit bigger than I would like, but that's a smaller trade off than the lack of waterproofness of the black diamond.

This has been a pretty long winded post, but I just wanted to get across how demanding I want to be on the freestanding feature of my next tent. So if you have a scarp1 please let me know if it will work for me or not. Thank you in advance for your input!

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
Loading...