Topic

GG Lighttrek 4 or Titanium Goat Adjustable Poles

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 10:26 pm

So after admiring Mark's super light GG adjustable Lightrek poles on the BPL Pt Reyes trip last weekend, I decided this is another area worth lightening up. We currently use very durable but much heavier Leki Super Makalu Poles.

I prefer a wrist strap, especially for winter, and I understand both are available with wrist straps now.

What's the difference between the two?

Which do you prefer and why?

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 11:33 am

The GGs have nicer grips, and thicker, more robust feeling CF poles, with the bottom section wrapped in CF tape. The TG poles do not have this wrapping, and have narrower cross sections poles. The GG poles are stiffer. The straps on the TG poles attach at the top, the straps on the GG at the bottom of the grip. The GG straps are intended just to keep the poles from falling to the ground rather than using them as propulsion. I found the TG straps too thin to be comfortable when used as propulsion…

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:05 pm

Actually I believe the gg straps also mount at the top. I haven't used them but from the description they sound very similar to the TiGoat ones. From the website:

"The strap is 3/4 webbing mounted to the top of the grip and can easily be removed."

+1 on everything else Lynn said. After using both I prefer the GG for the better (for me) grip, thicker pole, and larger locking mechanism.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:11 pm

Used both and choose the Lighttrek 4s for the the reasons listed by Lynn.

–Mark

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:14 pm

Thought I'd prefer the GG – thanks for the very helpful feedback.

Only one question – no problems with tip breakage? On aluminum poles my wife had Leki tips disengage twice where without disengagement or with a brittle pole there would have been a break.

Now have to wait until back in stock and we sell a few items in the next few weeks.

PostedJan 27, 2010 at 12:49 pm

We've had no problems yet with tip breakage on either brand of CF poles.

Now I see GG offers a strapped version of the poles, if that's your thing, but I've never felt a need for straps on my light poles.

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 1:03 pm

"Only one question – no problems with tip breakage?"

I've got 1700 miles on mine and no problem or even noticeable wear on the tips. I think the carbon poles are much more likely to be the weak link.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 1:14 pm

I meant breakage at the ends of the carbon poles, not of the removable Leki-style tips.

PostedFeb 2, 2010 at 6:00 am

I had an earlier version of the GG pole and one tip broke off, not just the metal tip, but the whole unit holding the tip. The pole itself did not break, so the tip could be replaced. The whole system has been improved, so don't worry! In fact the tip end is compatible, if not the same as Leki tips and could be replaced, if necessary. Either from GG or Leki. Both Leki and GG have excellent customer service.

The straps on the GG are attached with a removable unit and can indeed be used just like the wrist strap on a ski pole.

The grips are different. The GG Is a more traditional shape, with "finger curves" much like a ski pole and it's cork. Similar to the foam grip on BPL Stix. The TG grip is tapered, shorter, smooth foam, smaller diameter. Different feels, but both comfortable. Both have close ups views at the websites.
(Avoid poles with plastic grips if you plan to use them in winter. Plastic is very slippery when cold making them harder to grip)

Although the TG is a thinner pole, it has a similar flex to the thicker GG. In other words if the tips are placed on the ground and the poles held at at angle with one hand and the other hand flexes or bends the poles in the middle, one does not appear to be any different than the other. This is only a feel test, however, not scientific. By this "tests"both have more flex than the stiffer a one piece BPL Stix. (Length of each = 120)

Because the GG is a thicker pole it appears stronger, but I do not know if it is.

I did shatter a TG pole, but I have also bent Leki poles. Both companies have replacement sections available. Since Leki has a lifetime guarantee, the replacement is free. TG has a nominal charge.

The TG shattered because I was pushing myself up of the ground with it, lost my balance and fell over on it with the tip end wedged between a stone. Totally a dumb move on my part, but hey, I was tired.

FYI The adjustment fitting on the TG pole was quite slippery in the beginning. I kept having to pull it almost all the way out, tighten it just enough so I could get it back in, then slowly slip it all the way in to the desired adjustment. While giving a demo to n interested Ranger along the JMT, I loosened the pole all the way off with the inner adjustment piece lost within the pole. I had an nearly impossible time getting the pole screwed back in. Later talking with TG, they offered an easy solution.
There is a little cap at the top of the pole (my poles do not have straps) that is removable. Just take it off and with one hearty puff the inner gismo pops out the end.
The tip unit on the end of the TG pole does not appear to be a Leki part, but the actual metal tip shows zero wear after the JMT thru-hike, but that trail has more dust than rock!

I really cannot say that one is better than the other. They are different in the way they feel mainly because of the grips.

For traveling by plane, I put the poles in a map or mailing tube available at the Post Office, UPS stores, or Staples. The take them as carry-ons. They fit in overhead bins.

.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedFeb 2, 2010 at 9:57 am

Thanks Frank that was a very helpful overview. I think the adjustable GG LT4 with straps will work best for us. Selling some gear to pay for them in time for Grant's next batch.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...