Topic

Help Me Find My Next Rain Jacket

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 4:04 pm

I currently own two rain jackets and would like to replace them both:

1. Driducks — love its high breathability and 5 oz. weight. Wish it could look better and be more durable.

2. MontBell Peak — love its very high breathability and good looks — wish it weighs 5-6 oz. instead of 11.

So, can folks recommend a wp/b jacket that satsifies the following requirements:

1. excellent breathability
2. pit zips
3. 5-6 oz. for medium (NO heavier)
4. hideaway hood a plus (but not required)
5. nice looking

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 4:12 pm

Ben I don't know if a rain jacket exists that meets those requirements. The Marmot Essence is probably the closest at 6.4oz for a medium and underarm vents instead of true pit zips. If you do find what you are looking for please let us know.

CW BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 4:18 pm

Yes, do tell if you find such a Unicorn. :-)

. . BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 4:44 pm

Ben,

You did not explicitly list "waterproof" as a requirement, so perhaps your quest is within grasp. However, since you said "wp/b" I conclude that this feature is acronymically above speculative implication. "Nice looking" is of course heavily in tandem with precise fit, but I do hope that this cryptozoological anomaly rears it's handsome holy-grail of a head for all of us.

My current Jacket weighs 12 oz. and is by Merrel. It could certainly be improved, but I love the Polyester face fabric, which is inherently hydrophobic and appears more abrasion resistant than nylon.

So if this thread, with some subtle coaxing, somehow turns into a semi-comprehensive list of attributes for the ideal UL rain jacket, then I would add:

– Polyester face fabric w/ eVent or Nano technology DWR
– stretchy
– one waterproof (not breathable) chest pocket (?)
– interior mesh pocket
– adjustable volume helmet compatible hood
– I would accept 7 oz.
– availible in neon 80's ski colors for style + visibility

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 5:18 pm

Brad (or anyone who knows) – I recall vaguely Marmot coming out this year with an improved version of Essence — maybe with a different model name? Also, how does the TNF DIAD compare?

Greg — I would like something more breathable than Goretex, but I suppose I could settle for Goretex as a minimum breathability requirement.

Aaron — SHAMELESS thread hijack! You would do the Somalians proud. :)

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 5:39 pm

Hi, Ben- Marmot has the Mica, a 7-oz WPB hooded jacket, but no pit zips. IIRC the TNF Triumph (?) anorak is ~5.5 oz, again no pitzips. I think the DIAD is ~7.5. I liked the OR Zealot at ~7.5 oz in Gore Paclite (again no pitzips), but it's no longer made. Similarly, I have a GoLite paclite jacket from last season that I've been pretty happy w/, but it's around 9 oz. Of all these, I believe that the Paclites would have the most breathability, but I've heard good things about the Mica jackets.

I'm intrigued by the Rab On-Demand pull-over anorak, eVent, hooded… but 10 oz.

I haven't seen anything new in the 5-6oz range coming out for spring, although I have kinda been looking for the lightest shells. Definitely haven't seen anything w/zips… but there was a great MYOG "tutorial" on installing your own pit zips!

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 5:44 pm

The Marmot Essence and similar Marmot Micra use the new Membrane Strata that is new for 2009. The older Essence used Precip Plus.

Specs on the Membrane Strata are very good, much better than the Precip.

from the website:

Marmot’s own lightweight waterproof / breathable technology. A lamination technology that rates a whopping 20,000mm in waterproof performance and 20,000 gr in breathability. Requiring neither lining nor 3-layer construction like many similar lamination processes, MemBrain® Strata™ products are by far the lightest, most breathable garments in their categories.

Marmot’s proprietary 2.5 layer MemBrain® Strata uses micro non-organic particles on the inside of the lamination to increase durability and provide a dry touch instead of that clammy feeling you get from some other products.

The back print pattern is carefully designed to achieve the maximum durability and breathability. Abrasion tests rate 4-5 times better than regular MemBrain® (which is why regular MemBrain, as well as all 2-layer laminates require a separate lining).

Compared to 2.5 layer coatings in the market, our 2.5 layer lamination is about 100% more breathable. In addition, laminated stretch fabrics stretch more and have a softer hand than 2.5 layer coated fabrics.

PostedJan 26, 2010 at 5:53 pm

The TNF DIAD meets most of your criteria, although it is an ounce or two heavier.

I'm not sure about availability anymore, although it's listed on TNF's site.

I have both a DIAD and a Triumph anorak. The anorak is an especially nice garment, if you can live with a pullover. It's a little over 5 ounces, and can be balled up into a very small space. My rain and/or high wind shell package almost disappears in my pack, it being the anorak and a pair of 4 oz Montane Featherlite pants.

The DIAD gets used a little more casually; it's not my first choice for UL backpacking, but I did use it a lot in Australia during their winter, including in marine situations, and it was great. Very unobtrusive in use.

PostedJan 26, 2010 at 5:53 pm

1. excellent breathability
2. pit zips
3. 5-6 oz. for medium (NO heavier)
4. hideaway hood a plus (but not required)
5. nice looking

If it were me I would stick with the DriDucks and add my own pitzips. I think it's the only way you will get pitzips under 6oz. They are cheap enough that you can just buy a lot of them and not worry too much about durability. As for looks, well you just have to get used to the DriDuck look. I think they're nice looking, but only because I see their inner beauty ;)

CW BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 6:04 pm

DIAD is not on part with the Peak, eVent, etc. I can't use it during warmer months and just get wet from the rain rather than sweat.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 6:04 pm

Thanks, guys!

The new Marmot Essence looks really good. I am looking for something that can be worn for both town and trail. To me, Driducks are like Crocs — fantastic on trails but not in town.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 9:31 am

The 2010 Mica sounds very interesting, especially if it has pit zips and keeps the adjustable cuffs at 7oz.

I agonized over the 2009 Essence and Mica, and ultimately chose the Essence because of the "core vents". I imagine that many customers had a hard time deciding between the two since they were so similar. For some reason, they never published the weight of the Essence on their website. I think its a great jacket and I really like the Membrane Strata fabric.

If the new Mica is as you describe, my Essence may find itself on the Gear Swap forum!

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 10:34 am

Whoops! Looks like I got excited and misread your previous post. Thanks for correcting me.

It sounds like Marmot is moving in the right direction. The Super Mica is tempting but not at that price point.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 10:54 am

Does Anna work for Marmot and if so does she know the torso length of the new Micas? What is the pocket situation on the new Micas?

I have a Diad that I am selling off if you want to try it Ben.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 28, 2010 at 10:58 am

"I have a Diad that I am selling off if you want to try it Ben."

Brett – I wear a medium. You're an XL or something, no?

In any case, I think I will go with the new Marmot Mica. Thanks, everyone!

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 11:07 am

I agree with Lynn: You can buy 9 DryDucks sets (top and bottom) for the cost of one Mica. I've never felt the need for pit zips and I use mine for bug protection at rest stops in warm weather – when I've been sweating – and dried out with the jacket and pants on and closed up.

You probably won't need 9 of them, though. They are much more durable than expected. One jacket lasted me an entire AT thruhike being used as rain, bug and wind protection and then lived through several trail building projects. It got retired for general funkyness rather than losss of functionality. I never could get the thruhiker stink out.

PostedJan 28, 2010 at 11:10 am

It was more if you wanted to see how one acted but that is okay. I found that I really don't need a Rain jacket around town because of all the in and out and trees. Instead I just use my wind jacket made out of Momentum. The stuff is pretty close to waterproof and takes a good deal to wet out while still being breathable.

And that is odd that backcountrygear has it up when Marmot doesn't. That green color can only be loved my John Deere farmers.

And the possibility of XXL

Nope, Super is XXl and regular is XL with the super being made out of Membrane and the regular Strata

. . BPL Member
PostedJan 28, 2010 at 9:01 pm

Ben,

I'm looking forward to how you end up liking that jacket. Please do report back. Thanks!

And as for the hijack – I always start with, "Hi Jack" – whether or not there is one on the thread, in order to keep it subtle ;)

By the way, can you post or PM me a link to any photos or words from your trip? Thanks again!

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
Loading...