Topic

Clothing Layers – Need some help please

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Hans Dampf BPL Member
PostedJan 24, 2010 at 11:28 am

Hi there,

I'm currently revamping my wardrobe completely, and want to do this as good as possible, regarding breathability and weight.

I've read the interesting articles at:
http://www.verber.com/mark/outdoors/gear/clothing.html and http://www.psychovertical.com/?cuthecrap and I'd like to include this a little bit.

I want to test this in June, on an iceland trip.
First I thought about the following layers (for when I'm walking):

– underwear/insulation (merino)
– softshell (Rab VR Trail Shmock)
– rain shell (if it gets worse) Rab Momentum Jacket

Since Rab VR sounds very convincing. However, then someone also suggested this method because a softshell is just a little of both worls and nothing real:

– underwear (merino)
and on top, either:
– windshirt or
– rain shell (3-layer)

I'm a little helpless now, because I'm not sure what to look for (hiking/trekking) so I'd really like to get some input on the above methods.

For the camp I'm taking a Primaloft Jacket with me.

Can anyone help a little?
Thanks in advance,
Christoph

A Wilson BPL Member
PostedJan 24, 2010 at 12:39 pm

I'll admit I have no experience with softshells; I'm always tempted, and I always conclude that a base layer with a windbreaker over top = softshell at a much cheaper price.

On the other hand, Iceland may the place for them. It's blustery, cool such that you might never take a softshell off. If you never have to carry it, that's when I'd wear a softshell.

victor larivee BPL Member
PostedJan 24, 2010 at 2:10 pm

For the shoulder seasons my set is,lite mernio wool t-shirt, patagonia R1 hoody and a windshirt with a hood (if rain in he forcast I also bring a rain coat). I prefer the R1 and windshirt apose to a soft shell because is allows different set ups.
T shirt, R1, windshirt = cold, windy, damp (not raining)
T shirt/ windshirt =cool and windy
T shirt/ R1= cool no wind

love the hoods. Even in the winter I will hike with t shirt and windshirt and just the windshirt hood on my head and it keeps me warm.

Hans Dampf BPL Member
PostedJan 24, 2010 at 2:20 pm

I'll be there for three weeks

The thing is, I just cannot decide what kind of things to use/buy as my new stuff.

I'll probably take the Rab Momentum with me, and merino underwear…

But I don't know where the softshell would fit in, if it does or if it's better to just use a normal mid layer.

PostedJan 25, 2010 at 5:53 am

Iceland is the typical place where you may regularly need some more insulation than the base layer while hiking even in the summer but I wouldn't take a soft shell for the long distance: too specific, too heavy and not versatile enough. You can achive similar functionality for less weight and more wear options with a base layer, light fleece and windshirt (plus rain shell for the rain and lofty insulation for camp and stops). A light fleece in pullover style weights similar to a base layer and it's perfect active wear insulation.

Adrian B BPL Member
PostedJan 25, 2010 at 11:20 am

>If you never have to carry it, that's when I'd wear a softshell.

Even wearing it you still have to carry the weight.

If you're not sure about a softshell, I'd skip it – they're generally expensive and heavy, especially the stretch woven ones. As an earlier poster said, you can get the precisely result with a thin fleece/baselayer + a windshirt – thats all the Rab VR gear is, for example. Perhaps in consistently cold weather combining the two layers is an advantage, but I find two separate layers is more flexible, there is more choice on the market, and the result is lighter.

For example, I wrote to Patagonia when they brought out their Patagonia Alpine Wind Jacket (basically a wicking lined windshirt, similar to the Rab VR tops). They confirmed that the lining was thinner (cooler) than a Capilene 2 top, yet a Capilene 2 + Houdini combined was still lighter, with the advantage of a hood. I think perhaps the jacket had a more durable outer, which is perhaps a consideration for climbing.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedJan 25, 2010 at 4:14 pm

As others have indicated, a separate windshirt combined with a light insulation (mid-heavy base or light weight fleece) is typically lighter and more versatile than a soft shell.

So why do I use the Vapour Rise sometimes? First, it is not as warm because Pertex Equilibrium is more air permeable than the material used in most windshirts. I found that feeling a bit of air flow makes me feel a lot more comfortable. Note: I seem to run warmer than some people. Related to this is that I can vent heat more easily with the VR… the arms are wide enough that I can push them up to my elbows to cool off. Often times adjusting the hood, arms and front zippers amounts be to tailor my comfort without having to stop and take off or put on a windshirt. Third, while not as abrasion resistant as some of the heavier materials, Pertex Equilibrium seems more durable than the typical ultralight windshirt which is useful in some endeavors.

If I could find a light weight equilibrium shell, that had a good hood, hook&loop tabs for the arms and enough fabric to push sleeves up my arms, and a good fit, I would happily use it with a powerdry or powerstretch base and leave the VR home.

–Mark

Hans Dampf BPL Member
PostedJan 27, 2010 at 10:17 am

Thank you all for the comments and suggestions! Especially Marc since you are using the jacket in question

So you convinced me and I will go for the windshirt … and eventually still try the VR Trail for "daily" use..

What I have in mind is now:

– Patagonia Houdini, since it seems to be quite good according to reviews etc
– Rab Off Limit Pants
– Rab Momentum Jacket
– eventually the Rab VR Trail..

My problem are the sizes, since I have to order (no dealer nearby :/) so I'd like to ask:

If someone has equipment of Rab and Patagonia, and can eventually tell me their sizes compared to the vendor size so I can get a rough picture of what I need…

Thanks in advance,
Christoph

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...