Topic

How much sleeping pad do I need?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
PostedJan 22, 2010 at 4:24 pm

I recently ordered a WM Megalite sleeping bag, rated to 30F. Currently, my only light weight sleeping pad is a GG Thinlight 1/4" which I have used primarily inside my hammock in 45-60 degree temps in summer. I'm trying to dial in my ground sleeping system for the spring/fall seasons. Would the Thinlight on top of a NeoAir be enough insulation to keep warm in the Megalite at 30F?

Chris

PostedJan 23, 2010 at 12:47 am

Not that I have tried it…but I wouldnt think it was a good idea to put any other pad/mat ontop of the NeoAir. I own two NeoAir and really dont think they are suitable for that, not the toughest feeling material.

If you do try it please let us know how it goes

Cheers

PostedJan 23, 2010 at 12:55 am

Everyone's thermostat is a little different. That said, a 1/4" thinlight over a neo-air should be plenty. I know a number of users are fine at that temp with the neo-air alone.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 23, 2010 at 8:50 am

I'll be the dissenting voice… maybe not. Try the combo at home first, or on an overnight close to home. I personall would get cold w/the combo in the high 30s/low 40s. There are many, many threads on this exact topic already. Richard Nisley even did a nice big chart breaking down the combo of Neo w/thinlight; IIRC the comfort rating was ~40*F? Try the search function…

Edit:
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=25754&disable_pagination=1

http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=24000

also consider:
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=27625

The Neo only has an R-value of 2.2, thinlight would add ~0.5. Winter pad has R-5 or 6.

Nick Truax BPL Member
PostedJan 23, 2010 at 9:42 am

As everyone's personal comfort ranges, I agree with previous post as to test it out for yourself close to home.

For me, I've personally used the neoair alone into the high 20's and low 30's. My bag is a WM summerlite. 30F seems to be about the limit when on solid ground for me. I've recently been using a 3/8" blue foam on top for snow camping. Even in the same/similar temp range (low 20's to 30's) on snow I find that the neoair alone is cold but with the 3/8" on top it is plenty warm. I imagine it would be fine into the teens with this combo, just haven't had the lower temps recently to find out.

Kinda wish I had a 1/4" pad to see if it would suffice for mild snow camping temps. Other posts regarding this seem to say that two 1/4" pads on top of the neoair do the trick below freezing and on snow.

Again, give it a shot and let us know what you find. Best of luck!

A Wilson BPL Member
PostedJan 23, 2010 at 11:41 am

This totally depends upon the kind of ground you're sleeping on. If it's forest litter and duff that is not totally saturated (and not frozen!), no problem. Hard pack and rocks are another story, as they provide no natural insulation.

PostedJan 23, 2010 at 5:32 pm

Mark,

I'm not sure I understand why you feel the NeoAir is not durable enough to use a foam pad on top of it. How does the Thinlight pose a threat to the NeoAir fabric?

Brad,

I read through those threads, and see where Richard suggests a NeoAir + 1/8" Thinlight would be comfortable to 40F. The 1/4" Thinlight that I currently have should provide double the R value of a 1/8" pad.

Nicholas,

I will definitely be trying some combos at home as soon as I get all the pieces. There's been a lot of good 30F nights lately.

Andrew,

I hadn't thought of ground cover before. As I do most of my backpacking in PA, I generally sleep on leafy forest duff.

Thanks for all the responses.

Chris

PostedJan 23, 2010 at 8:35 pm

One thing to add here: regardless of the combination of pads, it's probably warmer to put the closed cell foam underneath the NeoAir. I queried the folks at Thermarest, and was advised that is the best way to do it. And this makes sense, since the NeoAir relies on a radiant heat barrier for most of its insualting capability, and radiant heat barriers work best at an optimal distance for the body that is radiating heat(yours). Adding a foam pad between you and the RHB would alter the distance and reduce the effectiveness of the RHB. By utting the closed cell under the NeoAir, you keep the RHB at optimal, and add the convective/conductive insulating capacity of the closed cell.

PostedJan 24, 2010 at 8:53 am

I would be very interested in getting some scientific backing on whether you should put an air mattress on a foam pad or vice versa.

Instinctively I would put the closed cell foam pad on the frozen ground, with the softer air mattress to sleep on, assuming the much lower R value of an air mattress will become void if it's in direct contact with a cold source that totally overwhelms it – basically a wasted R value. Where as you take away the worst cold with a simple foam pad, the lower rated air mattress may actually provide some isolation after all – it's a little more up to the job now.

Now I heard quite a few other opinions in numerous places over the past years stating that foam on air is the way to go. I suppose the logic here would be that you want your body to be in direct touch with the greater R value?

Can somebody provide me with some scientific insight or share some actual field experimenting results on this?

PostedJan 24, 2010 at 2:16 pm

I know there has been quite a bit of debate on this topic before, but I don't think there is a decisive answer. And the NeoAir throws another wrench into the equation due to it's reflective barrier that is supposed to radiate body heat back up to you. I think I will just have to do some home testing and see for myself :-) I may order a 1/8" GG Thinlight and do various tests using different combos of NeoAir, 1/4" Thinlight, and 1/8" Thinlight along with a WM Megalite bag.

I just hope I can find enough time to get out and do some "extensive" testing.

Chris

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedJan 24, 2010 at 3:54 pm

> assuming the much lower R value of an air mattress will become void if it's
> in direct contact with a cold source that totally overwhelms it
Nope, doesn't work that way. Sorry.

The best reason for putting the CCF at the bottom is to protect the air mat from punctures. Good logic there, but irrelevant in the snow.

The best reason for putting the CCF on top is because an air mat such as the NeoAir will lose a bit of heat out the sides where the CCF is missing. This could be significant for an AIR mat, but does not apply to the foam-filled air mats.

Cheers

PostedJan 24, 2010 at 4:33 pm

Check out Big Agnes Air Core or other insulated pads.

Exped or Pacific Outdoors Thermo-6

PostedJan 24, 2010 at 11:38 pm

Thank you Roger. Protecting from puncture does make sense and may easily overrule any other logic here indeed.

What I'm trying to get at is what is best practice when you have different materials and different R values. What would be the preferred order and why, purely from a thermal standpoint and ignoring practical reasoning as puncture protection. R values roughly add up, i.e. if you have a 1 and a 2.5 that essentially provides you a 3.5. However what would be the preferred order here?

For example, could one state that as a rule of thumb it would make sense to put the lower R value on top of the higher R value? And if so if, would this statement be independent of material or design (CCF / air mat / foam-filled air mat)? As you mentioned yourself the particular vulnerability of an air mat does not apply to foam-filled air mats.

What are the typical 2 layer setups here and what would be the preferred order?

From a practical experience standpoint it may be harder to compare as no two nights are ever the same. Weather, environment, your past day activities, food intake and current metabolism a.o. will be variables.

My personal, but not necessarily scientifically backed, approach to cold weather (~0°F) is to put the R 2.2 Therm-a-Rest Z Lite first, with a massive but simple, military 0.75" CCF (rating of around R ~3?) on top. I'm assuming here that the egg carton construction of the Z-Lite shields the CCF from the worst cold coming out of the ground. I tend not to use an air based sleeping mat in cold weather as a system failure would hurt just a little too much :-)

PostedJan 25, 2010 at 1:17 am

Roger has the science of it. If you ignore practicalities an air mat without down or synthetic fill will loose heat out the sides. A neoair does not have fill so from that point of view only, put the CCF ontop. If the heat all travelled straight down order of stacking would make no difference.
If I had a egg carton and a plain foam mat I would put the plain one on top, and of course the plain side of the egg carton foam, up. The Egg carton has free air channels, convection and pumping action as you move will expel heat sideways. It is best to have that extra loss as low and cool as possible.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedJan 25, 2010 at 1:43 am

Apart from the reasons Derek and I gave for putting the CCF on top, there are no other differences due to order. Doesn't matter in theory.

Cheers

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedJan 25, 2010 at 10:56 am

This issue has come up several times. As Roger says, the key here is that the NeoAir is more likely to lose heat via the sides. Not as much as it will to the bottom (of course) but still more than a closed cell foam. The reason it loses more to the sides is because it is not as warm per thickness. If not for that problem, it wouldn't matter which mattress was on top. For example, if you have a 1 inch foam and a 2 inch foam, it doesn't matter which one is on top.

The part that isn't obvious to me (OK, a lot of this isn't obvious to me) is why it matters which one loses more to the sides when stacking them. The answer is that you want the mattress that is going to lose the most to the sides to experience the least amount of temperature difference between the top and sides. If you put the foam on the bottom, then the top of the NeoAir is very warm, but the sides are very cold. If you put the foam on top, the top of the NeoAir is not very warm, and the sides are very cold.

I'm not sure how much effect radiant heat has. I personally think it is exaggerated. The great breakthrough in the NeoAir is the little triangular bubbles, not the radiant barrier. This is where testing could be really helpful.

Also, it would be nice to use a foam envelope and slip the NeoAir into it. It wouldn't take much foam on the side to pretty much eliminate side heat loss. Then, you would gain the puncture benefit of having foam on the bottom, while getting all the warmth benefit.

PostedJan 25, 2010 at 11:23 am

Where does a classic Therm-a-Rest self inflatable mat fit in? Is this just as prone to side loss as the Neo Air? Or does it fit somewhere between a foam mat and the Neo Air – which would make sense.

Still – following the same logic – you would put the classic self inflatable on the ground cause side loss will be better managed by a simple foam pad. Correct?

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 8:08 am

"Where does a classic Therm-a-Rest self inflatable mat fit in? Is this just as prone to side loss as the Neo Air? Or does it fit somewhere between a foam mat and the Neo Air – which would make sense.

Still – following the same logic – you would put the classic self inflatable on the ground cause side loss will be better managed by a simple foam pad. Correct?"

A NeoAir is not insulated, per se. It has a single horizontal emergency blanket in the middle of the pad that runs parallel to the top and bottom layers. That's it. That's the only insulative barrier. A couple microns thick. Standard self-inflators are filled with foam, full thickness of the pad. Most self-inflators have patterns die-cut in their surfaces to save weight, which sorta/kinda makes them "air mats" in those places, but which still work because of the greater percentage of insulated area and volume of the pad. No heat loss out the sides of a standard self inflator or down-filled mat. If you're working w/one of those pads, doesn't really matter which pad goes where when layering. Combined R-value the same either way. I usually put the CCF on bottom just because I find it more comfortable to lay on the other pads.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 26, 2010 at 8:10 am

"Brad,
I read through those threads, and see where Richard suggests a NeoAir + 1/8" Thinlight would be comfortable to 40F. The 1/4" Thinlight that I currently have should provide double the R value of a 1/8" pad."

Note that the difference gained from a 1/4" vs 1/8" pad was 1 to 2*F. Not very significant. Also note that values were obtained layered w/a down jacket under quilt…

PostedJan 26, 2010 at 8:31 am

I am not sure I totally agree with Brad. I think you will get more heat loss sideways from a self inflater than a CCF pad. If you ever needed to boost an exped down mat with CCF it might theoretically be better CCF on top but at some point we have to stop worrying about small differences in warmth and bother about: punctures, slippiness, comfort, damage. I tore an 1/8" CCF by using it on top of a neoair and being a fidgity sleeper.

Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
Loading...