Thank you Roger. Protecting from puncture does make sense and may easily overrule any other logic here indeed.
What I'm trying to get at is what is best practice when you have different materials and different R values. What would be the preferred order and why, purely from a thermal standpoint and ignoring practical reasoning as puncture protection. R values roughly add up, i.e. if you have a 1 and a 2.5 that essentially provides you a 3.5. However what would be the preferred order here?
For example, could one state that as a rule of thumb it would make sense to put the lower R value on top of the higher R value? And if so if, would this statement be independent of material or design (CCF / air mat / foam-filled air mat)? As you mentioned yourself the particular vulnerability of an air mat does not apply to foam-filled air mats.
What are the typical 2 layer setups here and what would be the preferred order?
From a practical experience standpoint it may be harder to compare as no two nights are ever the same. Weather, environment, your past day activities, food intake and current metabolism a.o. will be variables.
My personal, but not necessarily scientifically backed, approach to cold weather (~0°F) is to put the R 2.2 Therm-a-Rest Z Lite first, with a massive but simple, military 0.75" CCF (rating of around R ~3?) on top. I'm assuming here that the egg carton construction of the Z-Lite shields the CCF from the worst cold coming out of the ground. I tend not to use an air based sleeping mat in cold weather as a system failure would hurt just a little too much :-)