Topic

2 Newbie Gear Questions

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 8:28 pm

1. What would the best bag liner be for the weight? I've seen the Sea to Summit liner that says it can add 15 degrees to your bag. Is this a good choice?I have a 30 degree bag in which I'd like to use a liner with to be comfortable at 20 degrees.

2. Is there a difference in fleece as far as weight vs warmth? In other words, am I better off buying a higher quality fleece shirt? Will this give me a lighter weight for the warmth level?

PostedJan 16, 2010 at 8:40 pm

hi john

not an expert on fleece but have used the sea to summit thermolite reactor

i used it last year on a trip in very wet, windy and cold weather for 8 days in tasmanian wilderness – it certainly made my WM Summerlite warmer and i was not cold however it certainly didnt change the temperature by the stated increase.

I would normally use a liner in my bag anyway – especially on a trip like this where we were very muddy and wet all the time.

It definitely did better than a silk liner.

may not be able to get away from owning a summer and winter bag though.

cheers

nick

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 8:42 pm

You have several options:
1. Get a sleeping bag inner liner. Note that some of those weigh as much as my entire sleeping bag.
2. Get a bivy sack overbag. That adds some weight also.
3. Simply wear more warm clothing into the sleeping bag. If that clothing were very weight-efficient, that would be a good way to go. For example, a down inner jacket.

The overall best way to go would be to purchase a warmer sleeping bag.
–B.G.–

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 8:57 pm

John:

I've tried the Sea-to-Summit liner that supposedly gives a 15F temp boost. DON'T BELIEVE IT. It gives maybe 3F at best. Do a search and you'll see more feedback.

Sometimes, we desperately want to believe the specs — but in this case, DON'T, or you might freeze like I almost did! Now to your second question:

The materials that will give you the best weight to warmth ratio are (in order):

1. Down (the higher the fill power, the less down needed and thus the lighter for a given warmth).

2. High quality synthetic insulation – Polarguard 3D for example.

3. Fleece — good warmth to weight but BULKY!

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 9:22 pm

Best liner for weight? None and don't expect the S2S to add 15F. If you really want to add 10F to your bag, the best thing you could do would be to a a few ounces of down to your bag. My recommendation would be make sure you have a warm enough pad and use your clothing to get the last 10F (assuming your bag is good to 30F… not all bags are good down to what they claim).

Liners are useful on longer trips to reduce the frequency you need to wash your bags. Other than that they have questionable value. Appropriate clothing serves double duty where a liner is mostly restricted to when you sleep.

As to the difference between the fleece weight / warmth… yes. There can be some difference (for example the grid used on the Patagonia R2 is warmer to weight than a typical 200wt fleece) but differences between fleece are minor compared to the difference between fleece and high loft garments (down or synthetic like climashield, primaloft, or polarguard) which can often be 1/2 or better the weight for equiv warmth.

–Mark

A Wilson BPL Member
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 9:27 pm

Bag liners are good at keeping the inside of your bag clean, not at increasing its temp beyond a few degrees; and for sleeping in hostels and refuges where such a thing is required. Its much easier just to wear your clothes, which I'm assuming you'll have a dry set to change into. Warm clothes will increase a bag's temp by their corresponding CLO value, and would be the easiest way to do what you seem to want to do.

Fleece has three things going for it: it is cheap, can be shaken bone dry and still work wet, and lasts forever. This last one afflicts those of us taught by our mothers to use something until it wears out before replacing it. Apparently some people don't have my moral scruples.

There are, of higher quality fleeces that usually have some kind of windproofing. IMO a wind shell over a fleece is better, and usually breathes better.

If you've got money, even a very thin insulating layer like BPL's cocoon layer, or Thru-hiker's pullovers, will give you all the warmth, half the weight, and about 1/4 the bulk of a fleece sweater. Plus it has wind-blocking built in.

That being said, in those myriad life applications where LW is not necessary, fleece's ubiquity and durability still have a pace. Fleece is also just about the easiest thing to sew; and you can make all kinds of things out of the cast-off, voluminous fleeces had for pennies at your local thrift store.

PostedJan 16, 2010 at 9:40 pm

Liners do very little to add warmth to your sleep system. The S2S liner weight 9 oz.! Imagine what half the much weight in down would do for your bag.

Forget about a liner and save your money for another bag.

Fleece? I like plain old Polartec Classic. It is much warmer and lighter than the crap you can find at Old Navy. Plus it dries faster and is more pill resistant.

Joseph

PostedJan 16, 2010 at 11:13 pm

I used the S2S liner for over 4 months of working in all kinds of conditions. I used a pretty crappy old 25 degree Kelty bag cuz it was for work. We camped out for 8 day stretches from June til December. So the temps in Nov and Dec were near freezing on several nights. Im not a big fan of sleeping in clothing, so i found that the liner made a huge difference. I would say the liner was almost good for 15 degrees for me, not because of insulation, but because of moisture management. I usually just wore sleep socks and boxers to sleep, and the liner is really warm against the skin considering how thin it is. My only problem with that liner is that it was kinda hard to get up over my head and shoulders, even in the longest length, and im only 6'1". So get the biggest size.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 17, 2010 at 12:17 am

Sorry, I am not following. You said the liner made "a huge difference". OTOH, you were using a 25F bag in near 32F (freezing) condition — so was the liner really "tested"?

If the liner really added 15F for you, then presumably nighttime temps were substantially below freezing — something like 10F or 15F?

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 10:52 am

A bivy sack overbag may be a good choice. Are there any that will add maybe 10 degrees with a weight under a pound?

Wondering too if a wool sweater would be equally as good for warmth vs weight instead of a fleece pullover?

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedJan 17, 2010 at 12:15 pm

> the Sea to Summit liner that says it can add 15 degrees to your bag.

That has got to be one of the more blatant scams. If the liner material was that good, who would bother with down?

Cheers

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedJan 17, 2010 at 12:31 pm

^^^ Yup, but it seems to come up all the time, so it must be making them a lot of money.

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 2:04 pm

John,

> I have a 30 degree bag in which I'd like to use a liner with to be comfortable at 20 degrees.

Liners won't add more than a couple degrees, but a lightweight down jacket (Montbell down inner or WM Flash) that you'll need for camp anyway can definitely add 10 degrees. This is what I take when I expect 20 degrees: my WM Caribou bag (35 degree) + WM Flash jacket + wind pants that I sleep in. I'll usually sleep in socks too. If it's going down to 10 degrees then I'll bring my WM Alpinlite bag (20 degrees) and down inner pants + booties too. For camp I'll wear those down layers with a wind/rain shell outside to be water- and wind-proof. Then I can just shed the shell when I climb in my bag.

Works great! It's really nice to be able to keep the down layer on even when leaving the tent like if you need to pee in the night.

FWIW I've given up on fleece. The bulk was one problem, but even worse, fleece gets chilly in the slightest breeze, so I always needed a shell over it… and then it would quickly get too warm. Down has a huge comfort range by comparison.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...