Topic

WM Megalite vs. Montbell SS #2

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 2:06 pm

I'm considering purchasing one of these two sleeping bags and would appreciate any advice from anyone who has used either of these bags. I currently own a Montbell SS #5 (rated to 40F) and a Military surplus bag (rated to -20F) which is way heavy and I don't backpack with. I do most of my backpacking in PA from April – October. I think my lowest anticipated overnight lows would be between 20F-25F. I own a Montbell exlight down jacket to supplement warmth. I am primarily a hammocker, but would go to the ground in colder situations as I don't have an underquilt – I use a 1/4" foam pad in the hammock.

I like the comfort of the superstretch system from Montbell. But with the width of the Megalite, perhaps it is just as comfortable? The Montbell would be cheaper, but also a tad heavier. The Megalite also allows the option of 2 ounces of down overfill, which I would consider.

I don't think I would be disappointed with either bag, but any advice is appreciated.

Chris

Joe L BPL Member
PostedJan 16, 2010 at 9:23 pm

My Megalite is very roomy on the inside. So much so that a WM bag that is smaller on the inside would be slightly warmer. Look at the bag specification page at the WM website to see which ones are very roomy, slightly roomy, or very snug. Before buying a new one, I would buy a used one, expecting to sell it for near the same price if it is not exactly what I needed. Spend the money saved on other gear to keep your legs, feet, and head warm.

You've got a warm down jacket. Take it to your local WM and MB dealers and wear it inside of different bags. You want enough bag space that your jacket insulation is not pinched, but no more than that.

At those lower temps, you will need much more CCF pad under you to stay warm, regardless of your bag choice.

PostedJan 16, 2010 at 9:44 pm

I’m a BIG fan of Western Mountaineering Bags. I own the Caribou MF, MegaLite and a Versalite. They have all lived up to their reputations and have earned a place in my gear closet. There’s also the added plus of knowing that I have invested/purchased an American made product.

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 5:12 am

Joe,

I would really like to see a WM bag in person before I purchase. I’m struggling to find any retailers near Harrisburg PA. I’ll have to get on the phone to see if any retailers within an hour or so drive carry WM.

I do have several pad options for ground sleeping in low temps. I have a five or so year old Thermarest Ultralite short and a blue foam pad to pair with the 1/4″ GG thinlight. I was trying to make a point that use in a hammock is not my primary purpose with this bag purchase. I’ll stick to warmer conditions with the hammock.

I’m not a huge guy (5’10” 180lb) but the Montbell #5 would be too tight on me if it didn’t stretch. I also like the idea of possibly using my #5 inside the Megalite to make a cold weather bag if I would ever need to.

I’ve found a lot of old posts comparing WM and Montbell. It seems like there’s nothing bad to say about WM if you get the bag that fits you best, while with MB there is a mixed bag of comments. I found this post by David Horton which shows pics comparing the Megalite to a SS#2: link. This was in early 2008, so I’m not sure if MB was using 725 or 800 fill down back then. Either way, the Megalite just looks more impressive. I’m starting to lean toward the Megalite with 2 ounces of overfill. I just hope I can try one on before I purchase.

Chris

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 10:43 am

Transitioning to single-wall tents a few years ago with 360 degrees of mesh, warmth became a problem. My Megalite has made this a moot issue. I bought a Versalite first thinking that warmth was becoming a chronic problem but the Versalite has been too warm for me. The Megalite is just right for the Sierras from late spring thru autumn.

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 7:31 pm

"I would really like to see a WM bag in person before I purchase. I'm struggling to find any retailers near Harrisburg PA. I'll have to get on the phone to see if any retailers within an hour or so drive carry WM."

Can you attend the PA Ruck in two weeks? http://www.paruck.com

I expect there will be a few WM bags present. You might have to ask around. Not sure I can be there yet, but if I do go, I'll probably have both my Megalite and my Antelope (gets cold in the campground.)

PostedJan 17, 2010 at 10:04 pm

I've owned a WM Megalite for 3 summers and had it in 25 F. nights with good warmth if I had on light long johns. It has enough girth that I could wear my Thermolite Micro synthetic insulated jacket and pants inside and was fine in the high tens F.

On warm nights its extra width I've unzipped it all the way and used it as a quilt W/ the foot hooked over the end of my Thermarest reg. length mattress.

PostedJan 18, 2010 at 3:54 pm

Ken,

I won't be able to attend the PA Ruck. I decided to purchase the bag from Hermits Hut and give it a try. I'm 99% sure I'll be happy with it, but if not, I'm sure I can get rid of it without too much of a loss.

Paul,

I decided to go with the overfill. I want the bag to be capable of going below 30F. I have a 40F Montbell #5 for warmer conditions. There seem to be two schools of thought on down overfill: One is maximum loft = maximum warmth. The other believes that maximum warmth is achieved at considerably less than full loft. Richard Nissley has made some interesting and convincing posts in favor of the latter. I'm trusting his expertise. Hey, 2 oz. more down can't make a bag colder, right?

Chris

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...