Topic

“need” a new pack

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Dennis Park BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 6:44 am

There are a few variables that I am trying to solve. Can you guys provide some insight?

1. Framed (ie GG Mariposa or ULA Circuit) vs. nonframed (ie Jam2)?

2. Seeing that the GG Gorilla is made of a heavier material, were there any durability issues with the Mariposa?

3. Are there any durability issues with the nonmetal frame in the ULA packs (ie checking it in for flights)?

4. Any other packs I should consider? My base weight so far is 14#. I will need the ability to carry a bear cannister also.

Thanks.

PostedJan 12, 2010 at 8:14 am

With a 14 lbs baseweight, you're only going to be able to use a frameless pack on fairly short trips (ie. 1-3 days) and still be comfortable. With a frameless pack you only want to exceed a total pack weight of about 20 lbs rarely. If you only do short trips or you plan on cutting your baseweight significantly in the near future then you could go with a frameless pack (ie. MLD Exodus @ ~15oz) but otherwise I would go with a framed pack.

For framed packs, I really like the ULA Ohm and GG Gorilla. Anything else (ie. Osprey) is a lot heavier. For frameless packs, I like MLD and ULA the most.

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 8:22 am

For that weight, I would go with one of the light framed packs. I have both the GG Mariposa Plus and Gorilla and really like them, but there are other good options. The Mariposa Plus is plenty tough for the trail, it's not like it is Silnylon or anything. The Miniposa is made of Silnylon and would take a bit more care.

Nick Gatel BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 9:07 am

Dennis,

For base weights you are discussing I would go with a framed pack like the GG Mariposa Plus or the ULA Circuit at about 59 liters capacity each.

You need to look at the recommended base weight, not maximum weight specifications.

You mentioned the need to carry a bear cannister. I know of several PCT Thru Hikers have used the Mariposa Plus and were able to carry a cannister, but they had to do some creative packing. GG Website shows a cannister mounted outside on the top, but most users put it inside the pack and move items to the spacious outside pockets. Can't speak for the Circuit.

I find that the Mariposa Plus is easier for me to live out of. Just a personal preference.

As to checking it as luggage. The Dyneema material of the ULA packs are more durable. However the GG Gorilla is made from heavier nylon that the Mariposa Plus, but has a smaller capacity at 46 L. But to be honest, it doesn't matter. I travel a lot and baggage handlers can destroy anything, even my high end lifetime guaranteed (includes airline damage) Briggs & Riley luggage!!

Lori P BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 10:13 am

I'm not particularly kind to my Mariposa Plus – don't go bushwacking with it, but it's crawled through branches in deadfall with me.

I've carried a Bear Vault Solo in it. You have to be good at balancing the load but it works. Might get a Bearikade Expedition in vertically, would be a tight fit, but nothing larger.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 10:44 am

Also consider the Six Moon Designs Starlite or Traveler. Get it with the "optional" (IMHO, mandatory) stays. Total weight of the pack with stays is 30 oz. Heavier than the Gorilla (although the latter has no load-lifters, a must-have for me) but definitely lighter than most of ULA's packs. You can remove the stays if you want, for really light loads. But with 14# base weight plus bear canister, you need a supportive pack, especially for long trips.

I've used a SMD Comet (smaller version, unfortunately no longer made) for 5 years now and have been extremely happy with it. I've carried up to 37 lbs. in it–my shoulders, back and hips were fine, although my knees and feet were screaming! It will take a bear canister!

James Naphas BPL Member
PostedJan 12, 2010 at 10:28 pm

Like the others have said, above 25 lbs or so you'll want a frame.

I have a first generation mariposa (carbon stays, silnylon body), which works pretty well with a bear canister. The larger BV or garcia canisters only fit vertically, but getting the rest of your gear in the pack and exterior pockets is possible, given that you've reduced volume as well as weight. I've carried up to 35 lbs in it, but it's a lot more comfortable at 31-32 or less.

The Mariposa been sturdier than I would have expected. I've bushwacked with it some and sustained no damage. It picked up a small tear on the body when my then 15 year old son scraped it against a tree, and one of the stays poked through the bottom on the last trip I used it. Not sure how that happened, but maybe it was caused by overloading. My son now has a mariposa plus, and it's a little more sturdy, but not to the level of one of the dyneema packs.

I haven't seen the gorilla, but as it's a bit smaller than a mariposa I think it would be harder to pack everything you'd need for a solo trip using one of the larger canisters unless you've switched to tarping, use minimally sized cook gear, and have invested in clothes like the montbell UL down inner jacket that compress down to a very small size.

In packing for flights, I'd put everything in a duffel bag as loose items. I wouldn't want to depend on someone searching luggage to be able to repack your gear and not leave something out. I'd also label stuff like trekking poles, as I doubt that many of the TSA guys encounter stuff like that on a regular basis.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...