Still in my search for a bivy, I have narrowed it down to these two. I am hiking the PCT and will be using a tarp when needed, but prefer not too. I like to wake up and hike as quickly as possible, and my tarp takes more time to pack than a bivy. Any suggestions that one bivy is better than the other? Also looked at the TiGoat Ptarmigan, but these seemed to be more waterproof at almost the same weight- or is that just a semantics issue from the web sites? Any help is appreciated!! Evan
Topic
Terra Nova Moonlite Bivy vs. Montbell Breeze Dry-Tec U.L.
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I have the Breeze Dry-Tec. I would call it a sleeping bag cover as opposed to a bivy, although I have used mine as such on occasion. Only weighs 7 oz. and is extremely compact stuffed. If you are going to use a bivy as a stand alone shelter I would probably suggest something else.
Tim – Does your Breeze-Tec make a measurable difference in the temp rating of your bag?
David- I used it with a MH Phantom 32 degree with the temps in the mid 20's, with Powerstretch base layers, in an open bivy and was pretty warm. The Montbell cuts the wind and breathes very well. I would estimate it add 5-10 degrees to the sleeping bag's rating.
Hey there- thanks so much. You said you would not use it as a stand alone shelter- why is that? You mentioned that it breathes very well, and from the reviews it seems very waterproof, so it seems like a great shelter for only 7 ounces. Could you elaborate a bit? I would probably use it stand alone only in decent weather conditions, at other times using a tarp overhead. Thanks so much!
Because it has an open hood, MontBell refers to it as a sleeping bag cover rather than bivy. I would imagine that’s why Tim suggested it wouldn’t be a great stand-alone choice. If you haven’t seen it already, here’s an old thread that might be of interest to you.
A bit of a shameless plug but I have a brand new ID Endurance bag cover for sale that may bit your needs here: http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=27747
Its about the same weight as the Montbell in the larger size (10-12oz), nice and roomy, breaths well, seam taped, and has a proper hood so you don't have to use a tarp with it except in severe rain.
Become a member to post in the forums.

