Topic

Sil Poncho vs. eVENT/Drop Stoppers jacket

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
PostedApr 8, 2006 at 6:47 pm

I am tempted to purchase Ron Moak’s new Gatewood Cape for overnighters where I expect fair weather. However, I am a bit concerned about the breathability of silnylon as a poncho. I have never tried a non-breathable poncho. My experience with hiking in the rain is that Drop Stoppers Jackets are just barely breathable enough to be comfortable hiking in (and I know that’s about as breathable as watherproof fabrics get!). So my concern is getting sweat-soaked in a downpour with silnylon. I realize, though, that ponchos are more vented, but I wonder if that is enough. I do hike with an umbrella. I envision overnighters with an umbrella, wind shirt, gatewood cape, polycro ground cloth, and bug netting.

On the positive sides, the Gatewood Cape is the first poncho that I feel is storm-worthy as a poncho. Combined with my waterproof gauntlet gloves, it appears I might have full arm protection. I like that it doubles as a pack cover. And the pyramid design looks more wind-stable than traditional poncho-shelters. I’m so tempted by 11oz for both poncho and shelter!

I will be using it in the PNW. Having followed the forums on the liquid sunshine, I intend to use this for fair weather.

(For those of you following my other threads, I decided on the Hex 3 instead of making my own Epic bivy/hammock combo for foul weather hiking in the PNW. Thanks to all of you who suggested this shelter! I really do enjoy sleeping on my stomach (so no hammock), and I am amazed at the stability of the Hex in winds (tried it side-by side with my Shires Rainshadow, and there’s no comparison! (though I still love the Rainshadow). And I’ve found a way to clip my Gossamer Gear polycro groundsheet to the sides, so I have a 1.5oz bucket-floor for the Hex 3).

But for fair-weather overnighters the Hex is overkill. Thus my tempation with the Gatewood Cape…

PostedApr 9, 2006 at 9:50 am

John,

I just spent my third night in my Gatewood Cape. It is very storm worthy both as rain wear and a shelter. I protects better than a poncho, but it would prefer a poncho in an all day gentle rain. As a shelter it is stable in high winds, but your Hex gives you a lot more room in prolonged rains. Here in Colorado most of our summer storms are short and intense. The Cape is the perfect combination.

PostedApr 9, 2006 at 11:55 pm

Thanks for the Gatewood comments! I was hoping that the pyramid design of the Gatewood Cape would offer the same storm protection that I have come to appreciate in the Hex 3, so it is nice to hear that it is doing well in strong winds.

That’s about what I’m thinking; the Gatewood for Summer when I expect fair weather, and the Hex 3 for Spring/Fall or when I am *seeking* a good misty downpour =).

When you say you prefer a poncho in an all day gentle rain, do you mean as opposed to a jacket?

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Loading...