Does Shire's have plans of ever offering any of his tents in cuben? Considering he seems to be the most popular tentmaker it seems that cuben versions would be a great breakthrough.
Topic
Cuben contrail
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I believe Henry mentioned that he's not interested in cuben at this point because it would be too expensive of an investment. I think he should explore cuben, but I can understand how it would be daunting to spend all that money on expensive cuben and have to redesign your tents to match the no-stretch characteristic of cuben. It really would be starting over and Henry has a fairly refined line up now, so it would be a big decision.
I personally think cuben is going to be the material of choice for UL tents in the years to come for everything but the floor. Now that it's becoming available in colors other than white further strengthens it's case.
and it can be seam taped which is a requirement for the "big boys". That is why no major manufacturer makes tents out of Silnylon.
I've said this before but the reason I haven't jumped on the cuben bandwagon is because of price. Not my cost but the end user price of a finished shelter. I try hard to keep shelters affordable and I'm loathe to tack hundreds of dollars onto a shelter just to save a few ounces. As sacrilegious as this might sound to many of you, I'm of the opinion that no one can tell the difference of a few ounces in a fully loaded pack. One can put the price difference between a cuben shelter and a silnylon shelter toward another piece of gear that saves the same weight or otherwise improves the outdoor experience over and above just having a lighter shelter. Having said all that, nothing is forever and the day will surely come when we’ll do something in cuben or other high-cost fabric. I just want the reason to be more compelling than saving a few ounces.
-H
Personally I don't have any cuben products solely due to the price. I agree that spending hundreds of dollars to save a few ounces isn't always the most practical use of money.
However, lets say cuben (or similar expensive technology) decreases the weight by 25% (such as the MLD DuoMid going from 16oz to 12oz) and it costs twice as much (MLD DuoMid $405 vs $205). There are likely many people that are willing to pay twice as much for their gear for it to weigh 25% less. I am not one of those, but I might be willing to pay 50% more for a 25% reduction in weight. Everyone has different priorities in what they value more.
well I'm using cuben not just for weight, but it doesn't stretch! No more getting up in the night to tighten the pitch! More sleep, more enjoyable days
The cuben version of the old SMD Refuge tent (16oz) shaved 11oz off the silnylon version (27oz) which IMO is a significant amount of weight. That's about 1/2 day worth of food.
“and it can be seam taped which is a requirement for the "big boys". That is why no major manufacturer makes tents out of Silnylon.”
Bradford the reason that the “big boys” stay away from silnylon is the fire-retardant requirements of many states. This from California:
“ it shall be unlawful for any person to sell or offer for sale any tent designed and intended for use for occupancy by less than 10 persons unless the tent is made from flame-retardant fabrics or materials approved by the State Fire Marshal. One year after the adoption of regulations by the State Fire Marshal, but not later than July 1, 1976, all tents manufactured for sale in this state shall be flame retardant and shall be labeled in a manner specified by the State Fire Marshal. Any manufacturer of tents for sale in this state who fails to use flame-retardant fabrics or materials or who fails to label them as specified by the State Fire Marshal shall be strictly liable for any damage which occurs to any person as a result of a violation of this section. “
While Henry can take chances as just about every person that buys a tent from him considers him a personal friend, ;-) Coleman or Eureka that sell thousands of tents each year don't want the liability. That is why Big Agnes and MSR have been working on new fabrics that approach the weight of sil and still meet the requirements.
"One can put the price difference between a cuben shelter and a silnylon shelter toward another piece of gear that saves the same weight or otherwise improves the outdoor experience over and above just having a lighter shelter."
Thank you Henry for the intelligent post. Many of us feel the same way.
> The cuben version of the old SMD Refuge tent (16oz) shaved 11oz off the silnylon version (27oz) which IMO is a significant amount of weight.
I think we went through this before too but the only way that's true is if the cuben version has/had a cuben floor: 11 ounce weight difference = ~ 14 yds of fabric so that must include floor fabric. A cuben floor without an extra protective groundsheet is damage waiting to happen and to me that's shaving weight at the expense of durability/performance.
re: stretch, yes cuben non-stretch is certainly convenient and there's no doubt that silnylon needs to be retensioned after initial setup but if you stake it well before going to bed there's no reason you should ever have to get up in the night to retension.
I will say two more things regarding cuben and then I'll shut up. First, "Non-stretch" isn't quite true. Cuben does stretch a little and does so in a permanent way. Once stretched it wont ever snap back to original cut dimensions. That's a bad thing when designing a curved surface that needs to tension itself into shape for best performance and makes it very difficult to get perfect pitch once it has stretched because no amount of tightening here or there will pull the deformation out nor will it pull a canopy into reasonable shape to overcome uneven ground. The second point to consider about non-stretch materials is that they don't "give" to reduce stress. That leads to excessive stresses at attachment points, seams, and anywhere else where forces concentrate and thus is becomes much more important to reinforce stress points to guard against ripping and tearing. I'm not saying this to denigrate cuben–it's an amazing fabric–but only to point out that all fabrics have upsides and downsides.
-H
Thanks Henry for both posts. I agree: Cuben has it's advantages and disadvantages. I think an earlier post mentioned that, when it suggested that some designs might need to change. Unfortunately, the high cost of Cuben means that prototyping is also expensive.
However, I hope you one day reconsider your aversion to using Cuben because of its price. Your approach is understandable. You have every right to be proud of your products from both a quality and value standpoint. However, if everyone refused to spend the extra money just to save a few ounces, then few would buy anything made from down. It has clear disadvantages to synthetic and costs a huge amount more. I live in the Northwest (of the U.S.) and never thought I would own a down sleeping bag. I only save a few ounces by using down (and have to worry about moisture a lot more) but those ounces, along with other ounces saved making similar decisions, have changed my attitude towards backpacking.
I never liked the actual backpacking part of backpacking. By that, I mean that I never liked the part that involved carrying the big backpack. I really enjoyed day hiking and I really enjoyed day hiking from a back country camp, but carrying a heavy load was always hard on me (perhaps because of my slim frame). However, because of the various products available (including your tents) and the various techniques, that has changed. What would I pay for that? Probably thousands and thousands of dollars. Seriously. backpacking is a ridiculously great bargain. The average person spends more on just one typical vacation then I've spent on all my gear combined (and I've got a lot of gear).
I know I'm rambling now, but I really hope you reconsider.
I think we went through this before too but the only way that's true is if the cuben version has/had a cuben floor: 11 ounce weight difference = ~ 14 yds of fabric so that must include floor fabric. A cuben floor without an extra protective groundsheet is damage waiting to happen and to me that's shaving weight at the expense of durability/performance.
I think we did as well. I know that Ron's tent has a silnylon floor, so I'm not sure how he got so much of a weight savings. Perhaps part of it is the use of nano-seeum netting. I thought you guys occasionally hung out together — if so, I think that would a fine topic for discussion.
Henry,
I also hope you reconsider using cuben at some point. But I really appreciate your expertise with design and fabrics which effect stretch and the need for reinforcements, etc. I am convinced that if you offer your products in cuben or another advanced fabric some day in the future they will be well designed, tested and functional.
I hope you don't get peeved at these messages which come up every so often. It really is an endorsement of your philosophy and practices in making great shelters. In other words it may sound like whining but it really is a compliment.
It's just in our nature to want more, better, lighter and cheaper. Keep up the great work!
Henry,
I for one think there is big market potential for tents that weigh a lot less if such a thing is actually possible.
A huge percent of the US population, like myself, are aging baby-boomers who have started to retire and have extra time to take long backpacking trips. Many of us have worked for years looking forward to this time when we would be able to go on long multi-day trips hiking in the mountains, but unforetunately some of us are limited now by how much weight our aging backs can haul around.
If you are asking whether an extra $200 for a tent would make us decide to stay at home instead, I think I can say definitively that an extra $200 or even much more for a very light tent would be well worth it. It certainly would be for me. What other options are there for us to get out into remote areas? What does it cost to pay somebody to haul your gear around for us?Several days of that would equal the extra the tent cost. And the 50-70 year olds are also a part of the population that could more easily afford the extra expense.
I'm not saying that I am voting for cuben as the fabric of choice. I don't know anything about fabrics or making tents, I just think that a single person tent in the 10 oz- 1 lb range at twice the price would find a huge market among older backpackers.
I own a virga? (an ancestor of the contrail) And after using it the other night realized how much I like the design. I can't really justify going to the contrail yet, the virga's still in great shape. I wasn't complaining that there weren't cuben tarptents, just wondering why. I always like the idea of lighter and better, if Henry (who I appreciate adding his insight) could stand behind a sub pound contrail I would find a way to get the money for it.
"I for one think there is big market potential for tents that weigh a lot less if such a thing is actually possible."
I think it depends on what you mean by "a lot less." Cuben is lighter, but I'm not sure I'd say it weighs a lot less than sil in shelter construction. The sil DuoMid weighs only 4 oz. more than the cuben, a little less than 4 oz. difference between the sil and cuben versions of ZPack's hexamid, etc.
I think what Henry was saying is that there won't be a huge difference in his shelters if he made them in cuben, and he didn't think most people would really notice the difference in a full pack to justify the increase in cost.
>I think what Henry was saying is that there won't be a huge difference in his shelters if he made them in cuben, and he didn't think most people would really notice the difference in a full pack to justify the increase in cost.
Yes, thanks, that's pretty much it. For the smaller shelters there just isn't enough canopy fabric to make a "huge"– granted that word means different things to different people–weight difference. For a really large shelter like our Hogback then, yes, the difference is probably 11 ounces or so. However by then the price difference is stratospheric and the weight difference amortized over the number of occupants is still negligible. My point is that in a fully loaded pack these weight differences just aren't significant if you've already done what you can to reduce your other items.
If you think about it, a cup of water is heavier than these cuben vs. sil weight differences. If you're the type that stresses over whether your platy contains 1 liter or 1.2 liters of water as you're walking along then, ok, the big $$ for cuben is worth it. Otherwise, why stress?
-H
Looking at the offerings from MLD (Mids, Tarps) and SMD (Refuge), it seems that opting for cuben costs about $15 per ounce saved from SMD and $50 per ounce saved from MLD.
Spending $50 per ounce saved ($800/lbs) does seem a bit excessive, but $15 per ounce saved ($240/lbs) seems reasonable enough. Down isn't this cost:weight effective. I suspect the cost from TarpTent would likely be somewhere between these costs and perhaps would be in the $25-$30 range. Compared to other hobbies, this seems affordable. It's amazing what road bikers spend on carbon fibre parts. They will spend several thousand more on a bike to save 1-2 lbs.
I agree that for some ultralighters there may be better & cheaper ways to shave ounces than cuben, but I suspect many of us have reached a point where there are very few options left to shave weight and most of the remaining options involve significant compromises in the backcountry (ie. switching to a poncho tarp). It's at this point where saving weight with the only major downside being cost becomes quite appealing.
Become a member to post in the forums.

