Topic

Balaclava: Down vs. Primaloft?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Jim W. BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 3:28 pm

New thread to avoid hijacking the "Downworks Balaclava" thread.

Can any of you compare down vs. synthetic filled balaclavas? For my uses the weight difference is negligable. Either would be much warmer and lighter than a thick fleece balaclava. I would be making it myself and the cost difference would also be negligable.

Pros for down:
Slightly less weight (no more than 1 oz difference tops).
More compressible
Better moisture buffering/transport in dry conditions, resulting in greater comfort range.
EDIT: Down has longer lifespan.

Pros for Primaloft:
Less compressible possibly resulting in more comfort while sleeping.
Less moisture absorbtion and loss of loft due to rain (rare).
EDIT: "Downproof fabric not needed for inner lining so I could use Powerdry." Apparently not true- Primaloft needs a tight weave fabric to prevent fibers migrating out.
Easier to make

Ultimately I'd make four, so making my own will save a lot of money. I got started down this path after ordering a hoodless down jacket.

My initial design ideas came from looking at the Down Works and BPL Cocoon balaclavas. Black Rock Gear's down beanie is also intriguing.

Uses: For me combined with my new down jacket and to extend sleep rating of my mummy bag. One for wife combined with -my- new down jacket ;) (while I wear my Primaloft jacket) but mostly to extend the sleep rating of her hoodless sleeping bag. For the kids combined with various jackets and/or sleeping in their mummy bags.

Jim Colten BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 4:32 pm

I chose Primaloft.

Here's the rationale:

I rarely HIKE wearing a highly insulated balaclava .. it'd have to be a windy -10F or calm -20F. Any warmer than that and I'd use a SmartWool balaclava and the hood of a windshell, maybe with with a thicker hat, maybe with a PSolar mask.

I do use a heavy balaclava on cold mornings and evenings in camp but that is a small percentage of the time I use it.

The overwhelming majority of time it is used when sleeping with a drawstring quilt cinched around my neck. That is always gonna be in conditions where my breath is condensing. Ten hours of condensing breath yields a lot of moisture … every night.

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 4:46 pm

I would go with the Primaloft. I have a Cocoon Hoody, which I use in the winter. I often put it on when I eat lunch, and then sometimes snowshoe/ski in it (if I'm a little chilly and want to warm up). The temperatures are often close to freezing and damp. I bought it for summer use, but find I use it more for winter.

The only advantage of down (other than the ones you mentioned) is that it will probably last longer.

Evan Cabodi BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 11:18 pm

I'm definitely a biased opinion but I've really got to go with down here. If you get a good quality down, say 800+ or higher the benefits will really outway those of a synthetic. Weight might not be much of an issue for you but the down will definitely compress better and pack away smaller. Both Synthetic and down eventually "wet out" but a high quality down actually wicks and transports moisture very well. If you fill them with 900 fill they will simply wick any sweat or moisture away better than any synthetic in my opinion.

Also, from an environmental standpoint you'd be supporting a sustainable market by using down instead of going with the crude oil based primaloft ;) Might not sway your eventual goal but it's always something to think about.

As for construction the down will also give you a bit more room for error where the rigid sheet of primaloft can get folds and ridges in it when not sewn flat. The down will also allow for a much warmer balaclava in the end which sounds like the primary reason for wanting to make something. You'll mostly just be sleeping in them so why not go for the warmest insulation out there and get some 900 fill from Ed Speer over at Speer Hammocks.

As for my hats; the Black Rock Hat… I make them into a beanie for a few reasons. They are extremely light, compress to nothing but are a simple hat design (a beanie) that can be work all day while hiking, chilling around camp or while sleeping. They aren't a balaclava covering every inch of your head but they do cover your entire head and ears down to the back of your neck. I felt the simple versatility was more important than making something you'd only use for sleeping.

I actually wear mine under my helmet when I climb, when I hike and when I sleep. It's got about 1/2 to 3/4 an inch of loft and is good to about 20 below zero. When you pop one on your head it's stepping away from the cold. Your head is instantly warm and because the hat is so light you almost don't know you are wearing anything.

Just my $.02

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Loading...