Topic

light pack/ heavy load/ backpain

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 6:39 am

recently bought a golite Pinnacle, 2 lbs. 0 oz. Volume: 4400 for a winter trip. I had to carry nearly 40lbs. Never before have I had back pain until after this trip (lower Back). Could it be from using this pack? Is this pack not made for large loads? Is there an arguments for the use of heavier packs when carrying that type of weight? I'm a novice who loves the idea of cutting weight wherever I can but not at the expense of my back.

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 6:58 am

Hi Rick – I would say it is a possibility. I used Jam for awhile and I found it very uncomfortable anywhere near the 30lb rated limit. For me, it was fine at about 20 lbs. Given the Pinnacle is similar…..40 lbs would be overloading it.

Did you use the rolled sleeping pad method? Alternative?

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 7:06 am

I had a similar experience with a Jam2 at 28 lbs. I would expect at 40 on that pack it is probably pushing it quite a bit.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 7:27 am

Rick:

The issue is picking the right tools to handle the task at hand.

Did you not read up on your pack before you buy it? Not doing so is like grabbing a sleeping bag off the shelf without reading the specs — and then complaining that it didn't keep you warm.

For most people, a frameless pack (like yours) is good for loads between 20-25 lbs. A pack with a light frame is good to 35lbs. Much more than that, then you would want to go for something beefier.

The proper way to choose a backpack is as follows:

1. FIRST, decide what it will be carrying. This means you should shop for your pack toward the end, when you've got all your other gear pieces already. Then you will have a much better idea of the pack volume and carrying capability needed. ***

2. Second, have your torso length measured and select a pack accordingly — matching torso length, volume, fit and comfort, design features, price, etc.

3. Third, once purchased, you must load up your pack and "hike" somewhere nearby for 1-2 hours. If no particular sore spot or discomfort, then you're done. It's always better to find out everything before you take it out for that long trip.

Hope this helps.

*** You may think that you're ready to shop again since you've got everything else already. But No. Now that you've gone through a trip — do a rigorous post mortem on your existing gear first:

1. Did you bring too much stuff? Most people do on their first couple of trips. What can you safely ditch?

2. All the other stuff you feel you need — can any of them do double duty — so you can ditch a few more pieces?

3. After #2, are there still pieces that you wish to substitute with lighter versions?

Only after you've settled on your gear pieces should you then shop for your pack. Imagine the waste of time and effort if you go out and buy a beefy pack now — only to end up lightening your load down later — and then getting stuck with an overly beefy and heavy pack!

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 7:32 am

I use my Pinnacle for high volume, but light loads. I got stuck with the trash on the last Boy Scout trip, and I could feel the pack flex in the middle and put weight on my shoulders. Not too fun. In hindsight, I should have made sure I had the compression straps cinched down to stiffen the pack. I put a piece of Coroplast in the back panel of my son's Pinnacle, and it seemed to help with a pretty big load this summer in northern NM. Of course, he's 15 and bulletproof.

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 7:58 am

Did you weigh out your load or just estimating the 40lbs?
I just got a Pinnacle last week and am trying the rolled pad method with hydration pack as well. I have a linkrest I cut to size and also have a 2L platypus. I would guess this pack would be best at under 35lbs (manufacturer's specs) with half of this being water / food weight that will go down over time. I added up my winter gear list last night and am at around 20lbs and think this pack could handle enough food for 3-4 days comfortably.

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:04 am

Ben – sounds like you have had the pleasure of doing the process you described….several times. ;)

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:14 am

Yes and no, David.

My very first (virgin) backpack was a REI Morning Star 4200 ci. That trip gave me my first practical experience with backpacking. After my second trip, I did quite a bit of gear elimination, consolidation and substitution (big words, eh?) — and settled for my current backpack — my beloved Mountainsmith Ghost. I use this for all my "regular" trips.

I also have a UL set up — and here, I've played many different models. They all carry pretty much the same, but hey, I like to fondle gear — esp. packs and tents. I've tried (and liked) Fanatic Fringe Thompson Peak, Golite Dawn (love their shoulder straps the best), and Zpack Z1.

Just about the only frameless packs that are actually uncomfortable for me are the Gossamer Gear series (G4, etc.). The shoulder straps are much too wide for my narrow chest. Just goes to show that you've got to try them out before you know. :)

James Klein BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:18 am

Rick, it is fairly reasonable to assume the frameless pack at that weight would cause back pain. With a frameless pack nearly all of the weight will be carried on your shoulders and thus transfered down through your spine (creating a bending and compressive stress). With a framed back more of the load is transfered to your hips (bypassing your spine). The weight at which this would cause problems for your back is not easy to predict but above 25lbs is a pretty good starting estimate. I carried about 30lbs in this same pack (the women's version) this weekend and my back didn't really bother me anymore than usual.

James Klein BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:33 am

The whole idea of waiting until you have made your mind up on all of your gear before purchasing a pack seems kinda silly to me. To me lightening your pack weight is a dynamic undertaking. Im sure most people try quite a few things (shelters, stoves, insulation, etc..) before they figure out what works for them. The only way to effectively determine what works is to try it out — you need a pack to do this. Furthermore you need different equipment for different locations, seasons & durations. For me a: lightweight daypack, a larger frameless pack and a medium framed pack will take care of nearly all trips I anticipate taking.
Also, he wasn't complaining about the pack, just asking for advice. I see nothing wrong with testing the limits of his pack to find his comfort range.

Nick Gatel BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:34 am

Rick,

Maybe posting your gear list will help. But it sounds like too much weight for the structure of the pack. Or maybe you strained your back doing something else?

With lighter loads you can cover more distance in shorter time. Here I hike, sometimes I need to carry the heaviest consumable of all; water. So occassionally I need to use a big robust pack either a Gregory Whitney 95 or a Kelty Serac External frame. These can carry heavy loads and the weight is transfered to the hips… usually resulting in sore hips until the body gets used to it.

However, over the past couple of years I have only needed to use a big pack only once. I have found that with UL equipment and techniques, I can travel twice as far. Where I used to do 10 miles a day, I can now do 20 miles. I cannot see where one would need 40lbs, unless carrying a lot of water. The exception would be where you would be doing technical climbing and the need for ropes and specialized equipment.

The other thing, as Ben stated is to keep the weight within the limits set by the manufacturer. I have a GG Mariposa Plus that has a top limit of 30lbs, and has an aluminum stay. The most I have ever carried with this pack is 25 lbs and it did the job admirably. My ULA Conduit also does a good job, if the weight is within specs of 25lbs max.

Does GoLite publish weight ratings? If I remember correctly when I was shopping around, the Pinnacle does not have any kind of stay, but relies only on a foam pad for support. Without any kind of a stay or internal frame mechanism, I would not carry over 25 lbs with this pack.

Just my 2 cents.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 8:42 am

The whole idea of waiting until you have made your mind up on all of your gear before purchasing a pack seems kinda silly to me. To me lightening your pack weight is a dynamic undertaking. Im sure most people try quite a few things (shelters, stoves, insulation, etc..) before they figure out what works for them.

Methinks you are right that it is a dynamic process, but waiting to choose your pack after the dust has settled at least a bit will reduce the number of iterations/purchases. But YMMV — we have different decision-making processes.

I see nothing wrong with testing the limits of his pack to find his comfort range.

Right again. Manufacturer guidelines are just that — and fit/comfort are subjective. But methinks it's preferable to do the testing soon after purchase — find out if the pack's a keeper or not — before embarking on a long hike.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 9:21 am

Is it just me, or does Ben have a lot of "beloved" gear?? And that gear fondling…….I'm not sure that's even legal in Texas…..

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 10:54 am

I decided to try the pinnacle as a way to cut down on weight of course. I bought it not intending it to be a heavy load mover, rather a light summer bag. I have an EMS 7000 with a nice sturdy frame I've carried sizable first backpacking trip loads with, with no prob (40lbs estimated). It most definitely is an oversight not checking the specs on the pack to find weight limits. 40 lbs is most def pushing it with this pack. Had I gone 25 lbs I most likely would not have posted here. Its tru, I felt a majority of the weight on the shoulders not the hips. Couple that with "not the best posture" I have been unable to escape soreness for a couple weeks now.

Unfortunately, i am not methodical enough to shop for a bag after I have weighed my gear. All my gear I try to use in multiple situations, which was the same for this pack. I didn't buy the pinnacle expecting it to be the jack of only one trade.

Whats the rolled sleeping pad method?

There's nothing worse than back pain when you love an activity called BACK-PACKING!

Thank you so much for all the advice.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 6, 2010 at 11:11 am

Hey, nothing like learning from experience (we've all gone thought that). Treat all your gear pieces as a "system" to make sure they work well with each other.

As for the rolled pad method — you simply roll up your sleeping pad into a circle and drop it into your frameless backpack. You then pack everything inside that circle and cinch up tight. This gives your pack some "form" and serves as a substitute for a pack frame. Not really, of course, but sort of — and good enough when your pack weight is 25 lbs or less (YMMV).

But I prefer the fold flat method. You fold your sleeping pad in half lengthwise, then fold into thirds to match the size of your backpack (more or less). With your backpack flat (shoulder straps right on the floor) — you slide the folded pad in — and pack everything else on top. A folded pad gives you more layers flat against your back and provides for a firmer "frame" when the pack's all cinched up.

PostedJan 6, 2010 at 11:15 am

Ah yes – what Ben said.

I too prefer the folded pad against my pack because I use an inflatable. If I used a closed cell pad, the roll method would be used.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 7, 2010 at 9:40 am

It's already been said: too much weight for the pack. The volume is really just for bulky light gear… adding a 0*F sleeping bag to the pack, for example. The pack isn't a "jack of one trade;" a 25-pound load limit would give many people enough pack for a week-long trip.

If you want to keep the weight of your actual pack down, but not have back pain, and can't get your loaded pack weight down, then you need a framed pack. The rolled sleeping pad deal will help w/a frameless, but it's no match for a framed pack. The GoLite Quest might be something to consider, same volume, framed, ~3#. An Osprey Exos 58 at ~2#, framed. Maybe a Gossamer Gear Mariposa Plus?

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
Loading...