Topic

Which Bivy?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Ed Tyanich BPL Member
PostedJan 1, 2010 at 9:25 pm

I an looking at gettung an MLB bivy this year and am debating between the Superlite and the Soul Bivy Side Zip.

Any comments on these is appreciated.

Miner BPL Member
PostedJan 1, 2010 at 10:15 pm

I vote for the superlite bivy since that was my choice after debating this very choice last spring.

The superlite bivy works well and its a little lighter. It has a side zipper and a mesh net for the face so what else do you want for 3 season use? I used it for 60% of nights on the PCT this year and it doesn't really stink which is pretty impressive for something used that much without being washed. My only complaint with it was it was soo breathable that in a strong cold wind enough wind got through it (unlike with my old DWP fabric one), I felt cold until I threw my silnylon rain skirt over it to better break the wind. But this isn't really an issue of the bivy with its momentum fabric, but rather my choice of a campsite and not using my tarp to try to block the wind.

PostedJan 1, 2010 at 11:53 pm

Hi,

I ordered a Superlight last week from Ron.

My choice was based on weight, price and NeoAir compatability.

should have it soon and will be able to comment a little further.

Cheers
Mark

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 7:40 am

I used the superlight last summer and fall. It's a great piece, as is all of Ron's gear now ain't it. I just wanted the lower weight. I ordered a large(and I'm 5'9"~175) so I would have more room for layering if needed and any gear storage near head. Glad I did, bc if not it would have been tiiiiigght.

I wish the netting was a tad larger(although it must be a delicate balance for protection)-but overall I can manage. I think Ron made a netting change this year. After looking at the wired option on soul I think I would appreciate that now bc attaching the loop to my shelter can be a pain at times.

Very breathable for 90 percent of conditions 3 season and fine wind protection although I had several nightmarish experiences in 65-75 humid nights. Going for inner net for those nights.

I don't think the pad straps are necessary for me-I put pad inside bivy and never have issues. Maybe it has it's uses that I haven't encountered.

I think addition of all event footbox is great , and nothing more is needed. It's a sweet bivy and a decent price.
Now that I thk of this–I would like a combo of superlight and soul side zip. ha.

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedJan 2, 2010 at 7:46 am

I have a MLD Superlite Bivy on the way as well, this is looking promising. This is my first bivy setup as well so thanks for the input everybody. Things I like about it on paper, simple and effective design, super light hence the name, and Momentum top. Good luck with your selection Ed.

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 9:51 am

I just used my new MLD Superlight bivy for the first time this week in Joshua Tree. I ordered the medium. I found it to be pretty tight with a WM Summerlite on top of a NeoAir Small that was also in there with me. I'm 5'10" 138 lbs. The bivy was staked out and my poles were set up to hold the cord that keeps the mesh off my face… my nose still touched the mesh…

Temps dropped to 30F, and I woke up to ice on the inside of the bivy and all over the top of my bag. Everything was touching, so I figured this was going to be the case. I just wasn't liking it after the second night. I was wanting a little more space in there for the NeoAir.

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 10:08 am

For the price, you can't really beat the 2010 Alpine Bivy by MLD. Ron is making me one right now with a custom net like the Soul Bivy. $40 custom gear charge. Not bad at all.

I've also got a Superlight Bivy on the way. I'll post you some of my thoughts after they arrive and see some use.

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 2:05 pm

Now you all have me concerned with the size I ordered.

Im 5'11, will use it with a NeoAir and quilt, I ordered a regular perhaps it should have been a large?

Cheers

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 5:12 pm

I had Ron specially make mine large width regular length, since I'm short. It holds a regular length NeoAir just fine, or even a regular length DownMat 7. This was the 2009 model before Ron tweaked the regular SuperLight to hold the NeoAir.

PostedJan 2, 2010 at 10:17 pm

So I'm a little confused on size as well. I'm about 6'2 190lbs. Would the large MLD Alpine bivy or superlight bivy fit me with a WM ultralite 20 degree bag and a neoair style pad?

I've never used a bivy before and am a little concerned that if it was too snug it might turn me off to using a bivy.

PostedJan 3, 2010 at 1:19 am

Contact Ron and see what he says,

I am 5' 11 and re-ordered a large to use with a neoair and quilt.

Cheers

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...