Topic

“Weak” lofting down

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
PostedJan 1, 2010 at 4:22 pm

I recently purchased a new Mont-Bell Alpine Down Hugger #1 for mild low-altitude winter and shoulder season use. It's rated to -10 C at 1040g (Long) with 20 oz 800fp down.

It's not lofting very much. When I take it out of a compression bag and lay it out, it will be flat as a pancake even if I leave it for several hours and come back. If I spend a few minutes fluffing it up, I can get significant improvement of maybe 4-5" loft in some spots, but there seems to be an excess of fabric so it's hard to tell if the down is actually lofting that much or if it's just the fabric being supported by itself up.
It feels very warm crawling inside while in my unheated room, but the lack of loft has me worried (the problem is, the place I bought it from will only allow me to return it if I HAVEN'T slept outside in it).

At first I was concerned about underfill but the bag actually comes in quite overweight at 1200 grams. There is a lot of down in here, it just doesn't loft very well.
Despite that, holding it up to the light, there are always spots where I can see through there is no insulation at all, no matter how I try to redistribute the down.

Other -10 C bags I've seen look to be "bursting at the seams" with loft, but this one always looks deflated and wrinkly.

Is it possible for supposed 800-fill down to be defective and "weak"? If I push down on the sleeping bag anywhere, it will never spring back up until I fluff it. What would cause this?

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 1, 2010 at 4:46 pm

Brad:

I think it's pretty well known the MB bags don't loft much — esp. not when compared to, say, Western Mountaineering.

When I got my first MB bag — a No. 3 rated to 32F — I was very disappointed (and worried) that the thin little package wouldn't keep me warm @ Wind Rivers — my upcoming hike back then. I took extra insulation layers despite the added weight because the bag just seemed so utterly unconvincing!

To my very pleasant surprise, the bag performed marvelously and the temp rating was spot on for me (I view myself as an average sleeper — neither overly hot nor cold).

So unless someone at the plant grossly under filled the bag, you should have no problems. How can you tell if it's underfilled? Well, the shell/liner material shouldn't vary by much. So if actual bag weight is same as or very close to stated weight, then the filling should be correct.

If you are still worried, try sleeping in it — wearing long johns and socks — to make sure you don't dirty it in any way.

Have fun with your new bag. I expect you will soon be liking it a lot.

PostedJan 1, 2010 at 7:37 pm

I agree with Benjamin. I had the same initial reactions to my UL SS #2, but upon actual use realized that it is more than true to its temperature rating. I've slept in mine to 12F degrees (its rated to 25F) with just winter base layers and a fleece vest under a tarp. More than happy.

PostedJan 3, 2010 at 11:38 pm

I'm curious if anyone has any ideas why Mont-Bell bags loft less than the competition, considering they use the same amount of down as most competitors.
The thing that really confuses me is the amount of manual fluffing required to get the loft back after compression. I've never seen or felt down behave like that before – even 575 duck down springs back quickly.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 4, 2010 at 6:32 am

Brad:

Did you examine/weigh your bag to make sure it's in line with specs?

If so, then I wouldn't worry about it. Not an expert on bag design, but read up on MB bag construction — their bags are more elastic or "hugging" — rather than expansive — which they claim is more efficient (and as a user I agree).

Richard Nisley BPL Member
PostedJan 4, 2010 at 8:15 am

Bradley,

I have answered this question many times and in great technical detail. Please search the forum for my prior posts on this topic if you would prefer a comprehensive technical explanation. If a simple laymen’s explanation is satisfactory, “Down has a density range from fully lofted until ~2.5x increased density in which the clo/oz stays the same even though the loft goes down with the increased density. The elastic in the Montbell Super Stretch series compresses the down in this linear range.”

For my most recent related post my post see the thread “MontBell UL Spiral Down Hugger Sleeping Bag Review.” http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=26645&skip_to_post=220054#220054 Look at the Excel table items in red, in my post to Casey, and notice the correlation between the loft of the bags and the EN13537 lab tested temperature ratings.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 4, 2010 at 8:39 am

"The elastic in the Montbell Super Stretch series compresses the down in this linear range.”

In case someone forms a mental picture of a semi-scrunged up and ineffective bag — the MontBell design works — speaking from actual user experience (and I know I speak not just for myself but the many MB fans here as well).

The elastics "pull in" the bag internally to decrease dead air space that your body would otherwise have to work to keep heating up. This explains why the entire bag doesn't loft up as much as bags with more traditional designs. Also, MB claims that this design allows it to use less down — and thus less weight for the same warmth.

The real beauty to me, is that the elastics "pull in" just enough to be efficient — you will not feel like you're being rubber banded or anything. Indeed, the superstretch feature allows you greater movements than most traditional bags — great news for ye larger folks who crave ultralight but find the traditional ones too narrow and constrictive.

Note: In case anyone is suspicious, I am merely a happy MB bag owner and have no affiliations whatsoever with the company or any of its distributors/retailers.

PostedJan 4, 2010 at 1:48 pm

"The elastic in the Montbell Super Stretch series compresses the down in this linear range.”

I had considered this, but the Alpine Down Hugger (not Super Stretch) only has elastic stitching on the inner liner but not the outer. This has the effect of pulling the down closer to the body and actually EXPANDING (not compressing) the baffles because the outer pretty much stays put (from observation).
It would be observable if the down was being compressed by the fabric. In this case, it seems as though the down itself is unusual, not the bag design. It doesn't expand to fill the space in the baffle – neither completely nor nearly as much as in comparable bag designs using the same quantity of down.

Perhaps I'm missing something, but it really appears as though there is something different about the down that Mont-Bell is using.
I do believe, thanks to user reports here, that due to the bag's design (and the fact that I've verified my copy to actually be overweight), it will probably be as warm as advertised. I'm just interested in learning more about what appears to be a its down that behaves differently from what I've seen before.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedJan 4, 2010 at 2:37 pm

Good to know your bag is true to spec.

But stating the obvious, warmth is subjective and despite my loving MB bags — you may feel different after trying yours. Any way you can try it out somewhere close by for one night (like a nearby car camp where your car and an extra bag can be on stand by?

If not, I would recommend that you do what I did — make sure you have an extra insulation layer just in case. After that, love it or hate it, you'll have a good handle on your bag's performance.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedJan 5, 2010 at 4:14 pm

If you can look through a bag and see big empty spots where there's nothing between 2 layers of nylon, the bag simply isn't filled enough. IMO, a well-made bag doesn't require futzing and fluffing and praying to get it to loft properly, nor does it have spots where you can clearly see that there's no insulation. That said, I'm sure the elastic does bear some effect on the loft, but… no surprises to anyone, but I'd recommend checking out a WM Apache, or maybe a Marmot Helium.

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...