I recently purchased a new Mont-Bell Alpine Down Hugger #1 for mild low-altitude winter and shoulder season use. It's rated to -10 C at 1040g (Long) with 20 oz 800fp down.
It's not lofting very much. When I take it out of a compression bag and lay it out, it will be flat as a pancake even if I leave it for several hours and come back. If I spend a few minutes fluffing it up, I can get significant improvement of maybe 4-5" loft in some spots, but there seems to be an excess of fabric so it's hard to tell if the down is actually lofting that much or if it's just the fabric being supported by itself up.
It feels very warm crawling inside while in my unheated room, but the lack of loft has me worried (the problem is, the place I bought it from will only allow me to return it if I HAVEN'T slept outside in it).
At first I was concerned about underfill but the bag actually comes in quite overweight at 1200 grams. There is a lot of down in here, it just doesn't loft very well.
Despite that, holding it up to the light, there are always spots where I can see through there is no insulation at all, no matter how I try to redistribute the down.
Other -10 C bags I've seen look to be "bursting at the seams" with loft, but this one always looks deflated and wrinkly.
Is it possible for supposed 800-fill down to be defective and "weak"? If I push down on the sleeping bag anywhere, it will never spring back up until I fluff it. What would cause this?

