Topic

Mountainsmith Ghost vs. ULA Ohm

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 8:32 pm

Both Mountainsmith Ghost and ULA Ohm feature a Delrin hoop frame for loads up to 30lbs. Both are roughly comparable in size. But the ULA Ohm is almost a pound lighter.

For those who have actual experience with the ULA Ohm and either the MS Ghost or GG Vapor Trail — how does the Ohm compare to either when carrying a 25lbs load?

PostedDec 26, 2009 at 8:46 pm

You might be waiting a long time for someone with experience with both, so I'll offer my experience with the Ohm. Carries 25 pounds easily, in my opinion. Comfortable pack, rides well. Love mine. A bit squeaky, which might bother some. Doesn't bother me.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:03 pm

Thanks, Doug.

The Ghost was discontinued about 2-3 years ago and I figure other Ghost users might have migrated to the Ohm to save a pound or so. In any case, I've modified my post somewhat to include Ohm / GG Vapor Trail users as well. Maybe that will shorten the wait a tiny bit?

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:07 pm

The one obvious difference is that the Ghost is a panel loader and the Ohm is a top loader. I used a Mountainsmith Phantom for a long time and the old Mountainlight series of packs were great packs in their day. What is prompting the change?

PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:10 pm

Ben – can't comment on the Ghost, but compared to the Vapor Trail, the OHM carries very similar. Both have very good compression and load transfer.

The VT appears perhaps more robust, as it should given the weight. The hip belt on the VT is much better in my opinion for heavier loads in the mid 20 range. @ 28 pounds or so (max I had ever carried in both), I found the VT more comfortable but the OHM was no slouch.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:18 pm

Brad — No change per se, but just a question coming from an enquiring, gear-freakish mind. I love my MS Ghost for its wonderful carrying comfort, but also wondering if the ULA Ohm can match this while being almost a pound lighter? My comparison is strictly focused on carrying comfort at around 25lbs. — and not features/usability.

David — Your feedback confirms what I suspected — that the added weight of the VT's heftier hipbelt pays dividends when carrying a heavier load — such as your 28lbs example. To be fair though, 28lbs would be approaching the far end of the comfort range of my beloved MS Ghost as well.

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:27 pm

I used an original ghost for 5 years. It was and still is my favorite pack for sub 30 lb loads. I found the ghost very comfortable at 25 and ok at 30. The bottom of the ghost eventually wore through. The newer model ghost never fit me right.

I carried the ohm for the first 1500 mi on the pct this summer. It carries very similar to the ghost in that he combination of delrin rod and load lifters form to my back. The adjustable atachment point for the load lifters fits a wider range of torso lengths. At 25 lbs the ohm is barely comfortable. The minimal hipbelt means very little weight can be transferred to the hips. 25 to 30 lbs on my shoulders was too much over long days. Pockets and compression on the ohm are great.

If my full load starts at 25 and will mostly be significantly less I'll take the ohm. Otherwise I use a vapor trail.

PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:34 pm

Ben,

When my Starlite pack gets here, I'd be happy to send you the Ohm (medium with medium hipbelt) to try on if you'd like. You'd have to pay shipping both ways, of course. And I'd prefer you just loaded and walked around your apt./house, and not actually take it backpacking. I know, too many rules!

Take care,

Doug

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 9:50 pm

"The minimal hipbelt means very little weight can be transferred to the hips. 25 to 30 lbs on my shoulders was too much over long days."

I am getting the picture where all three packs (GGVT, MSGhost, ULA Ohm) are very well designed — but differences in comfort start to show at loads nearing 30lbs — where the hefty GGVT belt helps to make that pack the most comfortable of the three — follow by MSGhost, and ULA Ohm.

Perhaps it is at loads somewhere below the mid 20's that the ULA Ohm becomes 'just right' while the other two packs become unnecessarily 'hefty'.

Doug — Thanks for your offer, I'll definitely keep it in mind. Have fun with your new toy! I'll be very interested in your comparison between ULA and SMD.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 10:40 pm

I have tried the Ghost, GG VT, and the Ohm. The GG VT was my go to pack for six years (loved it's carry comfort, but found it inconvenient to use which is why I tried other packs). I tried the Ghost several years ago but didn't find it as comfortable as the VT so I sold it. This spring I tried the Ohm to save weight and do away with the extra volume I didn't need. I sold the Ohm toward the end of the summer because I didn't find it as comfortable as the VT. While use was separated by several years, I would say that the Ghost was more comfortable to carry than the Ohm.

Reasons I didn't keep the Ohm: the hip belt a bit inadequate for me when carrying 25lbs (my hips a very sensitive to pressure) and the stays where too strait so the pack didn't transfer the weight as comfortably as a pack with a more curved back. While minor, other thing that contributed to the Ohm not being as comfortable as either the Ghost or VT was the lack of padding on the back panel.

–Mark

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 10:58 pm

Thanks, Mark. If anybody has used all three packs (and many more) — it's you. :)

BTW, what is your "go to" pack now for weights in the 20-25lbs range?

John G BPL Member
PostedDec 27, 2009 at 6:54 am

Mark,
Do you think the VT or Gorilla (or something else) is more comfortable at 30-35 pounds ?
Thanks.

PostedDec 27, 2009 at 6:57 am

John – although I wasn't asked directly, I will comment that I found the VT not comfortable at that weight. However, the Granite Gear Ozone is! It really is insanely comfortable for such a light pack at that load.

PostedDec 27, 2009 at 7:24 am

Ben – if you measure well on the 'short torso' scale for ULA, the ULA Catalyst is on sale (2008 model) for $160. New.

Gear Enabler, Dave

PostedDec 27, 2009 at 8:13 am

I have both the Ghost and the Ohm. They both carry loads similarly, as previously indicated. The skimpy hipbelt pads on the Ohm have not been an issue with my frame. The main difference for me is that the padded back panel on the Ghost makes my back sweat less, where in warmer weather my Ohm soaks my back. Otherwise, the Ohm is my go-to pack.

PostedDec 27, 2009 at 5:43 pm

"how does the Ohm compare to either when carrying a 25lbs load?"

Not much difference up to 25#, although the MS Ghost hipbelt is inherently more comfortable. At loads beyond 25# the Ohm will become progressively less comfortable as it begins to sag into the small of your back, whereas the Ghost will continue to carry comfortably up into the mid 30's. I used it on the Bath Lakes High Route, a strenuous offtrail traverse in Glacier Peak Wilderness, with an initial weight of 37# and it carried like a dream over some pretty rough terrain. I wish MS would bring it back, updated with new materials and shorn of some unnecessary bits and pieces. If they did, they would have a worthy competitor for the Ohm.

P.S.

I still have my old gray Ghost and occasionally take it out for a spin. Sort of like driving an old 57 Chevy, I guess.
Fond memories of great trips…

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
Loading...