Topic

WM Flight and MB Inner for Winter Camping to 10F

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
Richard Nisley BPL Member
PostedDec 26, 2009 at 5:04 pm

MY RESPONSE
The original question is the bottom half of this forum post. I get a large number of private requests to do thermal systems analysis but I don’t have the spare time to do most of them. A request that has potential broad interest generally moves up in my To-Do list so that many people can benefit from my effort. I will first do a complete summary analysis for continuity. Any questions, not addressed in my summary analysis, will then be answered individually.

10F at 1.5 MET, blocked from the wind, requires 4.45 Tclo to be thermo neutral. The defined base layers are approximately 1 clo.

The Iclo of your WM flight jacket is 3.32 and will cover 48% of your body surface area (BSA)

The Iclo of MB UL inner pants is 1.66 and the BSA is 43%

The Iclo of the Patagonia PO (PGD) is 1.06 and the BSA is 48%. The jacket tested much lower than the insulation specification. Last year I found this general pattern for different synthetic insulation garments from a wide range of vendors.

The Iclo of the light fleece cap and the merino wool buff is .75 and the BSA is 8% (assumes this combo is ~.200" thick)

The clo total for your down jacket and pants is 1.96
The defined base layers is 1.00 clo
The Tclo 3.56

This amount of insulation provides 1.5 MET thermo neutrality at 26F
Adding in your optional Patagonia PO (PGD) increases the Tclo by .509, and changes the 1.5 MET thermo neutrality temp to 17F. The 2 MET, with the PO, temperature is -8F.

Most people subconsciously stand rather than sit in order to up their MET rate from 1.5 to 2.0 when necessary. This is why I typically provide both the 1.5 MET and 2 MET temperature ratings for camp chores.

-Your estimate of the WM flight jacket Iclo value was very well done; there is only a .28 Iclo difference in our values

-Again your estimate was extremely accurate; there is only a .16 Iclo difference

-The only mistake in your analysis is your clo total value. Rather than just add the Iclo values you have to factor them for their relative contribution to the total BSA.

ANALYSIS REQUEST
I am planning a trip where I'd like to be comfortable sitting and talking (1.5 MET from your chart) down to 10 degrees. From the chart you posted in an earlier thread, it looks like I need a total clo of between 4.5-6.5. I am a 28yo male of average build 5'10" and 180lbs. My current clothing plans are:

Lightweight wool boxer briefs

Lightweight Smartwool zip-t

Lightweight merino long underwear

Darn Tough Vermont Full Cushion Boot Socks

Light Hikers with Goretex Membrane

MontBell Down Inner Pants

WM Flight Jacket

Powerstretch Liner gloves

300 weight fleece mittens

Light fleece cap and merino wool buff as balaclava

Although you have not mentioned specifically testing the WM Flight Jacket, based on your tests of the MB Alpine down jacket and others with similar down fill oz., I am estimating the Flight has a clo of 3.5. Is that accurate?

Based on the down inner pants having a fill weight of 2oz and your mentioned BSA covered by pants at 43%, is a clo value of 1.5 reasonable?

Combined with my baselayers, should that put me around a total clo of 5.5?

First of all, are these numbers reasonable? Second, do you think this is sufficient for my goals or should I plan on also bringing my Patagonia MicroPuff pullover (Polarguard Delta) to wear over the down jacket?

Thank you SO MUCH for any information you can provide.

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
Loading...