Topic

SMD Lunar Solo Enhanced

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Mart BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 7:03 am

I am considering a solo single wall tent and want advice from actual owners. An older, BPL tent comparison article said that the older Solo was a "5 out of 5" on condensation. What say actual owners? Is the center placement of your trekking pole tent support a problem as far as interior space utilization? If you had a "do over," would you buy the same tent?

PostedDec 24, 2009 at 7:21 am

As a former Lunar Solo E owner I'd recommend the TarpTent Sublite Sil instead. I found it difficult to get a good pitch for the Lunar Solo on anything less than level ground, and when not taught the fabric tended to drape over my face. The Sublite, for me, is a much better designed tent.

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 9:09 am

I'd like to offer a different opinion as a former owner as well. I too found the Lunar "fussy" to set up taut at first — but after just a few tries, it all becomes very intuitive and a proper set up is very quick and very easy. But YMMV as they say.

When it comes to wind stability, I actually prefer the one-pole setup. So long as the tent is staked down properly — the Lunar deflects winds from pretty much all directions. Two-pole configurations will give you more headroom, but IMHO, they are not as solid in blowing winds as a one-pole tent nicely staked down. Should you encounter low to moderate snowfall, the one-pole configuration will handle that better as well.

Condensation will be a fact of life when used in humid areas. No way around this if you consider that double wall tents and even tarps will collect condensation when conditions are 'right'. But the Lunar's slope and its all-around mesh (the first foot and a half or so from the floor) both help to minimize the chance of condensation actually dripping down on you. Most will just wick their way to the mesh — harmlessly.

I really like the Lunar. So why am I now a former owner? I 'graduated' from 3/8" blue foam to 1.5" self-inflating pad and now the 2.5" air mattress. Because of the way the ceiling slopes down from the center toward both ends, the fabric gets too close to my face for comfort. This really is my only complaint and a subjective one at that. The Lunar is definitely a worthy option.

PostedDec 24, 2009 at 9:17 am

I'm a current owner, and I'll second what Ben says. After setting up the tent several times, I have no trouble getting a good, taut pitch in a variety of situations.

I especially like the side entry, and the ability to open up the tent in good weather.

For a bug-proof, 3 season shelter, I can't envision using anything else…

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 12:00 pm

My solo was a good tent, took a few tries to figure out how to get it taut, but no big deal. I just thought it had a really big footprint, and I wanted a Tarptent Moment in the worst way, so I sold it.

Mark Hurd BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 4:18 pm

I have both a Lunar Solo and a Tarptent Contrail. During a backpacking trip in the central Rockies a couple of years ago I lent the Contrail to a buddy, so both tents came along. When pitched next to each other in identical conditions the Solo always had way more condensation than the Tarptent. To its credit the Solo probably offers a little more protection than the Contrail due to much larger fabric overhangs around the perimeter. But that in turn limits the air circulation in my experience. YMMV.

I like both tents, but have moved on the a tarp and hammock setup for most of my adventures.

Happy Trails.
-Mark

Bob Bankhead BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 4:47 pm

I have the Lunar Solo e, Gatewood Cape, TT Contrail, and TT Dble Rainbow, and have used each of them for several years here in the PNW.

The LSe is my "go to" shelter most of the time, althought the GC runs a close second, especially when I know I won't need bug screening.

That said, the LSe actually works better with a higher pitch than the 44 inches SMD recommends; I prefer 46 inches. This makes the bug screen end panels almost vertical instead of slanted and lets more air come under the canopy. You still get the great protected area. I've never had condensation in my LSe, but I also pick my camp sites carefully.

I'm vascillating now between the 26 oz LSe and the GC at 18 oz (with its net insert) for the Colorado Trail this summer. I really like having the space to keep my pack inside rather than under the vesitbule, so the LSe may get the nod.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedDec 24, 2009 at 9:46 pm

I also found more condensation in the Lunar Solo than in Tarptents. The long "skirts" on the LS do eliminate splash from heavy rain. On the other hand, the "skirts" appear to funnel moisture from the ground into the tent, especially when pitched on grass. I've seen moisture condensing on the "skirts" before it starts condensing inside the tent.

The longer pole does help a bit. One thing that did NOT help was trying to squeeze an 80-lb. dog into the LS with me. The two of us completely overwhelmed the ventilation system. Even with just me (no dog), when camped on the Olympic Peninsula coast in fog and drizzle, the LS was really soggy inside while there was no condensation in the Tarptent Rainshadow with three people inside pitched right next door.

The 2.5" thick insulated air pad I was using didn't help, either–I had to be extra careful not to brush my head and feet against the tent wall, even though I'm only 5'3".

On the positive side, the Lunar Solo shed wind, rain and hail really well during Colorado thunderstorms.

PostedDec 24, 2009 at 10:10 pm

I disconnected the eves tie outs from the floor tie outs because I couldn't get the eves high enough without doing so.Now I can get the interior netting vertical and I have more headroom. I had to add longer tie out straps and I now just use separate stakes for the floor or no stakes for the floor but either way the shelter sets up higher and vents better now. It does have a large footprint and most of the time I prefer the gatewood or my hammock.My son loves this shelter and has taken it over.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...