Topic

running pack

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
PostedDec 19, 2009 at 7:51 pm

I am looking for running pack. I have tried running w/ golite ion but there is noticeable jostling due to lack of compression system. I am thinking of planning more strategic routes w/ confirmed water, food, shelter availability in between. I can go more minimalist with no backpack and turn 2-3 day hikes into runs.. I may still need to carry some water, food and gear. I have searched the forums and below is the list of products I am considering.

hip packs?? this could be my first choice as gear I want to carry is very minimal and it would keep me cooler compare to other options.

Vest packs:
Ultimate Direction Wasp
Eider Runner Extrem (discontinued)
Salomon XT Wings Vest 10+3 Exp
Nathan 020

Vest/jersey:
Camelbak Racebak
camelbak velobak

Other DIY:
Platy Insulator.
http://www.cascadedesigns.com/Platypus/Hands-Free-Hydration/Insulator/product
I am thinking of it as minimalist hydration pack with built in insulation. Insulator has 3 D-rings. I am thinking of using them to make cord lock adjustable strap system. I will attach a custom waterproof stuff sack to add food/gear.
details of attachment: tie one end of the cord to top left loop – goes over the shoulder -passes through the bottom loop – goes over the shoulder – tie other end to the top right loop. There will be a cord lock to adjust the cord in order to off the pack or wear it securely.

It is possible that platy may not turn out to be as stable as I am imagining right now. Let me know if you think this is not really a good idea.

Aaron Sorensen BPL Member
PostedDec 19, 2009 at 10:00 pm

If you want stable go for the Osprey 11.
Just read the reviews and you'll see how good they are, (even better than the nathan)

The jersey's from C/Back are made for biking and slosh around like crazy.

Art … BPL Member
PostedDec 19, 2009 at 11:51 pm

it really all depends how much you actually plan to carry.

Nathan HPL 020
Has a lot of happy users out there, but it doesn't really hold that much after you fill the bladder.
you could run with 2 handhelds and use the entire pack for stuff.

PostedDec 20, 2009 at 12:30 am

Seems good. I have read the reviews of UD wasp which is suggested to be better then nathan too. Any idea how Wasp and talon would compare. Actually you were the one who recommended nathan several times previously, so thats saying something about osprey.

But I dont want to carry a pack if I can get away without it, mainly because I want to enjoy freedom from sweaty back and increase ventilation. My hikes are such that I am always a few hours away (when hiking, running would be faster ofcourse) from a village where I can get food/shelter. Is there any thing light, comfortable, stable hip solution? Else I am thinking of just going without anything.

Jonathan Ryan BPL Member
PostedDec 20, 2009 at 5:39 am

I have not used one, but the Inov8 pack designs look pretty cool. I like how the water bladder is positioned low around the waist. They are pretty light as well.

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedDec 20, 2009 at 7:30 am

Hey Huzefa, maybe you could cue us in to what items you bring along on your runs? Lightweight shell, blister package, a couple gels, cell phone? There are several waist packs on the market that range from the ultra minimal pocketless design to the full on gear toting waist pack capable of carrying 40+ oz. of water and gear. Nathan makes a variety of waist packs ranging from single bottle lumbar packs to dual bottle packs with ample storage for calories, wind shell, gloves, cell phone, etc. I personally own the Delaney Plus by Camelback a single bottle design and when I'm out for 2.5 hours or more I bring along a handheld to supplement, I found the Delaney to be more comfortable than the comparable Nathan, however everyones waist line is different.

PostedDec 20, 2009 at 9:37 am

I am skeptic about the inov8 horizontal bladder. Since Inov8 does NOT have s/m/l sizes I figure it has a waist belt rather than a hipbelt so weight would be on your shoulders.

My hiking gearlist:
golite ion
rainshell- used as windshirt at night only
CCF sleeping pad
torch
tshirt
trek pants or running shorts – I switch them depending on terrain and weather
phone
map/route info xerox
money
keys
2X water bottles
food – protein powder, muesli, dryfruits, nuts
hiking barefoot lately but after a few hours on rocky terrain it get painfully slow. I am experimenting with huaraches which should get me fast over rough terrain.

For running I think will have to upgrade my kit. Lighter/brighter LED, supplex or similar active shell that will replace both windshirt and tshirt. convertible pants. I have some supplex fabric but need a good patten, AYCE maybe. less food/water and more reliance on villages/ water sources on the route. I have considered getting UV purifier but I have never been sick. May be my body is just used to it.

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedDec 20, 2009 at 12:11 pm

It is going to be tough to find a lumbar pack capable of carrying all that gear, water, and calories and still enable you to run comfortably without continually cinching down the waist strap. Mountainsmith style lumbar packs might fit the bill in the volume and size department, however the design is more suitable for the casual day hiker, not the fast moving runner. You are essentially looking for a fastpack/running pack it sounds. Best bet is to look at something like the Nathan HPL #759 pack or the Nathan HPL #063 AR backpack/harness system, famed ultrarunner David Horton used this on his PCT speed record attempt which involved a ton of running and speedhiking. This pack in particular has hipbelt wings and dual mesh hipbelt pockets, dual 22oz. bottle holsters at the waist region (essentially like a lumbar pack in that the weight is carried low), and a 2000ci. carrying capacity. I personally haven't used this pack but from what I've seen and heard of Nathan hydration harness users, they are very stable and comfortable and bouncing isn't an issue at all. The Osprey pack mentioned earlier would definitely work as well, there are larger volume packs in the Osprey Talon line if more is needed.

Salomon offers the XT Wings, XA Pro 10+3 or the XA Pro 20 packs for faster paced treks in the mountains as well. These packs look great for up to 2-3 days like the trips you mentioned. The latter 2 packs have hipbelts and hipbelt pockets, side bottle holsters, larger pack body for gear, and design features that enable you to hike/run comfortably. I've seen these packs customized as well, adding a front pocket and dual bottle hosters to the shoulder straps.

The Salomon and Nathan packs would enable you to still incorporate your 2 bottles in your gear list rather than adapt to an internal hydration bladder. The advantage I think that the Nathan line has is the cordage, stretch pockets and storage for items such as your sleeping pad, clothing and small items.

Are you trekking/running point to point staying at hostels, hotels? Or does the terrain and climate where you live enable you to sleep on trail with such a small list? I noticed you didn't list any shelter or sleeping insulation.

Aaron Sorensen BPL Member
PostedDec 20, 2009 at 12:28 pm

The Wasp is a little tighter of a pack making it a little better for running. However the shoulders are just webbing, so if weight wasn't an issue and the 9 litters is fine, it's a good pack.
The Wasp is very close to the Nathan 020 as far as comfort and as a " running pack" goes, only bigger. If nathan had a 9 litter pack close to the 020, you wouldn’t't be able to tell the difference between the 2.
The nathan synergy may be a better choice for you with 900 ci.

The Osprey can hold whatever weight you can pill in it very comfortably and doesn't budge or slosh at all. It is more of a hiking pack that works well for running.
The other 2 will work better if the load is at minimal weight.

The osprey is also slightly bigger but also has more useable space and a 3 litter water capacity. Be careful, only the 2009 version has side pockets on the hip.
You could literally fill the talon up with rocks and have it be comfy to carry.

I also have an Inov8 race-pro 12 pack. I just don't like it because it will not tranfere any weight off your shoulders or conform to your back all that well.
The sides going around the waist also rub me raw on my hip bones due to the fabric. It is not a good running pack, but would do good for fastpacking as long as all the weight being on your shoulders isn't an issue.
On the good side, the space is very useable.

For their size, (not comparing one to another),
I would give the nathan 020 a 10, the Wasp a 9, the osprey a 9.5 and the inov8 a 4.

I also have on old nathan 859. It does not disperse weight either. It is very useful and is the perfect size for an overnight trip in the mountains, but I would only give it a 7.

for what you are after, I would give the following rating.
1. osprey
2. wasp
3. nathan synergy
4. nathan 020
5. many others other than the inov8
99. inov8

PostedDec 20, 2009 at 9:00 pm

That some superb info. Thanks for sharing.

I wasnt clear about running gear list. This is what i am planning:

Worn:
supplex shirt
supplex convertible pants
CCF rolled/strapped to my back

carried:
one water bottle
food
LED
map xerox
money
key
phone

Is there any hip pack that will carry all this super comfortably?

Or is there a need for better engineering?
http://www.mchalepacks.com/sarc/03.htm

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedDec 20, 2009 at 11:49 pm

Oh geesh… McHale? Where is this going Huzefa? :) I'm confused, one minute you seem set on a lightweight lumbar pack design to tote your minimal gear list for multiday runs now we're gravitating towards a whole different beast? I honestly think you can get something to suit your needs for a mere fraction of the cost of a McHale pack. The McHale website is cryptic to me, confusing at best, good luck figuring out what pack there will work for you.

PostedDec 20, 2009 at 11:57 pm

see the link. I am just wondering if that hipbelt design can be used to design a better hip pack. Main feature is that it has duel buckles which stabilize the top and the bottom of the load.

Eugene Smith BPL Member
PostedDec 21, 2009 at 12:03 am

Or perhaps the joke went clear over my head!? :) I will say Huzefa, your CCF pad must be made of lead if you need a hipbelt worthy of a sherpa or toting the occasional teenage boy on your back! Granted, there is nothing funny about huffing 100 lbs. up a mountain and surely that hipbelt would help, but the picture at the bottom of the page with the guy wearing a shirt saying "Belize's #1 Beer" is humorous to me. Maybe a hipbelt of such engineering is worthy of a guy toting cases of Belize's finest up the great Mayan mountains! I'm probably going to be chided by McHale so I digress…

PostedDec 21, 2009 at 1:40 am

I am going to give packless running a try next week. According to calculation there should be enough moon incase it gets late. So no torch. Will carry my CCF pad w/ a strap on my shoulder, ziplock for drinking, whey powder, map, phone and money. That it. Goal will be to spend atleast two nights on the mountains. Will run only few hours per day and take a lot of rest. cant wait! :)

It not really wilderness. Most of the places are forts on top of a hill which are 2-4 hours from a base village and are frequented by lot of trekkers during weekends. 2 days means climbing 2-4 forts nearby. Village = food/water/shelter. Top of the fort = water from cistern/ shelter in a temple.

I will then decide about what kind of pack I need. or not.

PostedDec 21, 2009 at 5:06 am

I can’t figure out what this thread is about, but Raidlight make some nice looking running packs. A few models HERE

J B BPL Member
PostedDec 21, 2009 at 5:29 am

I have two Haglöfs Ace packs, the S and the M. Not the models on the website but the previous version though.

The have a strap that goes around the waist and prevents the pack from bouncing around, even when running. They work great.

When you’re running, they only bounce up and down.

They sit very low on your back:

DSC00003

I also have a GoLite lumbar pack, they’re also good but obviously more constricted in space.

PostedMar 5, 2010 at 8:56 am

I don't have any commentary on a specific brands since I haven't been in the market for a hydration pack for awhile. But one feature I would insist on is a compression system that attaches to the hipbelt. The compression system on most of the hydration packs that I see simply run from the front of the pack (the part next to your back) to the back of the pack. This secures the internal load but does nothing to snug the pack against your body and prevent bounce. A compression system that attaches anteriorly to the hipbelt will suck the pack into your lumbar area, be very secure and prevent bounce. By loosening the shoulder straps you can prevent the hipbelt from riding up.

Incidentally, I've found that I can fit two hydration bladders in the inner "sleeve" of the pack that was only intended to carry 2 L of fluid. On runs in excess of 15 miles I'll carry 2 L of water and 1 L of electrolyte.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
Loading...