I got this in an email from my local gear shop. They listed many outdoor activities but these two caught my eye. I don't think they were trying to compare the two or advocate UL backpacking.
Activities Based On:
135 lbs. WOMAN
200 lbs. MAN
Backpacking – 42+ lbs. pack with moderate hills
Women 576 cal/hr
Men 860 cal/hr
Hiking – 3 mph w/ day pack
Women 384 cal/hr
Men 573 cal/hr
Assuming the pack is the only variable: you burn 192-287 cal/hr less with a day pack versus a 42 pound pack. I thought the 42 pounds was crazy, but I'm sure there are people that lug around a kitchen sink. For a 135 pound woman that would be nearly 1/3 of her body weight.

