Topic

Well, it seemed like a good idea…

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 68 total)
Andrew Lush BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 4:23 am

A subjective list of gear that you thought would be great.

Maybe you used it once or twice but now it sits forlornly gathering dust in your gear cupboard.

I nominate the torso pad. Sure it's really lightweight. But it's also really, really uncomfortable. So much nicer to sleep on a comfy pad despite the extra weight.

There are many other examples.

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 5:27 am

The only thing i can think of that was a terrible buy, was Sealskinz waterproof gloves. They were the only gloves i've ever worn where my hands actually got colder by wearing them!
I love my Montbell UL 90 Torso Pad though.:)

Mary D BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 7:21 am

Those who have seen my recent posts on the Thermarest NeoAir know very well that for me it's #1 on this particular list! My POE Insulmat Max Thermo (now the Ether Thermo unless they renamed it again) is far more comfortable and a lot warmer. I've concluded that it's well worth the extra 8 ounces.

Another "seemed like a good idea" item is the Equinox bivy I got from Campmor. It turns out to be just too narrow for my Western Mountaineering Ultralight Super–it compresses the loft. I found the sleeping bag warmer without it. This bivy would be fine with a bag with less loft, though.

A third one was my attempt to save shelter weight by squeezing my 80-lb. dog and myself into a Six Moon Designs Lunar Solo. It was OK in fair weather when we were in the tent only to sleep, but when confined to the tent for longer periods during wet weather it was far too cramped. The two of us together also overwhelmed the ventilation system. You haven't lived until you've been awakened in the morning by the dreaded Labrador tail-wag bringing down a big shower of condensation–or worse yet, frost–onto your face!

Finally, my attempts to save weight using the Aquamira Frontier Pro water filter in combination with MicroPur tablets rather backfired. With the Frontier Pro (why are nearly all water filters labeled "Pro"?) set up as a gravity filter, it takes close to 15 minutes to filter a liter of water, and before filtering you need to let the tablets work for 15-20 minutes. So I'm back to my ULA Amigo Pro (another "Pro") gravity filter which filters at the rate of a liter per minute and is lighter (7.5 oz.) than most pump filters. Unfortunately, since the sale of ULA, that filter is no longer available.

All useful lessons learned. I'm becoming a lot more skeptical about investing in new gear just to save a few ounces!

As with many other things, Your Mileage May Vary!

Dean F. BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 7:58 am

#1. A GPS.

#2. A Fenix LOD. I thought it was the light way to go, but the more I hike the more it becomes obvious that everyone here is correct- a simple LED light is more than aqeduate.

Acronym Esq BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 8:52 am

When I started getting serious about LW backpacking a year or two ago, I confused bushcraft with backpacking. After doing loads of reading and watching youtube videos, I was convinced that a 3-6" fixed blade was necessary and awesome. I picked up a 5" Remington hunting fixed blade knife at Academy for $20 to see how I liked it.

It was definitely awesome, but I after 3 trips, I discovered I never batonned wood, built shelters, killed/skinned animals, or fended off hungry bears. In addition, the blade was too small to use as a machete, too big to open mountain house dried food pouches, and too big for making fuzz sticks. At 270 g, I really couldn't justify the weight.

I still think big fixed blades are cool, but I doubt I'll ever carry one in the back country again.

acronym 12/13/2009 10:50 AM

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 9:11 am

These posts are all very amusing so far. Good rainy sunday reading.

For me: Titanium Spork! It seemed so wonderful… I mean, come on! It's a spork, and it's made of titanium!

But the tines are too small to pick up any spaghetti or similar pasta (like eating pasta with a spoon). And they are spaced well enough that getting those last bits of food out of the corners of my cook pot was impossible (like trying to scrape the bottom of the pot with a fork). For me, it was the worst of both worlds.

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 9:15 am

Ditto folding titanium spork. Mostly b/c I use non-stick cookware. And because I couldn't keep it open when in use.

Jim W. BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 9:31 am

Sierra Zzip Stove. This is a wood burning stove with a fan to force the draft. Mine is older so it's pretty heavy. Once started, it burns very well. The problem is where to use it- for winter it might be good for lots of snow melting except the "dead and down" wood is all under snow plus I'd rather cook from my sleeping bag. For summer I'm usually either up high where fires and woodgathering are prohibited, or we're down low where a regular campfire is appropriate.

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 11:16 am

My worst purchase is probably a Eureka Solitaire. Try getting into it in a heavy downpour in wet rain gear without drenching your sleeping bag and pad.

Joseph

Jay Wilkerson BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 11:36 am

Golite Poncho Tarp–I liked the idea but in a worst case scenario you and all you gear will get wet. I hiked about 4 hours in a good Sierra storm—it was getting late and it was time to pitch a my shelter–Oh yea I am wearing my shelter and rain jacket–it was still raining hard—-I got soaked and so did my pack.. But I did learn some very good lessons on that trip to Tehipite Valley: Like sell the Poncho Tarp ASAP in Gear Swap.

Elliott Wolin BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 11:36 am

More votes for a titanium spork.

I tried pawning it off on my wife and kids, but they all agreed it worked lousy as a fork and even worse as a spoon. Liquids just dribble off before you can get it into your mouth.

Then there's all that heavyweight stuff I bought before I discovered UL, including some stuff I've never used (but keep because I'm sure I'll find a use for it one day, perhaps when I have to outfit a scout troop going on a Himalayan expedition).

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 11:39 am

Mary wrote, "Finally, my attempts to save weight using the Aquamira Frontier Pro water filter in combination with MicroPur tablets rather backfired. With the Frontier Pro (why are nearly all water filters labeled "Pro"?) set up as a gravity filter, it takes close to 15 minutes to filter a liter of water, and before filtering you need to let the tablets work for 15-20 minutes."

I have the same 2oz. Frontier Pro filter, and it filtered at a rate of 2.5 minutes per liter/quart in gravity mode. A fellow BPLer once complained about the "ridiculously slow rate" of his AquaMira Frontier Pro — then bought another one to give it a second chance — and got the same quick result as mine — just two and a half minutes.

If you like the set up in principle — then maybe give it a second try as well?

As an aside, be it Frontier Pro or ULA Amigo… if you're using a filter to block out the big baddies (protozoa) — then all you need is el cheapo chlorine/bleach (4 drops per quart/liter) to kill viruses and bacteria (30 minutes wait time). You don't need the really expensive Micropur or AquaMira tablets or liquids.

Sorry for the temporary thread hijack — now back to topic…

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 11:48 am

The Sea To Summit Reactor Thermolite Sleeping Bag Liner ranks up there on this list of bad purchases.

Wow, so light and yet boosts bag temp by 15F? That stupid thing added probably 3-5F tops!

It was a cold night that night, but thank heavens for REI's generous and very forgiving purchase return policy!

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 12:03 pm

The Aquamira Filter Bottle — dip and sip sounded great. Except the filter is an easily lost separate part to keep track of, reduces the bottle volume, and you can't get all of the water out of the bottle with the filter in place.

The bottle by itself is nice, and now serves as my water bottle for the gym…

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 12:19 pm

The Aqua-mira water bottle.
My complaint was that it took too much effort to force the water out. But it is good in a pinch.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 1:13 pm

> Ditto folding titanium spork.
Titanium cutlery, and sporks.
Give me proper Lexan cutlery any day. And it's lighter too.

Cheers

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 1:32 pm

Softshell jacket. It's nice for around campus or around town, but sucked for my kind of hiking. I've used it for a few day trips, but I think a layering approach worked better every other time. Oddly enough, it works great for rock climbing day trips but that is not what I bought it for.

Patagonia Houdini. I used it a lot on the first trip I took in on, but that was just to see how it performed. I used my event shell on subsequent trips and I was happier. It was a nice layer to block mosquitos though, which was a nice surprise.

Patagonia R1 Hoodie. Turns out I prefered a 100wt pull over and a powerstretch balaclava.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 2:42 pm

A poncho for raingear. It seems to make such good sense from a multi-use perspective and the theoretically great ventilation… but I always end up wet and am never happy with the experience. I have tried to do a poncho for three different seasons over the years but it's never stuck. Maybe I will finally give up on them and not be tempted to try again.

–Mark

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 2:56 pm

The Black Diamond Lightsabre Bivy. I didn't understand that the epic fabric used on these things is not truly waterproof. How can they make a standalone shelter out of the same fabric used for wind shirts? Fortunately I never tested it in a sustained downpour to get first hand experience on this failure. But now I don't even feel right selling it.

#2 is the BigZip platypus (the original one). A nice wide opening to fill the platy seemed great, but it was such an incredible pain to close that I never used it again after the first trip.

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 2:56 pm

The PACKA

Seemed like a REALLY good idea, but sucks for my uses. Sticky non-breathable silnylon next to skin. Yuck. Can't remove pack without taking the Packa off and getting me wet, plus have nothing to keep pack dry in camp. Hood too small. Not all seams are sealed. Heavy for what it is. Difficult to access hipbelt pockets while wearing….etc…

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 3:00 pm

The first marriage.

Ummmm, if you kinda think of a wife like gear anyway…..

Never mind.

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 3:12 pm

NEOS overboots.

I liked the idea of an overboot with MYO insulation inserts, but they just didn't work out as planned.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 3:49 pm

I knew there was something else–the BPL folding Ti spoon. While it was nice to have a spoon that fit my 550 ml pot, it was extremely hard to clean–food got into the "hinges." Back to the plastic spoon, even though I have to carry it elsewhere. Fortunately, I got the folding spoon on closeout, so it was cheap. But I now know why it was discontinued!

Ben, re the Aquamira Frontier filter, I'm wondering if the individual filters aren't highly variable as to the speed they filter. I also won't use bleach, even though cheaper, because of its byproducts, including such healthy goodies as dioxin. I don't use the tablets with the ULA filter (which filters out bacteria as well as protozoa) unless the water source is truly horrible, such as cattle-trodden stagnant ponds or a river downstream of human habitation.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 68 total)
Loading...