Those who have seen my recent posts on the Thermarest NeoAir know very well that for me it's #1 on this particular list! My POE Insulmat Max Thermo (now the Ether Thermo unless they renamed it again) is far more comfortable and a lot warmer. I've concluded that it's well worth the extra 8 ounces.
Another "seemed like a good idea" item is the Equinox bivy I got from Campmor. It turns out to be just too narrow for my Western Mountaineering Ultralight Super–it compresses the loft. I found the sleeping bag warmer without it. This bivy would be fine with a bag with less loft, though.
A third one was my attempt to save shelter weight by squeezing my 80-lb. dog and myself into a Six Moon Designs Lunar Solo. It was OK in fair weather when we were in the tent only to sleep, but when confined to the tent for longer periods during wet weather it was far too cramped. The two of us together also overwhelmed the ventilation system. You haven't lived until you've been awakened in the morning by the dreaded Labrador tail-wag bringing down a big shower of condensation–or worse yet, frost–onto your face!
Finally, my attempts to save weight using the Aquamira Frontier Pro water filter in combination with MicroPur tablets rather backfired. With the Frontier Pro (why are nearly all water filters labeled "Pro"?) set up as a gravity filter, it takes close to 15 minutes to filter a liter of water, and before filtering you need to let the tablets work for 15-20 minutes. So I'm back to my ULA Amigo Pro (another "Pro") gravity filter which filters at the rate of a liter per minute and is lighter (7.5 oz.) than most pump filters. Unfortunately, since the sale of ULA, that filter is no longer available.
All useful lessons learned. I'm becoming a lot more skeptical about investing in new gear just to save a few ounces!
As with many other things, Your Mileage May Vary!