Topic

Another windshirt thread

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 11:55 am

Hey guys, fairly simple questions here, just soliciting suggestions and that's all.

I'm getting rid of my "mid-weight" Montbell Stretch Wind Jacket and replacing it with two in different weight classes

1) The Lightweight
Looking for a basic, <4 oz, unlined, breathable, fairly water-resistant windshirt with a decent torso length / lower back coverage, and good durability for the weight class. Doesn't need to be a mythical superpower jacket, just needs to be a good performer. Will be used for hiking, backpacking, and just-in-case shell. Hood is optional, pockets not wanted, and affordability is a high priority, which probably rules out the Patagonia Houdini. Looking for the cheapest, lightest, simplest thing that delivers on what's written above.

My best guess: Montane Featherlite

Any other suggestions?

2) The "Heavy" weight
Want a <16oz, lined, water-resistant, highly breathable, durable, stretchy wind jacket. Full zip preferable, hood optional again. Will be used for trail running and outdoor sports. Occasionally might need to stand up to a chest trap in soccer or a layout (diving catch) on the ultimate field. Handwarmer pockets would be nice.

Current guess: Patagonia Traverse Jacket

Any other suggestions?

Thanks!

PostedDec 12, 2009 at 12:02 pm

I like GoLite Ether (3.17 oz) and Wisp (3.01 oz). Light, breathable, and the DWR is good. Often on sale here or at a reduced price elsewhere. Price is decent and much less than Pataguchi. Also check out the ID pertex (hoodless). I'm going to go to that eventually.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 12:19 pm

Can't say the GolIte Wisps we have show any sign of effective DWR. Wind-stop – yes.
The Montane stuff is also good.

Cheers

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 12:19 pm

Matt,
Thanks for the response.

How's the coverage on the Ether / Wisp in the torso? Well below the waist? How's the butt coverage? My Montbell tends to ride up on me if I'm moving too fast, jogging, reaching, etc. Want to avoid that in the replacement.

I wasn't aware ID made a non-hooded version of their Pertex jacket. Can you provide a link?

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 12:25 pm

Roger,
Which generation of Wisps / Ethers have you used?

I would concur based on an older GoLite windshirt that I had several years ago, but I've heard from newer reviewers that recent editions of the piece has gotten more h2o-resistant.

But, something like Pertex Microlite (in the Montane Featherlite) has such an extensive reviewer approval base and a consistent history that it's hard to ignore. I'm still drawn to the Featherlite, just want to be aware of any other options that are similar.

Also, another forum member has pointed out Wild Things' Epic pieces. They're great! I've got one of the Hooded versions that I use for lightweight raingear / durable wind jacket. But, those pieces don't fit into either of the two niches that I'm trying to fill.

PostedDec 12, 2009 at 1:48 pm

My vote is on the Montane Featherlite. This is what I used on my CT thru hike (as you can see in my profile picture) and couldn't have asked for anything more. Extremely breathable, and repells water well enough. Outside of backpacking, I wear mine daily.

J B BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 1:57 pm

But, something like Pertex Microlite (in the Montane Featherlite) has such an extensive reviewer approval base and a consistent history that it’s hard to ignore. I’m still drawn to the Featherlite, just want to be aware of any other options that are similar.

Just get the Montane, they’re great.

If you’re looking for the same, but different flavours, VAUDE makes the Laser Jacket (150 g, but has certain problems) and Haglöfs also has some. I used to have a Zeal jacket, it was good.

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 2:14 pm

Cool! I think I'm sold on the Featherlite. Nice n' cheap too.

Now for the "heavy"weight.

I've thought a little more and figure a full-zip OR pullover style would be fine.

Current considerations:
– Patty Traverse jacket or pullover
– OR contour windshirt
– OR avido jacket
– OR ether jacket

Anybody have anything interesting to say about any of these? Remember, I'm looking to fill this niche specifically for running, ultimate frisbee, and other high-output stuff. Sweaty sweaty.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 7:20 pm

> Lightweight

Montane Featherlite is the best deal I have seen. My only complain is that the zipper is a bit fragile. Care when you zip, and use both hands so it doesn't snag. My fav is the houdini, it is much more expensive. If you have an patagonia outlet nearby, you can sometimes snag them at a memorial or labor day sale for around $50.

> Heavy

How much wind do you want to block? I ask because when I am engaged in very high output activities like running I don't what 100% windproof… I want some air circulation. If you want some air movements I would look at jackets made from dryskin or one of the imitations from TNF or Marmot. Recently I have been playing around with using a hardface windpro fleece for around town sports and for some of my biking runs. Is a bit more insulating than often items I typically wear and a good bit less wind resistant… but they seem to offset each other for a good overall experience.
–Mark

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 7:41 pm

Mark,
You raise a good point. I probably made a mistake asking for a wind-anything in this second niche. From what I've seen from WindPro, that seems like it could be the amount of CFM I'm looking for. Quite high, much higher than any of the real windshirts I considered for the lightweight niche.

Trouble is, once I warm up, I think full-on fleece of any kind might be a little too much. I'm moving to Colorado Springs soon, and I'm trying to prepare for high-output training for winter and spring — probably the worst that it will get most of the time will be 20s F, and very possibly up into the 40s during the warm parts of the day. Right?

So I'm saying, once I start heating up, I could easily sweat through my 100-weight polartec Melanzana MicroGrid hoodie, even in 30*F. So I'm guessing real fleece of any kind will be overkill. Just the same way that most people (from what I've seen) have stated that the R1 would be too heavy for high-intensity stuff unless it's super-duper cold outside.

Anyway, I guess the question is — what acts like WindPro in terms of CFM, might offer a *little* water resistance, is <16oz, is durable, and is light enough that I won't overheat sprinting in 30*F?

It could simply be that my initial guess with the Traverse is the best option. Or possibly the OR Contour windshirt, made from the same fabric as my extremely-breathable Contour pants — which I love.

That answer your question, Mark?

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 9:38 pm

> Which generation of Wisps / Ethers have you used?
Well, I guess they must be a few years old – we got them for our 2007 trip through France.

Cheers

PostedDec 12, 2009 at 10:00 pm

When you get heavier, it becomes more of a softshell imo. For the 'heavyweight', you might want to stick with Montane, and have a look at the Pertex Equilibrium Dynamo Jacket

David Chenault BPL Member
PostedDec 12, 2009 at 10:16 pm

I think the Traverse is just what you're looking for. It's quite tough, blocks enough wind, and breathes very well. Nice long arms and trim torso, too. (I have the pullover and wear it all the time.)

PostedDec 13, 2009 at 7:19 am

you may want to consider marmot's driclime. it's a very flexible piece of gear

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 7:53 am

Thanks for the suggestions guys.

Re: the Montane Dynamo, the review for it on OutdoorsMagic looks outstanding, and the piece seems to protect and breathe in just the way I'm looking for. However, I can't seem to find it for sale in the United States, and if I want to get it from England it'll be spendier than I want. Also, I'd be a little concerned about durability. Dunno how Pertex Equilibrium handles abrasion, etc.

Re: the Marmot Driclime, well, I think I remember trying one on a couple years ago and I thought the cut was just terrible for me. Dunno if I'm misremembering. But, I guess I also would have questions about the Driclime's durability. Remember, I'll probably be laying out to catch a frisbee and scraping this piece along the ground.

So, I guess when I think about it, I'm still leaning toward the Traverse like Dave said, or possibly the OR Contour because it's made of stretch Cordura, which my pants made of the same have shown to have excellent longevity. Maybe in the end I'll just get the Traverse and the Contour and just pick which one looks / feels / fits better.

Thanks guys. Appreciate the feedback. Think I'm settled.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 13, 2009 at 2:58 pm

Given your activity level and that a 100wt is too warm, I think you want something that is wind resistant but actually lets some air through to help cool you. You might want to look at something made with cloudveil's inertia fabric. It has pretty good DWR, moderate wind resistant, has some stretch, and will wick a bit.

I don't think they have a jacket in production using inertia, but there are a number of sites on the web that still have some of the older jackets / pullovers made from inertia.

This might sound odd, but if the water resistant isn't a major part of the requirements, you might want to try a featherweight base + a supplex shirt. I found this combination surprisingly versatile doing sports around town and even spring time skiing.

–mark

Richard Lyon BPL Member
PostedDec 14, 2009 at 5:06 am

Backcountry.com's Rime pullover is an excellent non-SUL windshirt. Reasonable water resistance, great at blocking wind

John Brochu BPL Member
PostedDec 14, 2009 at 1:12 pm

>>>I like GoLite Ether (3.17 oz) and Wisp (3.01 oz). Light, breathable, and the DWR is good.<<<

Is the Wisp really supposed to be breathable? Mine doesn't seem to breathe at all and I assumed it was in the non-breathable category.

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 16, 2009 at 11:28 pm

Got my new Featherlite in the mail today, and incredibly pleased with it so far. The shoulder articulation is excellent, and I can raise up my arms without the usual hem rise. Every windshirt should be built with a drop cut like this! The torso length is awesome, and I know I won't have to worry about this riding up on me or fumbling in my pack's hipbelt. I wish American companies would make stuff with this kind of shape.

And the Microlite fabric, though obviously very thin and light, feels surprisingly solid and durable. Probably due to the calendaring, which gives it a slight stiffness.

Can't wait to play with it in the field! I'm moving to Colorado in January.

J B BPL Member
PostedDec 17, 2009 at 12:46 am

Got my new Featherlite in the mail today, and incredibly pleased with it so far. The shoulder articulation is excellent, and I can raise up my arms without the usual hem rise. Every windshirt should be built with a drop cut like this! The torso length is awesome, and I know I won't have to worry about this riding up on me or fumbling in my pack's hipbelt. I wish American companies would make stuff with this kind of shape.

You must have gotten the new cut then. Montane cut them like a sack of potatoes for a long time. :-)

PostedDec 17, 2009 at 1:51 am

Which featherlite are you guys talking about? I see several versions.

I'm thinking of getting a windshirt too but I'm not sure if I want to go with Montane or the Golite ones. It looks like the prices are around the same

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 17, 2009 at 7:49 am

Well, I'm sure glad I got the new kind.

For those that are interested and looking, BASEgear has a great deal, and that's where I bought mine. Although I guess they only had mediums when I was looking. But they've got several other Montane jackets to sort through too, all at good prices.

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
Loading...