Topic

Layering Under Heavy Down necessary?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
m a BPL Member
PostedDec 10, 2009 at 10:35 pm

Hi, i,m buying a down jacket for the first time. A Mountain Hardwear Sub Zero parka. Something to sit around in cold weather with, I get cold easily. Something to throw on at camp or something to carry for unexpected overnights . . . . . I dont really do mountaineering, but I do backpack and hike a lot. I,m trying to decide if i should get it with substantial room for layering, or get it to fit with just a base layer. Probably most of my cold weather hiking will be day-time temps from just above 0c to -10c

It looks like most "mountaineering" people throw on their down over all their other stuff, base, fleece, shell. Is this for the convienience of not changing clothes frequently or for lots of extra warmth? I remember being told that wearing too much clothing in a sleeping bag reduces its effectiveness, is this true for down outwear too?

If i throw on a Medium over my fleece it is tough to get the collar zipped to the top, but fitted perfectly in the body. Maybe the sleeves are a little tight? I cant really tell if I am compressing the down, i'm not used to fluffy jackets. I wouldn't try to get another layer under it. Arms at my side the sleeves are to the top of my thumb, juuuuuust long enough? Will i really regret it if i dont get sleeves down to my knuckles?

The large obviously has plenty long sleeves, but the body is realy spacious.

For backpacking below freezing I think i can stay warm by hiking with a power stretch fleece base layer, a heavy fleece and/or a wind stopper, so I imagine with the M size down jacket I would have to take off the wind stopper when I stop and need my "sleeping bag with sleeves"!

MHW gear all seems to be a very "fitted" cut, is there a reason for this? Is getting the larger jacket defeating the purpose of form fitting gear?

Thanks in advance

Travis L BPL Member
PostedDec 10, 2009 at 11:44 pm

When hiking in sub freezing temps, I do fine with a powerstretch baselayer and a softshell jacket. I believe there are various opinions about softshell, but thats for another discussion.

Anyways, when I stop and need to be warm, I throw on my down puffy. I like my clothes fitted, and I think if there's too much extra bagginess in something like a down jacket, it will detract from its effectiveness in being an insulating layer. Too much dead air to heat, and more chance for wind to swirl up from below and rob the heat from you. Personally, if I were you, I'd go with the medium.

Fitted cuts are much better in my opinion. Less material to flop around or get snagged, weighs less, looks better (hey, who doesn't want to look good in the backcountry!!), performs better. Its like olympic swimmers…they all wear the tight suits instead of the regular trunks we find at Walmart because they perform better. Hope that helps!

John Brochu BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2009 at 6:58 am

>>>It looks like most "mountaineering" people throw on their down over all their other stuff, base, fleece, shell. Is this for the convienience of not changing clothes frequently or for lots of extra warmth? I remember being told that wearing too much clothing in a sleeping bag reduces its effectiveness, is this true for down outwear too?<<<

For ice climbing and cold weather alpinism, I'm an advocate of what Mark Twight called the action suit system in his book, "Extreme Alpinism."

This basically means wearing the bare minimum to keep warm when moving, then immediately putting on a high loft layer when stopping to rest or belay. In practice – for me in most winter conditions in New Hampshire this means wearing a light base layer top and bottom, a water resistent stretchy bottom like schoeller, a very thin fleece top, and a WPB top. (Plus gaitors, gloves, hat, etc.)

Since ice climbing is often a wet endeavor, I've always used a golite synthetic high loft jacket sized to just throw right over my action suit.

This system prevents overheating when moving fast, allows for great range of motion since you don't have a zillion bulky layers like the systems of old, and keeps you warm when you stop provided you put the high loft layer on as soon as you stop.

To some extent, UL backpackers have adopted the same system for 3 season and 4 season use, but often use down rather than a synthetic.

As long as your high loft piece is sized properly to get over your other layers, and you don't expect those layers to be really wet leading to compromising the down, you should be fine.

Jim W. BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2009 at 8:49 am

I think it should be sized to throw on over your hiking layers. Otherwise it's a hassle to unlayer before putting the coat on. As long as it has a powder skirt or some sort of cinch at the waist and wrists you won't have a lot of air moving through.

Get the Large.

Sam Haraldson BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2009 at 9:27 am

John beat me to it. For what I consider to be the supreme informational resource about dressing in active situations during winter, read Mark Twight's Extreme Alpinism.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...