Topic

Pants – BPL Thorofare v. Montbell Stretch Windpants & others

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 3:08 pm

I'm trying to decide on pants for use on a thru-hike (either PCT or CDT). I've previously used convertible pants with success, but I am thinking of trying something else to avoid the weight and complexity. I prefer to wear shorts whenever the weather allows, so I'm looking for some sort of pants to wear over running shorts when shorts alone are too cold. I might occasionally wear the pants for sun protection, but I hope to use some sunblock as needed, and then develop a base tan so I don't need to wear pants all the time.

I want the lightest weight, most comfortable pants I can get for this purpose. Since I am using them as over-pants I don't need any bells or whistles, and probably don't even need pockets. I do need to be able to get them on and off over shoes, though. I'd like something very breathable, but also relatively bug-proof. I'd also like to avoid noisy nylon warm-up/wind pants.

I'm considering the thorofare pants, though I think I would have to add ankle zippers to them. I am also looking at the Montbell Stretch Wind Pants. Anyone have any thoughts about one versus the other?

I'd also like suggestions for any other pants I should consider. Finally, I'd love advice about whether I could comfortably get by using just my rain pants for this purpose (Golite Reed), and forgoing any other pants. I worry about situations in which the rain pants alone would be too cold, or too clammy.

Thanks!

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 3:43 pm

Where I live sun isn’t a problem, but I know the sun can be brutal on either the PCT or CDT and I think most hikers wear long pants, long sleeve shirts, and a good hat year round there.

If you go the convertible pants route I have only used the REI Seirra Convertables, and everything has held up fine except the zipper on the right pocket. It has broken on all three pairs that I have. My size large pants weigh 13.6oz.

I don’t have the Thorofare pants so I can’t say if they would be durable enough for a thru hike, but they are very light, and not too bad price wise with the current sale. One pant that I do know that people have used for multiple thru hikes (same pair of pants) is RailRiders Eco Mesh Pants. They have a claimed weight of less than 10oz and zippered mesh vents on the side of the pants for warmer weather.

As for using your rain pants for your all the time pants, I wouldn’t recommend it. Not only do you overheat easily in rainpants anyways, I don’t think they would be waterproof for very long if they were subject to all day every day type wear.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 3:50 pm

— "develop a base tan so I don't need to" —

Hey! These are scary words, my friend. Might want to check the science of this with, like, a doctor… before you plan to use this as a planned way to avoid skin cancer. My mother-in-law just had to have surgery for a number of cancer spots 'cos she thought she didn't need sunblock (she's always out in the sun and has a nice base tan)… just a word of caution. Take care & good luck with the thru-hike. ;-)

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 4:22 pm

Hey guys,

Thanks for the concern about my skin health, and I wish your mother-in-law well, James. I always hike in a railriders adventure shirt and an OR sunrunner cap. But I can't handle the pants. (Edit: I edited my OP for clarity — I don't plan to get a base tan for the purpose of avoiding having to use any sunblock, but rather for the purpose of not having to wear pants all the time). I thru-hiked the PCT before using the REI Sahara convertible pants, but used them in shorts mode most of the time. I then decided to give the railriders ecomesh pants a try and thru-hiked the JMT with them. I felt pretty sluggish. I then hiked with the ecomesh pants on part of the CDT in MT. On a whim I changed into shorts and it was a revelation. I felt hugely more energetic. I'm not saying shorts are better for everyone, but they are better for me. Of course I worry about the sun, but I would rather use a little sunblock as needed than wear pants. It's all about balance. A lot of us (maybe not people on this site, but people in general in the US) run a serious vitamin D deficiency, and could benefit from a little more sun exposure. So the balance I've found for myself is to use some sunblock as needed, but otherwise go with shorts, and cover-up everywhere else. And, of course, keep a careful eye on my skin. I'm not advocating that for everyone, but it works for me.

But enough of that tangent. Suggestions on the pants for when I do need them?

CW BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 4:55 pm

Brian Doble (2008 AT YoYoer) used the Thorofare clothing on his PCT thru this year. Maybe he'll stop by and provide feedback.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 4:59 pm

I think the Thorofare pants will be ideal, and they have a pretty wide leg cuff, so you may even get away without adding ankle zips.

As for tans, skin cancer and sunscreens, the odds are (the epidemiology really) James' mother-in-law now has cancer due to being sunburned as a child. Getting a natural, gradual slow tan is nature's way of preventing sunburn, providing vitamin D, and triggering hormones in the body that make you feel better, eat less and have less bodyfat. There has yet to be a shred of evidence that sunscreens prevent melanoma, but there is an overwhelming body of evidence that lack of vitamin D does cause many cancers.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 5:09 pm

+1 thorofare as light weight overpants… that's typically how I have used them. They are more air permeable than montbell. For me (who struggles with overheating and moisture management) they are better than montbell. If you goal is to block 100% of the wind, then montbell would be better.

I found the light calendaring of the thorofare to be more comfortable than many materials. I have not felt the need for ankle zips.

–mark

Nick Gatel BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 5:51 pm

Gosh, I sure have different experiences. The Thorofare clothes (shirts & pants), just make me sweat profusely. I find the Rail Rider Adventure Shirt and Eco-mesh pants to be the perfect set-up for most conditions.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 6:15 pm

I wore the Thorofare pants almost 24/7 on a 5 day trip this fall (see avatar). I found them to be comfortable, adequately durable and amazingly light. Overall I thought they were great. There are a few downsides but they are minor.

On the downside, they seemed to pick up stains easily, the hip pockets are a bit shallow (I lost a few things out of them) and the waist elastic is too stretchy. If you carry gear in the pockets the waist will sag because the elastic is so soft. If you want to actually use the pockets then you'll want to replace the waist elastic with a stronger one, or with some thin cord like I did.

I doubt you'd be able to slip your shoes through the Thorofare pants. You'd probably wind up tearing them unless you have tiny feet. I'd add ankle zips if you need this functionality.

The ankles actually have snaps that you can use to snap the opening smaller. Instead of adding ankle zips, you might just be able cut a slit up the pants, hem that and then use the existing snap to hold the bottom of the pants together.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 9:17 pm

I like my REI Sahara convertable pants for their light weight however they don't seem particularly wind resistant.

Maybe you can buy the fabric you like & make the plain pants from a pattern for men's pajamas. I used a pajama pattern from Jo Ann Fabrics to make my winter white camo pants AND parka (detachable hood pattern copied from another rain parka I owned.) Worked great.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 9:57 pm

I see at least one lost zip off leg every time I hike..

semi-loose rubber bands and a bit of rolling will convert any pant.

How come they don't add those knee height buttons and straps to guy pants like they do for all the women's pants? I think that's an awesome feature.

Ian Schumann BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 10:54 pm

Haven't seen much commentary on these, thought I'd throw in my limited $.02

I had a pair of MB Stretch Wind Pants for a little while but never found occasion to use them. Of course, a lot of this is simply because they were a little too long for me and so the zippers would try to bunch awkwardly around my shoes . . . BUT wanted to say that this is an *extremely* light stretchwoven fabric, SO light that they swish and make noise in a similar way that (I would guess) almost any other nylon windpants would.

I really like the fabric, overall, and have greatly enjoyed the complement piece, the Stretch Wind Jacket. Montbell's Stretch Ballistic fabric comes with their fantastic Polkatex DWR and still breathes quite well — easily comparable to a Patagonia Houdini.

Anyway . . . I digress. But the point is, these could serve you very well, if you get a pair that fits well and you don't mind the swish-factor.

Elena Lee BPL Member
PostedDec 10, 2009 at 11:00 am

My husband and I each own a pair. This past summer these pants went into our packs on all of our hiking trips in the WA Cascades and Olympics. He also uses these pants for winter running. I just returned from a snowshoeing trip using them over my capeline base. I have even tried to glissade once in these pants (not recommended :)

The fabric is incredibly thin and soft, yet water resistant and reasonably durable. No noise, no plastic feeling – just soft fabric. It has little stretch to it. Slightly articulated knees. Bottom zippers and drawstring stretchy top. They are also wind resistant.

Perhaps the only drawback of these pants – they are not made for heavy abuse.

About H2O: i would stay away from anything "waterproof" on the pants side. I can't tell about reed pants, but we both own a jacket which I believe is made of the same material (Vigra) and in the prolonged Pacific NW rain it is completely soaked-inside out. If it rains, just let your pants get wet but these ones will dry up instantly. You can also spray them with some extra DWR for better water repellency. If you are using Reeds already, and decide to take them as a pant of choice, don't get another pair of pants, but just get the lightest Patagonia capeline base layer to complement your system for warmth/comfort. In other words, use Pants + base + shorts , or Pants + shorts only. No need for two kinds of pants.

Cold: you won't get so cold anywhere on PCT that you would need anything warmer than a baselayer plus pants. You will be moving most of the times, and at night, you can utilize other things in your system to keep you warm (bag, quilt, etc.)

I think Montbell Stretch Wind will be an excellent choice for you. They are so lightweight you won't even notice them in your pack.

Nia Schmald BPL Member
PostedDec 10, 2009 at 1:06 pm

My system for legs were Cloudveil Spinner convertible softshell pants, a lightweight merino baselayer, and a pair of running shorts. The cloudveil covered normal conditions, wind, rain, and snow. I wore the running shorts only when it got extremely hot and in town when I did laundry. So most of the time I had the legs of the convertibles and a pair of running shorts in my pack. For me this was lighter than carrying windpants or rain pants. Plus I really like the stretch of the softshell.

BTW the spinner's are on sale at Sierra Trading Post. There's always at least a 20% of coupon available.

Hiker 816 BPL Member
PostedDec 11, 2009 at 1:33 pm

Thanks for the advice everyone. Of course, the different opinions are making it harder for me to decide instead of easier, but that's to be expected. Does anyone know of any simple supplex nylon pants in the 4.5 to 7.5 oz range that haven't already been mentioned?

Thanks!

Elena Lee BPL Member
PostedDec 21, 2009 at 12:25 pm

Just came from search and rescue training where i wore the montbell wind pants. while some people's heavy duty pants ripped apart by some of the most extreme bushwhacking i've ever seen for 2 days straight, mine came back with no single rip. i am simply amazed by this material.

J B BPL Member
PostedDec 21, 2009 at 2:22 pm

Elena,

I don't know what length your husband wears but if it's M or L, could you do me a favour and measure the length of them?

I'm tall but thin. I have Haglöfs pants in M that are good (though a bit short) and Montane in M that are a couple of cms too short.

Thanks

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 17 total)
Loading...