Topic

Clothing recommendations for a newbie

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 11:11 am

Hi, everybody!

I haven't done any serious hiking or backpacking in nearly 20 years, and I'm wanting to get back into it — I am assembling gear now, and I tend to be the type who researches before making purchases.

I live in Houston, TX; most of my hiking/camping will occur under two possible scenarios:

95F+ daytime/85F+ nighttime (Mar – Nov)

45-65F daytime/30-45F nighttime (Dec – Feb)

High humidity, and possibility of strong rainstorms.

I have a pack that currently weighs about 12.75 lbs, not including clothing, water, or food, and I think I can get that pack weight down to ~10.

I am now researching clothing systems for those two different weather scenarios. I am debating between merino wool products and synthetics.

I picked up a few pairs of socks at Gander Mountain — 3 pairs of Gander Mountain brand merino wool hiking socks, and one pair of Smartwool trekking socks. They both seem equally comfortable — the Smartwool are about twice as expensive. Does the quality of this brand justify the price premium over Gander Mountain brand? Are there other inexpensive brands that are just as good, or is it advisable to spring for the more expensive brands?

I haven't bought any shirts or pants yet, but I'm trying to compare merino wool shirts to synthetics, and for pants, I'm looking at lightweight synthetic fabrics that are tough and fast drying. Probably I'll go with merino wool boxers for base layer.

Before I buy anything, I'd like to hear feedback from people about the pros and cons of these materials, preferred brands, etc.

Thanks!

Sanad Toukhly BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 11:23 am

Hi Scott,
I live in Florida. We also have very hot and humid weather. Personally, I usually use synthetic. I found Railriders Eco-mesh clothing to work the best for long sleeve shirts and pants. They are very well ventilated. If you want to go the shorts and t-shirt route, I recommend Golite Drimove lite t-shirts. They weigh 3 oz. Their Baja shorts are also 3 oz I believe. If you don't like shorts that short, you can go with longer Under Armour shorts, I forget what they are called but they weigh in at 4 oz.

-Sid

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 11:50 am

Welcome back to backpacking!

Remember, everybody will have different ideas based on their experience and preferences. It’s always advised to take a ‘test run’ on such items, as you wear them the majority of a trip.

For the hotter times you mention (prolonged +95*F)… I usually use lightweight synthetics. I don’t like sunscreen on multi-day trips, so I wear white, long-sleeved, lightweight synthetic shirts.

For the cooler times you mention, I use ~150g long-sleeved merino with a zip neck for venting. I think most folks here would use something similar . Use the lightest weight you can, as it performs better.

As for bottoms, I like pants vs shorts for all but the hottest weather (usually desert, for me). It keeps dust and dirt off my legs and there is no need for oily sunscreen. I’ve found Prana Stretch Zion pants to be a good, durable hot weather option and good for cool weather as well.

For shorts, there are many lightweight running options out there like the Golites mentioned above.

Merino briefs are very popular, but I really like the Ex Officio boxer briefs, especially for hot weather underwear. Can’t say enough good things about them. It’s now all I wear.

I’ve never tried Gander Mountain socks, but I’ve used the Smartwool socks for years with decent results… They are fine, but they tend to break down/wear through rather quickly. I’m currently exploring other options.

Hope this helps.

EDIT: I didn't see a hat mentioned… I assume it was simply omitted from the post, but included on your list. If undecided… I like the Patagonia bucket hat. It weighs 1.2oz, offers good coverage and stays on in high wind.

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 12:11 pm

For your tempurature range, I wouldn't go with more than 150gram weight merino in a baselayer. In fact, I'd go with the 115gram weight BPL UL Merino Hoody, but BPL is the only place I know that makes merino garments in that weight, and they're pricey.

Lower cost, I'd go with Patagonia Capilene 2, (on sale)in a longsleeve zip neck. The biggest advantage of merino is the lack of stink, and in Smartwool, Icebreaker, and BPL, it's very comfortable against my skin. Capilene 2 is nice though too.

I feel like the capilene drys a bit quicker than the merino, but I can't say that quantitatively.

A wind jacket must certainly fit into your gear list.

As far as the socks, just make sure to check the fabric content. I did a quick check on med. weight hiking socks in Gander vs Smartwool, and they were about the same. 75% merino and 25% nylon and spandex. I can't speak to the quality of the wool or the construction. Certainly name brand can play a factor but quality can too, despite what some might claim. I'd try the Gander though for half the cost.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 12:30 pm

Thanks Sid, I put the Drimove t-shirt on my amazon wish list while I mull it and similar offerings over.

Thanks, Roger, I ordered a pair of the Ex Officio sports briefs, and a pair of their boxer briefs.

Based on your comment about the lack of longevity of the SmartWool socks, I may just stick to the Gander Mountain brand, and seek out even less expensive brands to compare.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 12:45 pm

Jim, I'm willing to pay a premium for quality, if it's truly justified.

How is the durability of lightweight merino wool vs. synthetic (e.g., the Patagonia)? Specifically, how does it hold up to carrying a pack all day long?

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 1:00 pm

Well, the BPL UL Merino hoody states specifically that it it is not made to stand up to wear under pack straps all day. It's a baselayer made to be worn under something else, a windshirt in my case. I've only had it for a couple months though so I can't speak to long term durability.

The Cap 2 material held up pretty well for a 3 seasons of dayhiking and backpacking. However, I was doing it in a California climate where I was almost always wearing it under a windshirt.

I also generally hand wash my merino tops to prolong the lifespan.

Capilene will still be a bit more durable, I think.

I really like 150 weight merino, the weight of the BPL Beartooth hoody and the Smartwool microweight items. I find it comfortable across the broadest range of temperatures, which has been 70-35 while active for me. 190-200+ is best suited to sub 35 temps for me, and 115 bottoms out around 45-50.

I wouldn't say my capiline 2 goes quiet as low and the 150weight merino.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 1:19 pm

“How is the durability of lightweight merino wool vs. synthetic (e.g., the Patagonia)? Specifically, how does it hold up to carrying a pack all day long?”

In my experience, the lightest merino products are noticeably less durable than synthetics like Capaline. According to a friend at Patagonia, that is the reason the release of Wool 1 lagged behind. Even my heavier merino products show more wear than the equivalent synthetic product after many miles beneath pack straps.

That stated, I still greatly prefer merino because it performs much better and stinks much less. I also find it durable enough, as do most folks here. Proper care helps with longevity, as Jim pointed out.

I also find my comfort level in-line with Jim’s temperature/weight recommendations. Most notably, 150g being most versatile.

Good luck.

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 2:05 pm

For a rain jacket, check out the Marmot Essence avalible at REI's Outlet. My size Medium weighs in at 6.4oz. If you need a true windshirt, the Montane offerings are hard to beat, but are hard to find in the US (many of us had to import from the UK), the Patagonia Houdini is another good, but pricey option.

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 2:14 pm

I find it really hard to suggest ‘one type fits all’ raingear, as it really depends on your climate, time of year, duration of trip, etc.

I have no experience with that jacket, but I am quite familiar with a poncho/tarp setup. Personally, I carry my poncho/tarp when I don’t expect rain. I rarely wear it and often don’t even pitch it. But, I have it if I need it.

If rain is in the forecast or my trip length exceeds the forecast, I pack other shelter and rain gear options. As to your wind question, yes, a poncho is a pain in the wind and you do get wet if you need to pitch it as a tarp in the rain.

A system I like was mentioned on here the other day… DryDucks for when you shouldn’t need it, ID eVent for when you do. I also like the rain wrap for when it’s appropriate. A system like this is what I’m probably moving to for next season… depending on where I go, when and for how long.

As for the windshirt… I bought a Houdini at an outlet. No complaints.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedDec 9, 2009 at 5:28 pm

My recommendation for hot assuming you want to have the material protect you from sun (UPF 30+) rather than doing short sleeves / shorts + sun tan lotion.

shirt either:
1) rail rider eco-mesh / adventure shirt in white. White helps reflect the heat away, the side / under arm mesh helps ventilate. Doesn’t wick but dries quickly.
2) ex officio Neo-Tartan shirt. very light weight nylon/polyester woven shirt that is more air permeable than rr shirt and wicks a bit.

“pants”: a kilt to maximum ventilation

Recommendation for your “cooler”

shirt: featherweight powerdry long sleeve shirt with xstatic or visa endurance treatment.
pants: any decent convertible supplex pants.
dri ducks rain suit
appropriate insulation for torso (mb thermwrap vest or jacket, mb down inner vest or jacket, wm flash vest or jacket, etc.

I have found that basic supplex pants have been completely adaquate for me if the nighttime low is 30f with the daytime temps >40f. Some people might add a mid-weight base for the legs.

more thoughts on my recommended clothing

–mark

PostedDec 9, 2009 at 8:23 pm

I appreciate the advice — I'm looking up these items and buying as budget permits when I think I see something worth trying out.

I should post my current gear list and see what obvious items may be safely discarded or substituted for lighter items.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
Loading...