Can anyone recommend a sleeping bag liner that gives a true added 10-15 F degrees of warmth. I read the sea to summit thermolite does not do as stated (15 F).
Topic
Sleeping Bag Liner
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Integral Designs Primaliner
Mont-Bell Thermal Sheet
I have used my reactor about 20 nights. It weighs 244 g w/o tags, draw string, and stuff sack. I don’t think it provides anything more than 5 F of additional warmth.
My wife has a silk liner from REI that weighs 240 g w/o tags and stuff sack. I don’t know how warm it is.
acronym 12/9/2009 10:43 AM
Something that is rated to 50-55dF IE a summer quilt should extend a bag 15dF.
The sea to summit thermolite is just single layer of thin fabric. I bought one and sent it back.
I have one of the med adv Thermo-lite Bivy II emer bivies that I modified a bit. Moded so I can open it all the way up like a blanket or just open the foot etc. Weighs 7 oz.
I have yet to try it out as an extender though.
I did try it in the house at about 70dF and came out of it about 1/2 hour later burning up.
Its going to act as a VBL, so its probably best to use below freezing.
I am going to test it under a golite ultra 20 in a hammock and see how that works out.
I use silk pants and bottoms now rather than a liner. They have more uses and I feel like they are warmer. I do not think they raise the temp rating 15 degs though.
John,
If it's too good to be true, it usually is. NO thin, ultralight bag liner is going to give you more than a few degrees temp boost — including the Sea-to-Summit Reactor — which I have little respect for giving their false advertisements. I used to own one, so I know.
I also own a MontBell Thermal Sheet — which is really not a sheet at all but a hoodless down bag. It is lightweight, however, as far as bags go — coming in at just 14oz.
So, if it takes a 14oz high fill power down bag to boost temp by 10-15F — common sense will tell you to stay away from the likes of S-T-S Reactor.
Another vote against the Sea to Summit Thermolite Reactor. My girlfriend and I both got one, and promptly returned it. At most it added a degree or two and more or less kept the bag clean. I honestly don't know how they were able to claim a 15 degree boost. The cocoon silk liners are probably your best bet for a thin liner, but even their 9 degree boost rating may be pushing it a bit.
Become a member to post in the forums.

