Topic

Frameless pack question?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 6:50 pm

Since joining this forum I've heard quite a bit about frameless packs and it appears from the posts that these are hikers with experience in the field.

I realize this is a lightweight alternative to framed packs but still can't quite grab the concept.

Are you really using these book-bag packs for week-end trips or are they better suited for over-niters with minimal milage?

I'm an avid backpacker and usually consume quite a bit of miles on my treks and due to recent purchase of much lighter gear i find myself in the market for a lighter pack and find that i have a lot of extra space in my 4600cu pack.

Will i sacrifice comfort with a frameless pack?,seems like the weight will be riding on the shoulders the whole time.

Educate me please.

Dean F. BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 6:58 pm

We're not talking about some college student's Jansport, here. These aren't book-bags; they are built very differently. Usually we're talking about a tube-shaped top loader. Yes, they only work well with relatively light loads, but our point is that with a little thought and effort you can trim your pack weight WAY down, and then frameless packs become a viable alternative that saves even more weight.

For instance- many of us load our sleeping pad into the pack first, and let it uncurl (or if it is a self-inflating pad we open the valve), so that it forms a stiffer wall to the pack and acts as a primitive frame. Then, other items are packed into the center of the pack, inside the "tube" of pad.

Does that make sense?

And, yes, some of us use frameless packs for week-long trips pretty regularly- not just weekends. In the summer, if your base pack weight is only 8 pounds or so, then assuming about 2 pounds of food a day, that's pretty do-able with a total pack weight of around 22 pounds. For mere weekend trips you can find psycho-light guys here carrying "reinforced mylar" a.k.a. cuben-fiber packs, with a total loaded pack weight INCLUDING food of notably less than 10 pounds.

For a totally frameless pack, or even one with just a pad for a frame, most of us wouldn't recommend more than about a 20 or 25 pound load- but there are exceptions.

(And, when a lot of us talk about "frameless" packs we actually also mean to include packs with just a primitive foam pad for a frame but not a true suspension. But there certainly ARE a lot of totally suspensionless/frameless packs, too, like the GoLite Ion, etc., etc.)

Some VERY small frameless UL packs do lack a waistbelt, but most still have one. Thus, no, you won't be carrying all the weight on your shoulders.

Back me up here, guys…

PostedDec 5, 2009 at 7:12 pm

Yes…the padding acting as a frame makes sense and clever.

Yes i was actually picturing a Jansport without hip belt.

Dean F. BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 7:15 pm

A lot of the purists here on BPL are annoyed at GoLite, a company that used to be cutting-edge in the UL community, but which has since been going more mainstream and making heavier and heavier packs. But for someone just starting to dip his toes into the UL pool, so to speak, I think they are an excellent "bridge". Look at their Pinnacle and Jam packs. (My first UL pack was an older Jam.)

http://www.golite.com.

Marc T BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 7:45 pm

With many ultralight packs the issue is going to be how the particular pack matches your personal anatomical profile. I have had better luck on the trail with my 3 year old 1.5 lb GoLite Pinnacle than with heavier Gregory packs considered very comfortable/stable by the reviews. My Gregory caused shoulder issues even with lighter weights. The adjust-ability of the Pinnacle is minimal, and packing technique is very important. You will never really be able to determine how well a pack will work for you, however, until you've taken it into the field. I think the readers here are often testing and rotating equipment from the popular sources: ULA, Gossamer Gear, GoLite etc. It's pretty easy to resell a lightly used pack, and its worth the effort to find something that works for your anatomy.

Luke Schmidt BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 8:01 pm

I'm going to respectfully disagree just a bit with Dean on the Golite Jam. If you're going to spend $150 or so for a pack that weighs almost 2 pounds you could just as easily get a pack with a frame that would be more easy to pack comfortably. Having said that I dearly love my frameless packs as long as I pack them right and keep weight reasonable.
Edit
I absulutely agree with Mark on the importance of a good fitting pack. I don't know what others think but I think its more crucial with a light pack that has less packing and adjustments.

Lawson Kline BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 8:13 pm

Lighten your load not your pack! A frame-less pack puts too much load on your shoulders and spine.

Dean F. BPL Member
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 8:15 pm

>> If you're going to spend $150 or so for a pack that weighs almost 2 pounds you could just as easily get a pack with a frame that would be more easy to pack comfortably.

What, one of the Gossamer Gear silnylon packs? But the trade-off is durability. Or are you thinking of something else? I haven't checked the market recently…

P.S. I also have an Osprey Exos as my "high-volume" pack, and I love it.

PostedDec 5, 2009 at 8:25 pm

No BS.

I have tried several internal frame packs and never felt as comfortable as I am when I have my frameless Granite Gear Virga on my back.

On a long trip I usually have a few extra pounds than I would like but that quickly lowers as I use my consumables, about 2 pounds a day. By the end of the trip my pack weight is down to around 10 pounds.

Why carry a large heavy internal frame pack when the benefit of the frame and the hipbelt are only noticeable the first few days. After that the weight of the frame is only a draw back.

Joseph

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...