Topic

Frameless Pack Carry Weight

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
PostedDec 5, 2009 at 6:28 pm

I know nothing about frameless packs, so I have some questions. How much weight can be carried in a frameless pack ? What kind of sizes do they come in ? and what are some good frameless packs to start out with that arnt to expensive that I can try to see if my son and I like UL frameless packs ?

Thanks,
J

PostedDec 5, 2009 at 6:46 pm

I would say 20-25lbs "comfortably" depending on the pack.

A few good choices in packs:

ULA conduit
Gossamer Gear Mariposa (frame or frame less)
MLD Exodus
Golite Jam2

You'll need the rest of your gear to be lightweight to ultra-lightweight for these packs to work, for multi-day trips.

PostedDec 5, 2009 at 9:31 pm

In my limited experience I find:

< 30 lbs = Tolerable
< 25 lbs = No worries
< 20 lbs = Nice to carry
< 15 lbs = Giggling down the trail

Obviously this varies a lot depending on the hiker, pack, pack fit, how well the pack is packed etc.

Subtract 5lbs from these weights if you don't have a hipbelt. I've done some experimenting without using the hipbelt in my Jam, and I found it noticably harder on the shoulders even though the pack is frameless.

The Jam is a good pack to start out with if you can get one for cheap. They can often be had for $50-$75. ULA and MLD make really sweet packs if you are able to spend more money (ie. $125-$200). That's still cheap compared to a traditional pack.

PostedDec 5, 2009 at 9:41 pm

How much you can comfortably carry in a frameless pack is a thoroughly variable thing. for one thing, frameless packs are frameless to varying degrees, for another it's personal. For me, I wouldn't care to carry more than 15 lbs in a truly frameless pack – but your shoulders may disagree with mine.

John G BPL Member
PostedDec 6, 2009 at 5:10 am

Check out this one:

http://www.rei.com/product/778469

Lid & Frame are removeable for a weight of 29 ounces. 2 lbs 10 ounces with frame & lid. The frame is a 1/8 thick piece of semi-flexible plastic with two 1/8" thick x 1/2" wide alumuinum bars glued to it.

I tried it in the store with 30 pounds and with all the gear loaded inside a 3/4 ridge rest that formed a tube inside the pack. The foam pad wrapped around to form 2 layers against my back, and I stuffed the pack full & cranked down the compression straps – so the pack body was pretty rigid. I was suprised to find that I felt the weight on my shoulders when bouncing up and down approx 33% LESS in frameless mode than with the frame. I use this "how much weight do I feel on my shoulders when bouncing up and down – without having the hip belt so tight it will cause bruises on my hip bones" test to compare packs without spending 2 hours in the store, and have found over the years (approx 30 backpacking) that it correlates with trail comfort pretty closely for me.

After several experiments, I discovered this was because the frame was bridging the gap created by my lower back and without the frame the hipbelt would suck the pack right up against my lower back and the friction would prevent the load from pulling down on the shoulder straps. I didn't try bending the frame stay's curve to match my back, so I can't comment on how frameless compares to a properly adjusted frame.

The flash does have some bells & whistles I wish it didn't, and the shoulder straps could be a little wider – but it's an inexpensive pack that will allow you to try frameless with little risk, since you can stick the frame in if you find you like it better – or you have an extra heavy load for a particular trip (ie: going somewhere with a Scout troop).

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...