I was looking for a little help. I am up in the air about two backpacks I'm looking to purchase.
I typically backpack for max three days two nights and currently have a 4900cu in pack. Im looking for a smaller pack. I can't decide on the Gregory Z55 or the Kelty Pawnee. Both are fairly equal in size ~3300 cu in/55L.
I like some of the features on the Kelty plus it was recommeneded in Backpack Mag.
Any help.
Thanks
Topic
Backpack Choice
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Well I'll wait for others to start throwing out pack names, I'm I don't think either of those 2 packs are going to be on anyone's top list due to their weight.
my motto, do the opposite of whatever Backpacker Mag says!
For a frame pack look at ULA or Golite.
-Tim
How much weight do you normally carry? Do you have any where that you can try one or both of these packs on?
John, please tell us more what gear you are going to be carrying for this 3-day backpacking trip, and how much it weights. this will in turn determine the kind of pack that you need.
Granite Gear Vapor trail for loads under 25lbs.
Granite Gear Nimbus Ozone for loads over 25lbs.
You can find either used for pretty cheap here.
I know not many people around here will recommend either of the packs based on their weight. However, I have the z55 and absolutely love it. Gregory packs seems to fit me exceptionally well, so I'm willing to carry a little extra weight.
Have you tried either pack on?
Thanks for the responses. Here is a little more info. Without the pack, food, water, clothes I'm around 15 lbs. So with either of these packs I would be a total of around 25-30 lbs with everything.
I'm on a budget and the Kelty is fairly inexpensive $70 and the Gregory is a little more at $115.
I have been working on reducing weight and going one item at a time buying low weight.
Thanks
Sorry forgot to mention. I did try the Gregory pack on at REI and it felt fairly good. I have not tried on this model of the Kelty but my other Kelty feels and fits good.
Don't know if it will help your decision, but REI outlet has the '08 Gregory Z55 at an additional 20% off the already marked down price, bringing it under $100.
FYI I belive Golite will be running a 40% off coupon code again, if not right now.
As has been said, both of those packs are not the popular choices in this community because of the weight. However, I have a Gregory Z65 and a Z55 and don't have any complaints on either of them.
If weight isn't your top priority and you're sure you have it limited to only those to packs, I'd go with the Z55 because of REI's sale Kimberly suggested. It totals $91.93 in shopping cart:
"Any help."
If you are at REI, you might check out their Flash series of packs, light, well designed, well regarded by Will Reitveld IIRC, and cheap. Plus you can always return one, no questions asked.
Yeah, I've been using my REI UL45 for a couple of years and love it. With my upcoming Arizona Trail Thru hike I'm looking at a larger volume pack to get in the extra food between resupplies and have been debating the flash 65 and a Jardine Kit. If REI puts the Flash 65 on clearance (that's when I bought my 45) I don't think I'll be able to resist.
To throw out another one:
If you want a full function pack how about the Osprey Exos? I love mine, for when I need a higher-volume pack.
(I know absolutely nothing about the Gregory or Kelty.)
Become a member to post in the forums.

