I'm just interested in general thoughts. I have the Extremely Light down Jacket on it's way in the mail.
If anyone has experience with both of these pieces and can compare them (the thermawrap as well) as far as warmth etc. I'd appreciate it.
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
I'm just interested in general thoughts. I have the Extremely Light down Jacket on it's way in the mail.
If anyone has experience with both of these pieces and can compare them (the thermawrap as well) as far as warmth etc. I'd appreciate it.
Ty,
I reviewed both the UL Down Inner Parka and EX Light Jacket for backpackgeartest.org; you can read my detailed comments there. Both are great pieces that save much weight and space over fleece. The Down Inner is more versatile and could be used by someone not especially cold-prone as an outer layer as well as its intended use as a mid-layer. The EX Light insulates better, fits slightly more snugly, and had some durability problems. In my opinion strictly a mid-layer because of its fragile fabric and weaker DWR.
Well the Ex Light Down Jacket is a few ounces lighter. I own both though my UL Down Jacket is the old model(2006?) with the snaps instead of a zipper. They are both excellent jackets in my opinion and hold up well. The Ex.Light jacket just finished a PCT thru-hike and still looks good as new (makes a great pillow too).
I'd like to say that they are both about the same in terms of warmth, but I've never taken them to the limit where they've started to feel cold so I can't really say for sure. I've never seen 3 season temperatures where my usual clothing layers couldn't handle it along with this jacket (which for me has been 20F with significant wind chill and above).
Montbell told me they offer the same warmth. The EL is lighter with higher quality fill and a more fragile fabric. The UL is made with a lesser down so it requires more of it for the same warmth. It also has a heartier fabric.
Apples to oranges.
If you are rough on your gear, get the UL. If you aren't, get the EL and save a small bit of weight.
There is not a lot of difference between them. If you like pockets, get the UL. The pockets add ~1oz. If you don't need pockets then get the EL and save ~ 1oz. A lot of marketing hype in the EL IMHO.
Thank you all for the feedback.
I went with the Extreme Light and now my only decision is between the size L or M. I am leaning towards the M for use as a form fitting mid-layer–almost like a shirt–for around camp in mild conditions.
Montbell sizes a little small since they are a Japanese company. If you are on the upper edge of a size medium like I am, I'd recommend the large size.
I happend to be at a nice shop this weekend and tried them both on. My .02 is the EL is not the coat I would have purchased. I am 6' 175#, long torso and arms. The EL is cut very short in the torso, with no bottom closure, and was just barely long enough in the arms for me. YMMV, depending on what you look like, lol. It just seemed to me the UL was warmer, with the bottom closure (elastic) and much longer torso. Also, it seemed the collar was a little higher on the UL when fully zipped. I am sure both will work for a mid layer, but the weight difference seemed worth it for the UL to me.
Become a member to post in the forums.