I have not purchased a neoair yet but might be getting one over the holidays. What is the lowest temps folks have used this pad in? I currently use a WM Badger 15 degree bag during the winter months.
Topic
Neoair (lowest temp)
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
This thread has a lot of opinions.
And according to this one, you need a cumulative R-Value of 5 when sleeping on frozen ground to avoid losing heat to the ground, regardless of sleeping bag rating.
NeoAir is only manutacture rated for 2.5, so you’ll need a CCF pad to make up the difference.
In my personal experience, I used the NeoAir + 1/8″ GG Thinlite on snow in temps in the mid 30s with a 30 degree bag. I was definitely losing heat through the pad. I was able to sleep, but when the couple times I woke up during the night, I was chilly.
I used the NeoAir into the high teens in Yosemite in August, but the ground wasn’t frozed. 32 degree bag + thinlite and Montbell UL down Inner Parka, and was chilled a bit, but the ground wasn’t frozen, so it was probably at least partly from pushing my bag so low.
This winter, I intend to try out a system of NeoAir sandwiched between a Thermarest Z-lite underneath and the GG 1/8″ thinlite on top. That should be an R-Value of 2.2+2.5+.45 for just over 5, using things I already own vs buying a new insulated pad. I’m hoping it’s adequate.
A lot depends on your individual body thermostat! There have been a couple reports on here from people who claim (they say) to have been warm at 15*F with a NeoAir and a 1/8" GG Thinlight pad. I would want at least a 1/2" CCF pad.
I did find, in my attempts to stay warm at 18*F, that putting the CCF pad on top of the NeoAir was a little warmer than having it underneath. The NeoAir was also slightly warmer when fully inflated, although it then became very uncomfortable and "bucked me off" every time I moved.
Considering that a 16 oz. POE insulated air pad is comfortable for me at 20*F, I decided to ditch the NeoAir. Adding a thick enough CCF pad to the NeoAir cancels out the weight savings of the latter, and the POE is far more comfortable. Your Mileage May Vary. I suggest that you either test your NeoAir at low temperatures at home or take an extra CCF pad along just in case.
while it certainly varies, there is a long-ish thread floating around where many folks were comfortable at freezing w/ the Neo Air- myself included, below freezing you'll need to add to it
for a three season pad it fits the bill, wasn't designed as a four season pad clearly, that goes for lots of pads though
I had THE 1st Neo Air in 'Vegas and discovered it a bit cool on a 30 F. night. But its bouncines and overnight cold air "shrinkage" (hee, hee) led me to return it and resume using my 10 year old Thermarest Lite. At 8,000 + ft. & 25 F. in the southern Sierra Nevadas later in this summer I was glad I wasn't on the Neo Air!
by the way, I asked Cascade Designs about whether they think it better to have the CCF on top of or underneath a NeoAir for snow camping – they said CCF under is best. Don't know how that correlates with anyone's experience. Anyone tried it both ways?
I'd take a 1/8" and a 2/8" inch. Put the 2/8" under and the 1/8" on top. The problem (with all 2.5" lofted air mattresses) is that you lose heat as cold air comes into contact with the sides of the pad. With the neo-air, though, it's too fragile to have on bare ground, so you have to have a pad underneath it or it will puncture. (I have two holes in mine already this way, easily repaired though.)
Paul- I used 1/8" Thinlight "under" the NeoAir and slept very warm at 28* with a down quilt.
Nate, what did you use to repair your Neo Air in the field? Do you suppose a Platy patch can be used to get by until you return home?
Frank, the NeoAir is a great pad. I like mine a lot. But it is distinctly not a winter pad.
I start feeling the cold from below somewhere in the low-mid 40s. Into the 30s is shivering, "just can't get warm" territory, despite all the extra layers on top. Some people on this site report having used their Neos around freezing and been OK. But the pads are about 1/2 as warm as you'd want for a winter pad. You might be able to make it workable with a foam pad, but…
Are you looking for us to tell you it's a great winter pad? 'Cause that's not what it's about. It is a great 3-season pad. If you're looking for something for winter, a Downmat might be the way to go. Obviously not as nice to carry in the warmer months, but for winter, not far off in weight if you consider adding the weights of a Neo, Ridge Rest, etc.
I just did an overnighter and the temp dropped to 30 degrees… I sleep cold, so I used my 1/8" Thinlight under the Neo short, and a 3/4" torso length Nightlight on top of the Neo, and my pack under my legs/feet. WM Summerlite under the stars and I was snug and toasty. Had it been warmer, I would have left the Neo at home to nix the weight… besides, my hips were sore the next morning. I am considering returning the neo for a dedicated cold weather pad, just using my GG pads in the warm months…
What about a 19oz Stephenson's DAM. It should be warm enough for most winters. I have an Exped Downmat 7, which is very warm, but light it isn't. I might eventually get a Stephenson's, but for now I still carry the Exped.
Aside from individual differences in cold tolerance, I think the answer to the NeoAir warmth depends on ground temps, NOT air temps. This would explain why some folks sleep OK into the low 30s and other are shivering. A warm autumn day can drop to freezing at night, but the ground is still above freezing. This is quite different to sleeping on frozen ground.
Stephenson's DAM is plenty warm enough for average winter temps. Watch the gear swap for a couple coming up for sale out of my closet!
^ I think that is a very valid observation, one that I hadn't thought of
my positive 30 degree experiences were on w/ unfrozen ground (@ ~ 10,000' )
I think the answer to the NeoAir warmth depends on ground temps, NOT air temps.
That has been a frequent rant of mine … for all kinds of pads. HOWEVER that opinion has been tempered by graphical info from Richard Nisley that ground temps (just a bit below the soil surface) are very closely correlated with air temps when the air temps are above 32*F. IIRC the same graph showed ground temps pretty much flat in the high 20*F-30*F range for air temps below 32*F.
The lowest temp for any pad is pretty subjective for most of us, because our body "thermostats" vary so much. I'm the first to admit that I'm most definitely a cold sleeper!
However, I consider a three-season pad one that will go down to 20*F (-7 C). I've seen temperatures that cold in Wyoming's Wind River Range in mid-August. My recent 18* F (-8 C) night was at the beginning of October–that's not exactly winter! Yes, I was at 5,000 ft. (1500 M) in the Washington Cascades, but nearby communities at about 1,000 ft. (300 M) elevation experienced the same low temperature that night. At least for me, the NeoAir does not qualify as more than a warm-weather pad!
I've had neoair down to upper 20s (~29F) and it was perfectly comfortable (for me). The ground wasn't frozen so that might have helped.
I had the NeoAir down to 25F during a sudden snowstorm, expected temps were in the low 40s. Would probably take the good ol' blue CCF to add to it if I expected such temps, as in shoulder seasons when the temps are routinely that low, as I do suspect the difference is in the ground temps overall rather than the pad itself.
A couple of months ago I slept on packed snow at 6000 feet, outside temp in the high 30s. I blew up the Neoair fully. It seemed that only my butt got cold (where the Neoair was maximally compressed) without a supplementary pad. A double layer of 1/8 CCF under my butt really increased my comfort. I think the inner baffling in the Neoair does little to insulate over an open tube design although I have never tried an old style air mattress. I'll take my 1/4 CCF next time.
Become a member to post in the forums.

