Can anybody who has purchased the caldera compact compare it with the original in terms of speed to boil, efficacy, wind protection and stability?
Thanks
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
Can anybody who has purchased the caldera compact compare it with the original in terms of speed to boil, efficacy, wind protection and stability?
Thanks
Whilst not directly answering your question, Michael, you will find a lot of information on the Caldera and the compact at this blog address. No hard numbers, but the Compact is not quite as efficient as the original Caldera, but in my view is close enough especially given there is no need to carry the extra weight of a caddy. However, YMMV.
I can produce no hard data, and only really used it on one hike so far, but my experience has been that it takes noticeably longer to get a good rolling boil with the compact version. I suppose that translates into worse fuel efficiency.
But +1 what Roger said- I'm using the compact for solo hikes no longer than a long weekend, situations in which the extra lightness and compactness (from not taking the caddy) are handy.
I'm thinking of getting one of the MLD compact calderas to replace my current one (MSR Titan Kettle), which I love dearly. I've been able to consistently boil 2 cups of water in the Titan with 1/2 oz alcohol, even starting at about 32 degrees.
So I am also very interested to hear if anyone has exact numbers for how much efficiency is lost. As it is, I think the weight and space savings alone would be worth it.
I estimate ~5-10% less fuel efficiency with the compact under standard conditions. BUT, you can dig a hole for your 12-10 or Esbit stand to sit in and lower the pot to achieve the same efficiency as the original stove.
I have the MLD compact setup as well as a Tri Ti for an the MSR Titan and I have def noticed a longer boil times with the compact. That said the small size and super low weight still make it very useful in my eye's. If I were going for a long unsupported trip where every gram of fuel mattered I would take the tri ti. For most normal outings the Compact setup is awesome and will still blow most normal alcohol or esbit systems out of the water.
>> BUT, you can dig a hole for your 12-10 or Esbit stand to sit in and lower the pot to achieve the same efficiency
!!! Lightbulb!
Thanks all for the comments,
Caldera Compact for xmas it is. As well as its smaller size I also like the idea of being able to grab it by the handles instead of using pot grippers/bandanna.
>> BUT, you can dig a hole for your 12-10 or Esbit stand to sit in and lower the pot to achieve the same efficiency
!!! Lightbulb!<<
I see the logic here, it's attractive to think we can have the best of both worlds. Doesn't this rely on the fact that you can still lower the mug into the cone which has to be perfectly fitted so that the lip can support it? I recall comments by Rand that the tolerances are looser now for the UL cones, and they can support several mug sizes now from a single cone design. Also, the slot on one side of the cone is absent with the UL design and I can't see how the handle would fit through the opening. To re-capture the efficiency you would need to lower the mug completely into the cone so that you can apply heat to the entire surface of the mug, right? Let me know if I'm missing something here. Is a mod to the UL design possible to allow us to get the best of both worlds?
"Doesn't this rely on the fact that you can still lower the mug into the cone"
Good point. I should have clarified that my comment was for the Caldera Keg where you can adjust the height of the can by moving the silicone band.
But as the 2 photos show, for the MLD 850 mug, Lynn's suggestion will also work.

Actually, it should work with any pot…all you're trying to do is increase the distance between the bottom of the pot and the top of the stove. No need to alter the height of the pot.
Become a member to post in the forums.