Topic

Driducks cancels out windshirt

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedNov 21, 2009 at 2:50 pm

Hey everybody, i have the driducks ul rainsuit (not the regular poncho), it has a hood that zips into the jacket collar. Anyway, it is wind/rain proof, so what the point in bringing my houdini windshirt? Seems like excess weight at this point, anyone else ditch the windshirt after getting driducks?

I notice that there seems to be some water collecting on the outside of the grey material on the suit, it does not bleed through to the other side, but it does increase the weight of the suit when it gets wet. Anyone else notice this, it seems to happen after i put it in the washing machine after some trips , not sure if it did it before.

http://www.froggtoggs.com/store/choose.asp?ItemNum=DD1232&ItemType=%

Thats the one i have.

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedNov 21, 2009 at 3:14 pm

Yes…no….maybe.

I carried a Frogg Togg jacket on the JMT but it never rained so I really only used it as a wind shirt for a few times, like going up the west side of Whitney or hanging out on top of the passes. It worked well when it was cold or I wasn't moving much. It definitely felt like a sauna. I imagine DriDucks perform much the same?

The Houdini breathes a lot better and is a more comfortable windshirt. It can still make me sweat though, so it's not perfect.

You'll have to weigh your intended uses to decide if you want a do it all rain shell or two lighter weight shells, one for wind and one for precip.

In the end there are a lot of wind/rain/snow protection schemes you can use. You found one of them. There are more :)

PostedNov 21, 2009 at 3:45 pm

The last few outings I have only brought the driDuck jacket. The windshirt has wetted out during two rainstorms so now I dont bother carrying it. The only reason i would return to using it would be for its high comfort level and extremely lightweight.

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedNov 21, 2009 at 5:04 pm

What Jeff said. A windshirt is never really a necessity, as any rain jacket will act as a windshirt, it just won't breathe as well. Propore breathes better than Goretex (but not as good as Event) but still not as good as a nice windshirt. So, it really depends on how often you might use a windshirt and how much sweat you will generate and can tolerate under a rain jacket (when used as a windshirt).

EndoftheTrail BPL Member
PostedNov 22, 2009 at 4:51 am

For 3-season day trips — I habitually carry a windshirt and leave wp/b jacket (e.g. Driducks) at home. I like the added breathability – and in case of rain, I'm not all that far away from the trailhead.

On multiple-day hikes, however, it's the reverse — I take my wp/b shell and leave the windshirt at home.

PostedNov 22, 2009 at 11:33 am

I use my windshirt a LOT, and in many situations where my DriDucks would get shredded and I would boil with excess perspiration. So it depends as much on what kind of hiking you do as it does on the weather IMHO.

Michael Martin BPL Member
PostedNov 22, 2009 at 5:14 pm

I've been hiking with a DriDucks shell for several years now, and I've gone both with and without a windshirt. If you are extremely weight conscious, I agree with the other posters — go ahead and leave the WS behind. But, there are still a number of good reasons to carry both a WS and DD:

1) The DD shell has a very roomy cut and can flap around a lot in the wind. A more form-fitting windshell is a nice alternative that flaps less and pumps less air through.

2) A windshirt is more breathable than the DD, allowing you to take it into warmer conditions and higher exertion levels that would otherwise swamp the moisture transfer capacity of the DD.

3) For quick rest stops, very windy conditions, and/or low exertion levels, you can wear both the WS and DD at the same time. The extra boundary layer of air between them adds a nice warmth boost. I used this system extensively on the last BPL Wilderness Trekking course with Andy Skurka where we were hiking along an exposed ridge with 30+ mph wind gusts. Though, in fairness, my "windshell" on that hike was the hyper-breathable BPL Thorofare Shirt. My total torso layers for the trip were (1) Lightweight poly zip-T base layer; (2) Thorofare shirt; (3) Driducks shell; and (4) BPL Cocoon Hoody for use in camp.

Cheers,

-Mike

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...