Topic

Doing it wrong?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
PostedNov 19, 2009 at 9:46 am

So recently I was doing some day hiking with my pack fully loaded, just getting some exercise and taking advantage of unseasonably warm weather. There's an outdoor store near the trailhead that I stopped in to grab some small stuff. I had my pack on when I went in there, and a salesperson stopped me in my tracks and said I had my hip belt on "WAY too high".

He offered to fit it "properly" and I figured why not hear him out. I had my hipbelt so the top was roughly an inch above my illiac crest, as I had always been taught, and for me that is roughly even with my belly button. The salesperson adjusted the shoulder straps and all so that the bottom of my hip belt is at the top of my ball and socket joint for my femur. This also put the weight of my lumbar pad solidly on my L5 vertebrae, the last of the lumbar vertebrae. The front of the belt feels great because it's not pressing on my pony keg anymore (it's been years since I've had a six pack ha!), but it feels like it's kinda restricting my sideways leg movement.

This new adjustment seems odd to me, but I've been obsessing on this for the past few days since this encounter. I feel like someone's just asked me how to breathe and now that I've gotta think it through, I can't get back to normal. Everything I can read says the illiac crest placement I had was right, but pics of other hikers don't really convince me of either way. I got the chance to walk a couple miles around the neighborhood with this new configuration, and it felt OK, hard to tell if it's better or worse in such a short jaunt.

So tell me – where do you place your hipbelt?

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 9:55 am

Can you easily lift you knees up 90 degrees without the hip belt restricting the movement?

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 9:59 am

Yeah 90 degrees no problem – i can feel the belt on my leg with the lower config, but it's not hindering movement

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 10:04 am

I've always read that you put the hip pad centered on the "hip bone". I don't have any "hips", so mine tends to be lower. Most everyone I look at seems to have theirs too high. The belt is definitely below my naval, a requirement for me (can't have anything pressing on my naval). I'm guessing that once I get walking, the top of my hip belt is about even with my "hip bone".

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedNov 19, 2009 at 10:06 am

Kieran, the sales guy you met was flat-out wrong. You've been doing it right. Don't listen to a thing he said. I've met a lot of "packfitters" who don't know how to properly fit packs.

Center of the belt, or perhaps the top third of the belt, on your iliac crest, on your side, the highest point of your hip.

If you wear a pack like he told you to the pack will not transfer weight to your hips as well. The pack will tend to slip down. It will restrict hip movement to a degree. If your pack is already properly fitted, then wearing it lower will cause the shoulder straps to wrap too much over your shoulder.

Ignore everything he said, continue on as you were before.

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 10:09 am

My advice would be to wear it where it is comfortable. I think wearing the hipbelt up on the illiac crest is a good general starting point, but results may vary for some. I personally have to wear mine slightly below the illiac crest because it is just too uncomfortable to wear any higher.

Also, I definitely wouldn't stress out about it. Just try wearing it in some different configurations, and see what works best for you.

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 10:19 am

Agreed, do what works for you. I wear mine more like the guy in the shop fitted yours, but that's because it's where it's most comfortable FOR ME. I used to wear it centred ON the iliac crest (not an inch above like you were doing, that's waaaay to high for me), but all that did was wear the skin off my (then) bony hip. It's a food thing to keep in mind when buying a new pack, as the sizing will affect how you wear it. If I measure myself using most of the manufacturers methods, I would always be a size small torso, but because I wear mine lower, I really need a medium-large to keep the weight off my shoulders.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedNov 19, 2009 at 10:39 am

Larry, try an experiment. Put your hands on your hips. Roll your hands upward a bit, then push in on top of the hard spot. When you push down your hands won't be able to go anywhere. That'd be your iliac crest. Although many of us aren't "hippy," we all have hips (an iliac crest on each side)!

I agree that the most important part of pack fit is to find one that's comfortable. No question. But many people buy packs that are too long in the torso. I somewhat frequently even see who are wearing the belt properly but who have the shoulder straps attaching to the pack above the level of the shoulder. This will keep the weight off the shoulders, but won't provide any stability to the pack. Additionally, if the pack were fitted properly and it had adequate framing, then you shouldn't need to fit it that way. This is why you tend to see people wearing frameless packs that are technically too long for their torso–the pack doesn't have a frame, doesn't transfer weight to their hips as well, which means they need to get the weight off their shoulders somehow. That's how we used to fit external frames in the days before load lifters.

By far the most common mistake in pack fitting is wearing the pack too low. Hey, I wore mine that way for several years, too! But I gave the "right" way more time than I really wanted, and found that it is a more comfortable, more effective way to fit a pack.

If you're concerned about your navel, you can usually keep the hipbelt itself positioned properly, but kinda pull the front of the webbing a little lower to buckle.

Edit: Yup, I used to write "breathe" on my to-do lists…

Thomas Burns BPL Member
PostedNov 19, 2009 at 11:06 am

Only what feels comfortable to you.

I wear my "hip" belt right over my belly button because of a herniated belly button that I've had since birth.

If it feels comfortable to you over long distance, then go with it.

(And tell that officious salesperson to get stuffed.)

Stargazer

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 11:25 am

Yup, I do have a “hip bone” and I can feel the iliac crest. I typically start with the hip belt centered over that, but as I adjust the pack I think it ends up a little lower. And the hip belt tends to angle down in the front, so that also helps keep it off the naval.

I too have a pack that is longer than my measured torso length. But, the attachment point of the shoulder straps is lower than my shoulders and the fit seems good to me. When I purchased it (it is my first internal frame pack) I had the lady at REI check to see if it fit “properly”. Her hands flew pulling on straps (I had no idea how to adjust an internal frame pack) and it felt great when she was done. She asked me how much weight I planned to carry so I could “test drive” the pack. She gasped in horror when I responded (between 80-100 lbs). 40 lbs was the most she would/could put in it. It felt so comfortable that I would touch any of her adjustments for a long time (until I understood what they were for). I guess I got lucky in getting someone that knew what they were doing. ;-)

So, to answer the OP, I tend to have the upper half of the hip belt on the iliac crest, I think. Centered is the highest it would be.

Hope that helps. 

PostedNov 19, 2009 at 11:51 am

I think you also need to consider where the pack will rest at your lumbar region as well. For packs that have lumbar pads, I like to let the pad find its sweet spot, then tighten the hipbelt in place, which is always centered over the hipbones, not resting on top. A hip-belt is padded for a reason, its made to wrap around the hips, not way up high on ones upper stomach.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...