So recently I was doing some day hiking with my pack fully loaded, just getting some exercise and taking advantage of unseasonably warm weather. There's an outdoor store near the trailhead that I stopped in to grab some small stuff. I had my pack on when I went in there, and a salesperson stopped me in my tracks and said I had my hip belt on "WAY too high".
He offered to fit it "properly" and I figured why not hear him out. I had my hipbelt so the top was roughly an inch above my illiac crest, as I had always been taught, and for me that is roughly even with my belly button. The salesperson adjusted the shoulder straps and all so that the bottom of my hip belt is at the top of my ball and socket joint for my femur. This also put the weight of my lumbar pad solidly on my L5 vertebrae, the last of the lumbar vertebrae. The front of the belt feels great because it's not pressing on my pony keg anymore (it's been years since I've had a six pack ha!), but it feels like it's kinda restricting my sideways leg movement.
This new adjustment seems odd to me, but I've been obsessing on this for the past few days since this encounter. I feel like someone's just asked me how to breathe and now that I've gotta think it through, I can't get back to normal. Everything I can read says the illiac crest placement I had was right, but pics of other hikers don't really convince me of either way. I got the chance to walk a couple miles around the neighborhood with this new configuration, and it felt OK, hard to tell if it's better or worse in such a short jaunt.
So tell me – where do you place your hipbelt?

