Topic

Caldera Cone Keg-Foster’s: I broke mine

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
PostedNov 13, 2009 at 5:16 pm

I have about 40 days on a Caldera Cone Keg-F – the Fosters can version, and have developed holes at the support ring. I finally noticed them when cooking over fine dry sand, and saw the wet spots. I've been in contact with Trail Designs, and Rand has been great! He sent a replacement , AND a 2nd can, AND a Caddy, gratis, the day he got my e-mail.

And it turns out that it is probably Operator Error. I haven't been using a Caddy, just laying the Fosters with the Cone and stove at the top, back, of my pack, nested amongst other stuff, lightly cinching down the collar, and then clipping down the lid. Even though I was trying to be careful about over-compressing, I think that was the culprit. With every step I took the pack flexed the Fosters can ever-so-slightly until (360,000 steps later) it stress-cracked at the support ring. At least that is the current theory. Mine was the first, and Rand feels that eventually, due to the thinness of these cans, pin-holing or cracking will eventually occur, especially without Caddy.

Note the shiny spots on the outside, and the faint dark spots on the inside.

FostersB Holes

Fosters Inside

Check Your Fosters by looking for similar bright spots, and feeling on the inside, under the lip for a slight bump.

Because I don't want to use a Caddy I'll probably get a Keg-H (Heineken), which, while a little heavier, is a substantially more robust.

So, no complaints from me, just the realization that everything has a lifetime, especially if not used as designed (i.e. without a Caddy).

Great product. Great Support.

PostedNov 14, 2009 at 1:20 pm

It's why I never used a Fosters can with any of the MYOG projects. Kinda interesting, is there a seam halfway up the Fosters can? Was that a cut and weld intended to hold the cone? On my Heineken I added a few wraps of fiberglass wick, JBWeld'ed, for that purpose.

I've heard similarly great feedback on customer support from Trail Designs. An excellent cottage company.

thanks for the story/warning

-Michael

PostedNov 14, 2009 at 1:40 pm

Michael,
They roll-form a lip into the can at that location to provide the support interface to the Cone. I think (WAG) that discontinuity concentrated the stess from the flexing.

The can what still quite usable, but I knew the end was in sight.

I think Ball makes all these-straight sided cans, and would guess they are identical.

PostedNov 16, 2009 at 11:04 am

Trail Designs has moved a away from that ridge and instead provides a silicone band that you place around the can to hold it in place. So now you can replace your Foster's can anytime you feel like it without having to get another one from TD.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Loading...