Topic

Intergral Designs Primalid vs. Fleece Beanie

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Tony Wong BPL Member
PostedNov 1, 2009 at 11:33 pm

Anyone have any experience using the Primalid?

http://www.integraldesigns.com/product_detail.cfm?id=769&CFID=1369859&CFTOKEN=44352917

I hike pretty much in the Sierra/Yosemite area three season and into the shoulder seasons.

Currently I am using a REI 2.0 oz fleece hat, which can use while hiking and as part of my sleeping system.

I like that it is able to pull down to cover my ears and most of my neck.

What intrigued me about the Primalid was that it was the same weight and looks like it should be warmer than what I currently have for the same weight and does not restrict peripheral vision like the BPL Balaclavas.

For those who might have this, does it pull down far enough to cover your ears and back of your neck?

Is it too warm to wear while hiking in cooler weather when a fleece beanie would be perfect for keeping you warm?

How does it compare to your previous insulating hat/fleece?

Seems like this could be a winner over my fleece hat if has duel use for hiking and sleeping.

Thanks for your thoughts.

-Tony

Hendrik Morkel BPL Member
PostedNov 2, 2009 at 5:57 am

Hey Tony,

I don’t have the Primalid, and neither the Black Rock Hat but the latter is filled with down which means it is lighter. The Black Rock Hat weighs 0.74 oz which ain’t bad at all, and it looks like it should be a decent hat for using it for sleeping as well.

I myself use a Klättermusen Loke for sleeping, and also use a Merino Buff with it. Works good for me. Anyhow.

I think you could use the ID hat for what you planned in case you don’t like down or merino, and that it should be warmer than a fleece hat which you’re currently using.

Jonathan Ryan BPL Member
PostedNov 2, 2009 at 7:27 am

Hello,
I have a Prima Lid and it is a pretty solid product. I bought it to use as part of my sleep system. There is a fair amount of insulation in the hat so I would think it would be too warm to hike in in all but the most extreme cold.

PostedNov 2, 2009 at 8:12 pm

"Seems like this could be a winner over my fleece hat if has duel use for hiking and sleeping."

It's going to be too warm to hike in, Tony. But great for around camp and as part of a sleep system.

Tony Wong BPL Member
PostedNov 3, 2009 at 9:45 am

Thanks to everyone who replied back.

Well, looks like I will be hanging onto my trusty REI fleece hat for now.

Maybe the Primalid would be good for snow camping.

You guys just saved me $30!

-Tony

Evan Cabodi BPL Member
PostedNov 3, 2009 at 4:15 pm

Interesting thread! My buddy emailed me about the discussion since I make the Black Rock Hats. I've seen the down Balaclava's before. I'm sure they are really nice to sleep in but they don't look like much fun during the day.

If you really like your REI fleece you'd probably love going to some sort of down product. My hat's work really well as an additional sleep system since they fit nicely on your head. They cover your ears and are soft all the way around for a nice feel while in the bag.

The other advantage over fleece is that the hat is basically windproof and wicks the sweat away from your head better than fleece. It also works really well in the rain and dries out much quicker than wool or fleece. It also packs smaller than a fleece and makes it much easier to want to take a warm hat on trips where you aren't sure you even need it.

You might also check out the Balaclava made by Nunatak. Very expensive but if you really need something purely for sub-zero sleeping you might check it out.

Tony Wong BPL Member
PostedNov 3, 2009 at 9:55 pm

Evan,

Thanks for your thoughts.

I checked out your website and your Beanie looks pretty intriguing.

My concern is how your hat might handle in heavy rain given that it is down.

Maybe not a fair question given that I do have a MLD Poncho tarp to provide head protection.

There are times when I have hiked in the rain without the hood because the silnylon is a bit noisy and I have my Sunday Afternoon hat on with my fleece beanie underneath.

When you say that the Black Rock Beanie dries out faster than fleece, are you talking about the shell? Not assuming that the down feathers inside are soaked?

-Tony

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedNov 4, 2009 at 6:46 am

Very Cool, I didn't even know such a hat existed. How much down is in each hat? Would it loft comparable to the hood on say the Mont-Bell Alpine Light Jacket?

Evan Cabodi BPL Member
PostedNov 9, 2009 at 5:46 pm

Tony – The hat actually does very well in the rain. The shell material used has a very good DWR finish and sheds the water nicely. In addition to the high quality material the 900fp down is really good at wicking away moisture. The higher quality down will help pull the moisture through it distributing it evenly and allowing it to evaporate quickly. It's one reason you never have that clammy feeling like you get from non-breathable synthetics.

Compared to a fleece the hat definitely dries faster, inside and out. You never get that chilled layer of sweat or rain that builds up in the fabric and has a hard time to evaporate. The inside headband pulls the sweat from your head while the down continues to breath and dry throughout.

Below is a thread I've got going testing the material's and down I use in the hats. It's got detailed information and photo's on the hat and shows the DWR coating in action.

http://www.whiteblaze.net/forum/showthread.php?t=47681

Bradford – The hat has about 1/2 an inch of loft throughout and is similar to the MontBell UL Down Parka itself. I would have to say that it's actually much warmer than the hood since it's also got a soft headband liner and fits snug to your head keeping the heat in. It's very much like having one of the light down sweaters for you head and you are right, there is definitely nothing like it out there.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
Loading...