Topic

The One, Lunar Solo e, Contrail, [Vamp]

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 10:01 am

I've been researching 3 season solo shelters in reviews and on the forum and looking for feedback comparing these shelters for stability in windy conditions, ability to snug down tight in storms, ease of setup and condensation. Some condensation doesn't matter that much to me – it's to be expected with many single wall shelters, and as long as I don't contact the tent sides all the time I'll be fine.

Note that I'm 6 ft tall 190 lbs and walk with 2 adjustable poles (hence prefer a solo shelter that will take advantage of hiking poles) and will use this shelter mostly in the Sierras and Santa Cruz mountains of N California, and more rarely in New England and the Pacific Northwest. I would also add the Six Moon Designs Vamp to this list when Ron posts in around November/December.

If there's another shelter you think I should be considering, by all means let me know. I'm open to suggestions.

Gossamer Gear The One
Six Moon Designs Lunar Solo e
Tarptent Contrail
[Six Moon Designs Vamp]

PostedOct 30, 2009 at 10:27 am

You might also want to look at the Nemo Meta 1P, although it is not avail. until Feb 2010. Under 2 lbs and 100" of interior length. Because of the sloping walls I figure high 80 inch usable length. Looks reasonably 'bomber' for a single wall 3 season.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 12:59 pm

Hi David, the Nemo Meta 1P looks very nice. Thanks for the heads up. Looks similar to the Lunar Solo e. Have you ever used anything of theirs or heard anything about their tents?

Hi Dave T., thanks for the feedback. Heard some nice things about the Contrail – a few quick questions:
-How does your Contrail do in strong winds?
-Can you snug down your Contrail nice and tight to the ground when you need to without losing a lot of space? When snugged down straight to the ground, would it be enough space for someone 6 ft tall?
-When you do snug it down, is there still adequate ventilation?

PostedOct 30, 2009 at 2:57 pm

I have used both the Contrail and the One – and I am 6 ft tall as well.

The Contrail is by far the roomier tent – I have spent about 1,5 years of my life in tarptents (Virga, Virga 2 and Contrail) and liked them all. You can't go wrong with them. But they are not ideal for strong winds, although you can make them more wind resistant with the side guylines.

I have also used the One, but only for a very short time – it was leaking like hell. I had to return it to GG and got a refund. GG claimed that I had just received a tent with faulty fabric. Now they have a new version of the One on the market which might not have that problem. The One is much more complicated to set up than the Contrail and although I still felt ok in the One you are much more restricted than in the Contrail.

I have hiked in the regions you mention on my PCT thruhike and the tarptent Virga (earlier version of the Contrail) was more than sufficient.

Considering the cheaper price, easier setup, more room and tested waterproofness I would go for the Contrail.

Christine

PostedOct 30, 2009 at 3:13 pm

I had a Contrail ,and in some higher winds, it can flap a bit even when fully staked out tightly.

I sold it and now have a TarpTent MOMENT which is VERY stable in high winds by my own experience at 11,550 ft. in the Rockies in all night winds often above 45 mph.

For 4 more ounces I'd definitely go with the MOMENT. No question about it. Even faster setup than the Contrail and more convienant sit-up space with more headroom. Also a better vestibule arrangement IMHO.

Eric

Ross Bleakney BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 3:55 pm

Some of it is personal preference. A lot of people like the high point of the tent to be in the middle. That way, when they sit up, they don't need to scoot to one end. Personally, I like the high point to be by my head. That way, when I lie down and look up, I have a lot of space between myself and the top of the tent (it feels roomier). Plus, I think that helps a bit with condensation (all other things being equal).

Jay Wilkerson BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 4:34 pm

I really like the Sublite at 21.5 oz..Plenty of side room and headroom. The Sublite is a perfect solo tent IMHO. I am 6"3-230lbs and I have A Lot room for sleeping and messing around with a small stove if need be.. I was in debate between the One and the Sublite…I purchased the Sublite in Gear swap at a great price and was told the set up is much easier then the One..It can be set up with 4 stakes in just under two minutes..One of the best features of the Sublite is the ventilation.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 4:51 pm

Jay, do you mean Sublite Sil? For some reason it doesn't appear on Tarptent's website anymore. Only Sublite, which is supposed to be water resistant and not waterproof.

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 5:14 pm

Can anyone comment on the Lunar Solo e compared with any of the pole-supported shelters mentioned, especially the pole-supported Contrail, Sublite and the Nemo Meta 1P (at least by the looks of the design).

Eric, good to hear the Moment held up. Can you snug down all the sides of the Moment tight down to the ground?

Basically, I expect some condensation and it's not a big issue for me unless the tent is so restrictive I keep bumping into wet walls.

What I'm looking for is a light but sturdy shelter that will:

-perform well in windy weather, not deflecting or flapping too much (though needn't be a mountaineering summit tent or winter tent).

-snug down tight to the ground in a storm, to stop wind and wind-driven rain.

-if possible take advantage of my adjustable hiking poles for strength and weight savings.

A shelter that will make less noise and move less = better night's sleep for me.

Backpack Jack BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 6:37 pm

EJ If you are going on the hike to Point Reyes I will be there with my Lunar Solo and you can check it out for your self. This is the only tarp tent I own and I haven't used it enough to give you any feed back, just wanted to let you know I would be on that trip if you wanted to check out up close. I set it up when I first got it at my friends house so he could lay in it, he's 6'2" I think, and he still had plenty of room. I thought I saw your post on the Point Reyes trip so hopefully will see you there and you can check it out. Jack

Ethan A. BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 8:28 pm

Jack that's great. Yes my wife and I absolutely plan to be there.

Backpack Jack BPL Member
PostedOct 30, 2009 at 9:24 pm

EJ on one of my trips I think it was actually my 1st trip me and my 12 year old daughter were able to sleep in it. The only problem we had was when she woke up her head hit the tent were there was a little condensation but not bad. I was surprised that we both fit, snug! but doable. The thing I like most is the light weight, my pack just keeps getting lighter and lighter thanks to the people on this forum and the smaller companies that produce UL equipment my hats of to them!! Jack

sheila o BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2009 at 1:33 pm

I really like my Lunar Solo E, but I haven't tried any others. I'm 5'6", but there has to be at least 1.5 feet extra room. See ya at Point Reyes also, but likey sharing a 2 person tent with a buddy.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2009 at 3:23 pm

For what it's worth, I tried a Lunar Solo (e) for two summers, then sold it. My situation is a bit different from many in that I share my shelter with an 80-lb. mostly Labrador Retriever.

For nice nights when we just crawled into the tent to sleep, it worked out fine. My dog curled up in the triangular area at the back (gear storage space) and was quite happy there. When it rained, though, the tent was just too cramped to spend the evening in.

I also had a lot more condensation problems with two sets of lungs crammed into a space designed to ventilate only one. In other words, it's designed to be a solo tent. With a much smaller dog, it might be OK.

Headroom was a bit of an issue, even with the head end pulled out. I'm only 5'3"; however I sleep on a 2.5" thick air pad (that's 160 cm and 6.4 cm for you metric folks). It took a long time before I finally learned to sit up without brushing the top of my sleeping bag hood against the tent wall! A 6-footer (183 cm) with a similarly thick pad might have significant issues with headroom. I also prefer the high point of the tent at my head.

The Lunar Solo has really wide eaves ("skirts"?) that stick out way beyond the netting portion of the tent wall (I think at least a foot–I didn't measure, though). This is excellent in that you can have the tent pitched as high as you can and still have no splash coming in even during a Rocky Mountain cloudburst. IMHO, it's also bad because the wide eaves appeared to funnel moisture from wet ground or grass into the tent. I regularly noticed condensation on the underside of the eaves and just inside the netting long before it became a problem on the upper part of the tent.

The shape of the LS is excellent at shedding strong wind (as I discovered during the Colorado cloudbursts). It also means that you can sit comfortably in your sleeping bag and wipe down the entire inside of the tent down without crawling out of bed. (The exception was when my dog woke up first and started the dreaded Labrador tail-wag routine! I didn't have to wipe the tent but things got pretty wet inside!) Most of the tent should shed moderate snow just fine, but I suspect that the almost-flat triangle at the back might be a problem.

I did find that even without the dog, the LS was more prone to internal condensation than a Henry Shires tent (Rainshadow 2 with 3 people inside) pitched right next door. I had quite a bit of condensation while the Rainshadow had zero (this was during several nights on Washington's Olympic National Park coast with its usual fog and drizzle).

I suspect that if I had always been going solo without dog, I'd have kept the Lunar Solo. With the dog, though, it's much better with a slightly larger tent!

Viewing 21 posts - 1 through 21 (of 21 total)
Loading...