Topic

Initial thoughts on the MLD Trailstar

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
David Chenault BPL Member
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 7:52 am

I've had mine for a month now, and have spent ten nights in it. Conditions included light snow and rain, winds up to 20 mph, and temps from around freezing to 5 below (F).

In summary, I like it. It's a clever design that is well executed, blending cost, versatility, size and weight effectively. It's capacious for two folks and all gear. It has limitations, but only those which are not really separable from the design.

MLD does a good job minding the details. I love that it ships with a bunch of guyline, all that I've wanted to rig it for a flip, and more sil-sealer than is necessary. Some of the stitching is less than flawless, but only in a cosmetic way. Bartacks are in all the right places, and I was pleased with how large the gridstop inner peak reinforcement is. Not only can you use a trekking pole to pitch the tarp, but a paddle or even a handy branch could be used with no worries.

The linelocks are brilliant. They make pitching and adjusting the Trailstar very quick and easy. The instructions on the MLD website are dead on. I've rigged each of the five corners with a generous amount of cord. It makes it easy to tie it tight to a stake, or loop it around a stick, rock, or tree.

Most often I stake four corners loosely, put in the center pole, then tie the fifth corner out, ideally to a convenient tree that provides a bit of rain protection for the entrance. This rig makes the entrance larger and easier to get in, but the effective protected sleep space a little shorter. When the weather looks a little more windy, I tie or stake down all five corners, then guy out and up one of the midpoints. (As pictured on the MLD website.) This increases the interior space (especially length) quite a bit, and makes things a bit more sheltered.

An adjustable pole is ideal for the Trailstar. I've been using my one-piece 115cm poles, and with the center pole straight up I cannot get all sides pitched to the ground. This hasn't been necessary, but with strongly blowing rain or snow would be handy.

I'll find out this winter how the Trailstar deals with snow, but I presume its low profile would sag a good bit under more than moderate snow loads. Time will tell.

I've yet to hand the shelter from the outside peak loop, but doing so in the right situation should be simple enough. Rigged this way without the center pole, you could fit three full sized adults inside very nicely.

Mine weighs 20 oz with a very thorough seam sealing and all 60' of factory guyline. It loosely stuffs into the included sack, which is the size of a loaf of bread.

Come spring, I'll be making an inner net to clip onto the factory clips, to enable use come bug season.

Lastly, the subtle silver-gray is a good color. Not too light, not too dark, and blends in to the scenery well enough.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 8:52 am

It would be interesting to know why someone would chose this shelter now that the Speed Mid is available for only 2.5oz more? It seems the latter would be more usable in all types of weather.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 9:34 am

I took the SpeedMid out last weekend for a short trip in Dolly Sods. What a wonderful shelter. Sets up blazingly fast (stake 4 corners, prop up the center, you're done if you want to be. Stake the mids in necessary). Plenty of lightweight room for a one person shelter. Internal clips are a nice touch (used one to keep my bivy off my face). Got a small bit of snow, couple of inches, but only about an inch fell on the shelter and iced over a bit. Wiped right off with a pack towel.

Ron did me a favor by overnighting me the last one he had in the shop so I could have it in time for the trip. Forgot the polejack, so I used a spare set of TiGoat trekking poles (or, actually, three pieces of the four). I've got to mod my GG Lighttreks so I can use them like the TiGoats if GG tells me there's no problem with the mod (with the TiGoats you can remove a cap in the top [handle] portion, and insert the bottom end of the other trekking pole in, so you have an expandable 3-section pole. Really worked like a charm!). The shelter pitched quite taut with minimal fuss. I tightened it up a bit just before going to bed (after it had been snowed on for a couple of hours, but no real accumulation). I'll be interested to see how it does with a bit more snow load (but not too much, I realize it's not made for heavy snow loads!).

Can certainly highly recommend the SpeedMid after one use! (Of course, I'm a rather big fan of Ron's gear. Not only well made, but really thoughtful touches, like the linelocs mentioned above, and the clips on the inside).

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 10:17 am

Thanks Douglas for the review on the Speed Mid! Is there sufficient room end to end for a 'long' bag or do you suspect that there would be some touching?

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 11:14 am

"Is there sufficient room end to end for a 'long' bag or do you suspect that there would be some touching?"

Hi David. I think there would be some touching if you just went along one side. But if you were using it by yourself, or perhaps even with your son (if he's still as small as the pic!), then you could slant the center pole a bit and cant your bag a bit to avoid touching, say end to mid, if that makes sense. I'm using my hammock this coming weekend, so I can't try it out, but perhaps I'll use it again the following weekend and try it and let you know.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 11:26 am

Thanks Douglas – Yes – that is what I thought. The Speed Mid has more slanted ends than the Super Mid. As a solo shelter, however, there would be a ton of room.

David Chenault BPL Member
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 1:59 pm

Matt, I don't post full reviews without many more days of use. Maybe by next summer.

David, Doug answered your question. The Trailstar sounds roomier.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 2:25 pm

Back to the TrailStar. This is a spaciius two person shelter with room for gear.
I used a 120 cm fixed pole with good results in getting it off the ground, and line tensioners to keep the pitch taut. The "door" can be set up between any of the corners, so the shelter does not have to be moved if the wind changes direction. You can also lower the door just by reaching out and grabing the pole to take it down. No need to get totally out from underneath.
Trailstar
Some might recognize this tent site!near Donohue Pass

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 2:54 pm

Back to David's question on why someone might choose a Trailstar over the SpeedMid – no moving parts. No zippers to stick/break. Some might see that as a plus. Some might see it as an inconvience. I like having a door, easier ingress and egress! But there's something to be said for no moving parts. It's why I bought a Patrol Shelter, and would prefer it to the Alpinelite beaked bivy with zipper that someone recently posted pics of.

Of course, I now have way too much gear, much of it bought before I found and fell in love with my Warbonnet Blackbird. Might be some good deals come Spring! Some of it in cuben!

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...