I can personally vouch for the ID Salathe. Its heavier than many other bivy designs but I trust this bivy under all but the most extreme weather conditions. What I like is that it is easy to get into and can be used with a right or left zip sleeping bag since it zips 32" open on both sides. You can't vent it as much as you want or close it up as much as you want. I've never really had condensation issues. I've only had condensation issues in temps well below freezing when I have closed up the bivy nearly all the way. That's to be expected. I had a 40 degree bag that I was squeezing every degree of temperature out of to stay warm. It was a true bivuoac situation.
I use mine high up in the Colorado Rockies on climbing trips. Sometimes I bivuoac high up at near 13,000 feet when I'm going to be climbing multiple peaks the next day. Its a great option. I use it as my primary shelter and don't bother with tents anymore. I do bring a poncho/tarp but don't bother to set it up 90% of the time because I trust this thing so much. I don't think a lot of the really lightweight shelters used by many would hold up in the conditions I use the Salathe in. I have dealt with horrific winds and frightening thunderstorms way up high very farm from treeline at the base of 13,000 and 14,000 foot mountains.
It is a very robust and versatile bivy sack. I really can't say I regret buying it. I just can't think of a single bivy sack on the market that does what my Salathe does without costing a fortune. I got mine on sale at REI for a very good price a couple years ago. If money was not a factor I would probably have got maybe a Black Diamond Bipod or ID eVent Unishelter. I don't have that kind of money so went with the Salathe. Like I said, sure it might be heavier than a lot of bivy sacks but I just don't see many of the ultralight shelter systems holding up in the conditions I use the Salathe in. It is designed for climbing and suriving brutal mountain weather.
It would work fine with a synthetic cold weather bag. It doesn't work so well with high lofting down sleeping bags and feel that anything warmer than a 20 degree down bag would be pushing it for chest girth. I mainly use 30 and 40 degree down bags with this but since synthetics don't loft up as much as down bags and have stiffer insulation it should work fine with a cold weather synthetic bag. I have enough room to put a Prolite 4 and a 30 degree down bag with a good 3-4" of loft in it. I think a 5" loft 20 degree bag is about the limit though for room. Not an issue with synthetics.