Topic

Bivy bag advice

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 4:19 am

Hey guys, I have used the search function and have not turned up anything that has really helped me out so far regarding a bivy bag. I am after a storm proof and winter capable bivy bag. I use a synthetic winter sleeping bag however something reasonably roomy is still needed so I don't compress the bag too much. So far this is what I am looking for…

-Waterproof
-Roomy
-Preferably zipper on the left
-Preferably pad straps although not a must.

I am wanting to try my hand at camping with a bivy bag and unfortunately am not located anywhere close to a store where I can try the gear first. My sleeping bags are all left zippered so I am assuming the bivy would be more convenient with a zipper on the left (opinions are welcome here). So far my choices are:

-Integral designs Salathe
-Integral designs South Col
-Integral designs Unishelter (if having a zipper on the opposite side compared to the sleeping bag is not an issue)

I have chosen these bags because they seem to be robust and have a bug screen included. They will all be used with a tarp in bad weather too. Any help is greatly appreciated.

P.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 4:43 am

I'm new here as well but have you considered the REI Minimalist? It seems like a good way to try bivies out without committing a ton of money (may be a bit heavy though). It meets your requirements concerning the zipper and has bug netting. But you'll need that tarp or your rain jacket over your face since it doesn't close up completely.

http://www.rei.com/product/731432

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 4:59 am

A bug net shouldn't be needed in winter.
I would go for Event fabric, as that seems to be the best at handling condensation. Much better than others i've used.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 5:34 am

"They will all be used with a tarp in bad weather too."

Having said that, you might consider a Momentum bivy. I've seen many first time bivy buyers go with a heavier and waterproof bivy only to find that the lighter DWR bivy would have been the answer. A Momentum (DWR) bivy will stop drafts and spindrift from rain or snow, while allowing good breath ability and are a much lighter weight. A popular and low cost first time bivy on this site is the TiGoat Ptarmigan Bivy. I went with the TiGoat for my first bivy, then went to an MLD Soul Sidezip later on. I use it on it's own, but in inclement weather use it with a tarp. If you do go with a waterproof version, eVent is the way to go… but don't think that it will be the answer, without a tarp, in a heavy rain situation.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 5:48 am

The Black Diamond Winter Bivy is reviewed under "Reader Reviews".

http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/reviews/display_reviews.html?forum_thread_id=4730

NB general comments about what to look out for in a bivy for winter use.

I know a story of a woman climber who was buried by an avalanche in Huntington Ravine on Mt. Washington, NH. Dug herself out. Climbed up higher, spent the night with 75 mph winds, but survived because she had packed a bivy as emergency gear. She had a head lamp, too, which helped.

When I day hike in winter, I make sure to carry a bivy and a head lamp.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 7:12 am

Having used an eVent ID South Col and Bugaboo and BD Winter bivy, my favorite is the WT eVent bivy.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 10:20 am

I will need a bug net as it will still be used in the summer and the mozzies here can be pretty thirsty. Also, I am looking for the most water proof fabric that can breathe so I guess I will be limited to the event fabric. Can anyone comment on wether the zipper being on the different side to that of the sleeping bag will be much of a problem? Thanks again.

P.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 10:50 am

an OR Deluxe Bivy i bought a number of years ago and still love it. I think they make a new model called the advanced bivy that's the new comparable model and both have bug screens. The only concern you might have is it's a front zip design.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 2:09 pm

Yep – sorry.

FYI – I was quite unimpressed with the BD winter bivy, eVent is much more breathable and W/P.

if the Montbell cover is as breathable as eVent/paclite – that is what I would get as a UL bivy.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 4:07 pm

I would die in a waterproof bivy in the summer. Death by sweating. Not a pretty sight.

In my experience — actually, my partner's experience, since he's the one who tried them all — his Goretex bivy is pretty hot above freezing. He tried an Epic bivy in moderate weather (around freezing) and got soaked. My homemade Momentum bivy has *never* had any condensation, in any weather conditions from mid-teens through mid-50s. (In summer I use a tarp tent.)

I haven't tried an eVent bivy, though I expect it will be somewhere in the middle.

PostedOct 21, 2009 at 2:22 am

Thanks for that Ken. So far I have only heard good things about event. I am aware that it comes in in different thicknesses (2 layer and 3 layer) so I guess if condensation is an issue then a bivy in 2 layer would be the better bet.

Can anyone set me straight on wether the a right zipper bivy with a left zipper sleeping bag would be an issue?

P.

PostedOct 21, 2009 at 5:45 am

Before making the change to quilts I used right sided zippered bags with a left sided zipped bivy. Where a difference would come in is if the bivy had a long zip, mine doesn't. In my case it meant entering from the top since the short zipper was for expanding the opening to make entry and exit easier only. If the bivy has a long zipper, and you plan to enter and exit from the side, then having it on the same side as the bag's zipper would be helpful/convenient… but not absolutely necessary.

PostedOct 21, 2009 at 12:40 pm

Cheers John. I am thinking it will be an inconvenience, especially if it is wet on the ground as the bag has the opportunity to open free from the bivy and touch the ground. This kind of limits the choice to the South Col and the Salathe as these can be hand with a left side zipper. I am avoiding the top opening bivy bags as I don't want to go through gymnastics getting in and out. Is there any other bivy bag that has a side open zip that has the option of being on the left? Thanks.

P.

Ron Bell / MLD BPL Member
PostedOct 21, 2009 at 4:28 pm

Hi

We are down well under 4 weeks (and getting shorter time every week) with some stuff on the shelf ready to go – a customer called today and we had the right bivy and shelter ready to go!

In general:
Small stuff 0-2 weeks
Tarps and shelters 1-3 weeks
Packs 4 weeks

Peace,
Ron

PostedOct 21, 2009 at 5:42 pm

I can personally vouch for the ID Salathe. Its heavier than many other bivy designs but I trust this bivy under all but the most extreme weather conditions. What I like is that it is easy to get into and can be used with a right or left zip sleeping bag since it zips 32" open on both sides. You can't vent it as much as you want or close it up as much as you want. I've never really had condensation issues. I've only had condensation issues in temps well below freezing when I have closed up the bivy nearly all the way. That's to be expected. I had a 40 degree bag that I was squeezing every degree of temperature out of to stay warm. It was a true bivuoac situation.

I use mine high up in the Colorado Rockies on climbing trips. Sometimes I bivuoac high up at near 13,000 feet when I'm going to be climbing multiple peaks the next day. Its a great option. I use it as my primary shelter and don't bother with tents anymore. I do bring a poncho/tarp but don't bother to set it up 90% of the time because I trust this thing so much. I don't think a lot of the really lightweight shelters used by many would hold up in the conditions I use the Salathe in. I have dealt with horrific winds and frightening thunderstorms way up high very farm from treeline at the base of 13,000 and 14,000 foot mountains.

It is a very robust and versatile bivy sack. I really can't say I regret buying it. I just can't think of a single bivy sack on the market that does what my Salathe does without costing a fortune. I got mine on sale at REI for a very good price a couple years ago. If money was not a factor I would probably have got maybe a Black Diamond Bipod or ID eVent Unishelter. I don't have that kind of money so went with the Salathe. Like I said, sure it might be heavier than a lot of bivy sacks but I just don't see many of the ultralight shelter systems holding up in the conditions I use the Salathe in. It is designed for climbing and suriving brutal mountain weather.

It would work fine with a synthetic cold weather bag. It doesn't work so well with high lofting down sleeping bags and feel that anything warmer than a 20 degree down bag would be pushing it for chest girth. I mainly use 30 and 40 degree down bags with this but since synthetics don't loft up as much as down bags and have stiffer insulation it should work fine with a cold weather synthetic bag. I have enough room to put a Prolite 4 and a 30 degree down bag with a good 3-4" of loft in it. I think a 5" loft 20 degree bag is about the limit though for room. Not an issue with synthetics.

Jason Brinkman BPL Member
PostedOct 21, 2009 at 10:05 pm

I use an ID eVent Unishelter (right zip) with a Marmot Hydrogen (left zip) all the time. It's not any problem for me because the bivy zipper is plenty long and the bag zipper is pretty short. Would not be ideal in a downpour, but that can be mitigated – either wait it out, camp under a tree, move quick, use a tarp, something.

For the record I do not use a tarp with the Unishelter – it's very stormproof on it's own. I do however bring a black plastic garbage sack to waterproof my pack and boots at night, and I primarily hike in a relatively dry mountain climate.

PostedOct 22, 2009 at 12:34 am

"I have an MLD Soul Sidezip bivy. It can be made in either momentum or eVent. You could even have 0.6oz cuben fiber for the underside, if you wanted that. This, to me, is one of, if not THE, best bivy's made. Zipper side is optional and loaded with other features, too."

What he said.

I've been very happy with my MLD bivy, and have used it both summer and winter, and haven't had any issues with compression of a winter sleeping bag.
I probably wouldn't use it without some other kind of cover such as a tarp, etc., but it's very breathable, and keeps me dry when wind blown water is an issue, such as in a leanto.

PostedOct 22, 2009 at 7:09 am

Chris, have you found the Salathe leaking with the orientation of the zippers? We sometimes get heavy showers here that can catch you off guard. I don't mind the weight so much as a good sleep system is one of the things I won't count ounces with. Seeing that you have a great deal of experience with this bag I will probably have a few more questions…

I like the look of the MLD Soul bivy except to get it similar to the South Col (side zipper and Evenet) will bring it over my budget to a substantial degree. That is the price of hand made, good quality equipment I guess. Thanks.

P.

PostedOct 22, 2009 at 1:00 pm

I'm a big fan of it for a number of reasons – first of all the C-shaped zip is easy to enter and to leave – I was also impressed how well it seals out rain – I seem to have the easyist time adjusting it so that I can breath out of it.
100% event, so I just use it like a cover and put my mat down on the ground below, reduces wear and tear.
Quite light, and the mesh is removable.

There are a few things I dont like about it, it could be lighter, and I might do away with the mesh entirely, and that would allow me to use waterproof zippers that did not separate – but overall? I really like it.

I do feel that while you can buy one bivy for 70-80% of all times you would want a bivy that it is hard to buy for 100%. I would like a UL bivy, I would also like a two-person bivy, one for car camping, and one for alpine climbing/ski trips.
But this one works for a good 80% of my uses YMMV.

PostedOct 25, 2009 at 1:43 am

Robert, do you have any pictures of your Wild Things bivy? I have searched the net for more detailed photos but have not come across any. I just want to see how the zipper configuration works as I have to make my choice pretty soon. Thanks again.

P.

Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
Loading...