Topic

Tarptents for the tall?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
PostedOct 19, 2009 at 10:19 pm

I'm looking for a lightweight shelter and am tall (6'3"), which aren't necessarily synergistic. I've been eyeing the Double Rainbow and Scarp 2 but am not sure I'll fit with a long bag. Any other tarptent owners out there 6'3" or over?

Thanks,
Chris

PostedOct 19, 2009 at 10:32 pm

Mountain Laurel Designs has a new Solo Mid coming out that is 9 feet in length. There is to be an inner tent that will be available as well.

Having said that, you will fit into a Rainbow without issue (and room to spare even with a higher loft 'long' bag).

PostedOct 19, 2009 at 11:06 pm

You will provably get conflicting opinions, but here is how you can help yourself…
You will find the exact size of the Tarptents in the "cutaway dimensions" link on each product page.
For example this is the Scarp 2 :
http://www.tarptent.com/scarp2_2.html

Next you get some masking tape and bits of string and you build your own mock up.
The Scarp 2 is really easy because the floor is boxed shaped , no funny angles/tapering to take into account.
Scarp 1 floorpplan

This is my version of the Scarp 1, and if I remember correctly the length of the mat plus the pillow is 6'3".
Note the bits of string that give the "roof line…"

To contrast that , here is another shelter that was discussed in another forum.
Maybe not
The mat this time is 168cm (66") .
Since it is the floorplan of a single wall tent , it took me about 10 min to figure out if I would fit in it or not…
Franco

Brett Peugh BPL Member
PostedOct 19, 2009 at 11:44 pm

I am 6'5" and fit in a Double Rainbow. Henry has also assured me that I will fit into a Moment when I decide to buy one.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedOct 20, 2009 at 2:31 am

I'm anything but tall; in fact, I'm 5'3" so have the opposite problem from you big folk.

Nevertheless, I really like Franco's idea. It will show you if you're going to be stuck with your face a half-inch from the tent wall in a side-opening tent. This can be important if, like me, you need a nice, thick, cushy air mattress (if you don't need one now, you will when you get older!). It really helps going through this procedure if you have a 2.5" air pad or a 3.5" Exped downmat, which definitely reduces the clearance between you and the tent.

Thanks, Franco, for showing us how to do the mock-up!

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 9:49 am

David and Joe,
I should have been a little more specific in my reasons for looking at the Double Rainbow and Scarp 2. I'm initially looking for a 2 person tent for the wife and I. Needs to have bug protection, hence looking at the tarptents.

Eventually I'll be looking for a solo tent and the Moment definitely piqued my interest. The Mids also look interesting but I don't think I would fit in the DuoMid InnerNet so I'd have to go to a SuperMid. The new Solo Mid sounds interesting. Any idea when that's coming out David?

Chris

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 9:56 am

Six Moons Design – Lunar Duo

Huge tent. Perfect for tall people and more headspace than the Double Rainbow

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 9:57 am

Franco,
That's definitely a good way to simulate the tent. I did something similar to that with furniture to simulate the Double Rainbow's with and length. What I wasn't sure of was if the head or foot of my bag could touch the silnylon or if there is mesh that would prevent that. I know there are mesh walls on the Scarp 2.

Chris

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 10:14 am

Hi Christopher – I have been told by Ron that the Solo Mid should be making an appearance within a couple of weeks.

With respect to length, there is a couple of things to take into consideration. First, we are longer laying down than standing up. Out spine relaxes, our feet relax. I am 6'1" but laying down relaxed I measure 78". If one is 6'5", you will relax to very close to 82" or so. Would you fit in an 84" long space. Yes, I guess but without much room to move.

Now add a 'long' bag, perhaps a Montbell SS UL Hugger #2. That bag is 84" long fully lofted. So the Rainbow looks good, but the Moment will be too short if you move. That bag fits in the Contrail end to end without any extra room.

Six Moon Designs was to be coming out with a long solo shelter but it has not hit the market yet. Perhaps someone else knows some further information on this shelter.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 4:13 pm

Totally agree with Rene. We own both the Double Rainbow and the Lunar Duo, and greatly prefer the LD for two people. Both are terrific shelters, but the interior room of the LD is much greater.

I am 6-2 and use a long bag, and every Tarptent I have every tried has been plenty long enough.

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 7:32 pm

I've definitely looked at the Lunar Duo. Currently, I don't use trekking poles so I wasn't considering it. That being said, I've thought about using them so I could be convinced. Just seems a little cumbersome especially when scrambling.

Ken,
Is space the only reason for liking the Duo? Are their situation where you use the DR or is it just sitting at home lonely on every trip? Is there mesh at the head and foot of the DR to keep your bag from touching the silnylon while lying down like on the Duo? Lastly, how do they compare in wind shedding?

Thanks all for the responses so far. Much appreciated.

Chris

PostedOct 22, 2009 at 6:25 pm

Chris,

1. Yes, space is the issue. The long side walls in the Double Rainbow slope inward, reducing interior volume. The floor space isn't bad, but we have a hard time sitting up together. The long side walls of the Lunar Duo are vertical, making the usable interior space is substantially larger.

2. The Double Rainbow has turned out to be my favorite solo cold weather shelter. Two doors provide good ventilation and views, and there is plenty of room inside for me and all my gear. The sloping walls don't bother me when I am by myself.

3. Mesh. The DR doesn't really have the same design as the LD with the mesh walls. But it's long enough that I have never had an issue with touching the end walls.

4. Wind stability. Haven't had the Lunar Duo out in bad weather, but my Double Rainbow has been in heavy wind and handled it well. I use my hiking sticks to provide additional support (the DR is designed for this.)

I like both shelters, but when I am hiking with my lovely wife, it's no contest.

PostedOct 24, 2009 at 9:26 pm

Thanks for making my decision that much harder Ken! But seriously, I appreciate you comparison of the two. Our current Sierra Designs tent is similar to the DR in size so I don't think it would be a hard transition. But more space for similar weight does sound tempting… Maybe I should save my self the agonizing and get both ;)

Chris

PostedOct 25, 2009 at 4:11 pm

I'm 6'3" and my TarpTent Squall 2 has length to spare. In fact I'd guess even 6'6" people would have no trouble. I just lent the tent to a friend this weekend who's 6'2" and he remarked how surprisingly long it was. The tent that is.

Doug Wolfe BPL Member
PostedOct 26, 2009 at 6:43 am

Well I'm not as experienced as some of you other guys, but I will say this I bought the appy trails tent an it only weighs like a 11/2 pounds with poles an is a little bigger than a soft ball when stowed its got 4 walls an is labled as a three man but myself an my pack are a comfortable fit. Here's the link http://www.appytrials.com an sam is a good guy who backs his tent!!

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
Loading...