Topic

Golite Ultra 20 or Montbell SS #3 long

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 1:25 am

Well first I must say I'm enjoying the member content (just signed up a couple of hours ago and have been reading, reading, reading). Secondly I must apologize ahead of time if I start rambling. For some reason I do that on forums much more than in person.

Anyway, I've heard that high quality down (specifically 800 fills) tend to not set off allergies like cheap down products do. Since I'm asthmatic my dust allergy can be a big concern and in the past I've suffered through some miserable nights in a USGI surplus down bag while coughing, and wheezing, and being toasty warm. I like the toasty part. I gave that bag away because of what it did to my allergies and asthma and have been searching for a nice synthetic 30 degree bag or quilt. Since then I've learned more about insulation and decided I might try down one more time.

I'm seeing Golite Ultra 20's reasonably cheap and with free shipping these days but I'm leery because, despite the fact they seem to work well for people at +30F their quality control regarding the fill and loft has me wondering if corners were cut elsewhere as well… like in how clean the down is.

Montbell on the other hand touts their down as being hypoallergenic which (I hope) means they probably really clean the allergens off of their down.

Do any of you have any experience or insight you can add to my decision? There has to be someone on here who suffers from a dust allergy that can shed some light on the this. I'd really like to be confident in purchasing the Golite quilt because it's lighter, significantly cheaper at the moment, and with an UL down quilt I think my gear would fit in an ion and that would be really nice.

Hendrik Morkel BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 3:06 am

Larry, welcome to the Forums!

I have a GoLite Ultra 20° and am super happy with it. I do not suffer from any dust allergies or similar, and don’t own a Montbell to compare to, but I feel confident to say that the GoLite quilt is as hypoallergenic as the Montbell. For me it does sound a bit much like marketing talk, to be honest, hypoallergenic.

You always could drive to a store close by and test them both, or, even better, order both home and test them there, and then return the bag/ quilt which you didn’t like. With free shipping and return that shouldn’t be a problem.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 4:17 am

From what I've found so far all down is hypoallergenic – that is it doesn't contain allergens in and of itself. The problem arises when companies don't properly clean their down before putting it in products and leave a bunch of allergens on the down that the goose picked up in the course of living.

I'm really hoping I don't just have some rare allergy to goose down.

EDIT: This site (http://bedding.lifetips.com/cat/59757/allergy-free-bedding-tips/index.html) says it may actually be the feathers that cause people with animal allergies to react to down and not the down itself. Therefore, the better quality the less feathers there are and less allergy flare ups will happen.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 8:38 am

Do dust mites trigger your asthma? An old sleeping bag might be loaded with dust mites and it might be that rather than the down or feathers that's the problem.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 2:00 pm

Yeah, I'm allergic to dust mites and some cats. It's probably something the cats pick up around the house or outside since not all cats effect me.

That's why I'm interested in whether or not Golite uses the cleanest down.

Edited for grammar.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 9:26 pm

I have asthma/allergies (cats, dust, plus assorted other mystery stuff) and own the MB UL SS#3. No problems with allergies at all sleeping in this bag.

PostedOct 19, 2009 at 2:03 am

Thanks for the heads up on the MB bag.

I've arrived at a convenient solution to save a bit on shipping. I ordered the Ultra 20 with free shipping and if it doesn't work out for me then my dad is buying it from me (he wanted one anyway at some point) and I'll order the MB. If the MB doesn't work out then I'm only out the cost of shipping it back. Quit trivial really.

I'll let you guys know how things work out. The Golite should be here either Thursday or Friday.

Edited for spelling.

PostedOct 26, 2009 at 2:10 am

The Ultra 20 came in last week and I've gotten the chance to use it once… with no allergic reaction! I'm planning to take it out again later this week for another trial run.

It was only in the mid 40's so I had it draped very loosely and was nice and cozy. Plus it cut almost 4 pounds out of my base weight meaning it's almost time to retire the old Alice pack. That will be "the day" so to speak.

Now my dad is getting jealous since his old bag still weighs 4 or 5 lbs so I've got to find him one.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...